Thomas P. Fischer v. First Chicago Capital Markets, Inc.Thomas P. Fischer v. First Chicago Capital Markets, Inc.
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Wood
First Chicago Capital Markets, Inc. (FCCM) hired Thomas P. Fischer to serve as a consultant on a new securitization program. When FCCM refused to pay compensation to which Fischer believed he was entitled, Fischer filed this diversity suit, alleging breach of contract and a variety of quasi-contract claims. The district court dismissed Fischer’s complaint for failure to state a claim upon which relief may be granted. For the reasons discussed below, we reverse and remand.
I
Because the district court dismissed under
Tom, as we have discussed, we will determine referral fees on a case by case basis. If the Program is successful, we hope to move from this arrangement to an ongoing consulting arrangement on a fee basis that will be paid by Program participants. The following administrative services will need to be performed going forward: (1) the initial calculation and the ongoing (annual) monitoring of the “average useful life” of assets financed in accordance with federal tax guidelines; (2) the monitoring and implementation of annual updated hospital board of directors’ resolutions ...; (3) the coordination, accumulation and dissemination of information to First Chicago on a quarterly basis; (4) coordination with First Chicago to insure Program effectiveness; and (5) assistance to First Chicago with the marketing of new and/or expanded programs. We are thinking at this time of a sliding fee scale for such services from between 8 basis points per annum and 5 basis points based on the size of the Program, but this agreement will be worked out in the future when both of us know how the Program is workingand the feasibility of continuing our work together.
Between May and December 1995, Fischer performed his obligations under the Agreement. The parties then agreed to extend the hourly fee arrangement to June 1996, and Fischer continued to work on behalf of the Program. During this period, Fischer completed the start-up process and initiated the Program with bond issues totaling $82 million: a $16 million, 20-year bond issue by the St. Francis Healthcare System and a $16 million, 27-year bond issue by ServantCor. At FCCM’s request, Fischer continued to service and market the program from June 1996 through March 1997, despite the fact that his hourly fee arrangement had terminated upon completion of the start-up efforts. As a result of his post-June endeavors, Fischer obtained a lucrative new participant, the Daughters of Charity National Healthcare System, for the Program.
Despite the promising start, the relationship between Fischer and FCCM soured. Beginning in June 1997 (after both Vallrugo and Campbell had left the company), Fischer repeatedly invoiced FCCM for $25,600, his first year’s compensation. Fischer, who believed he was entitled to an annual fee based on the size and dollar amount of the Program’s bond issues, reached this figure by multiplying eight basis points by $82 million, the amount of outstanding bonds in the Program. FCCM eventually responded with a letter dated August 5, 1997, that announced that FCCM was terminating the contract and that it was willing to give Fischer a one-time payment of $16,000, or five basis points times $32 million, but no more. Maintaining that he was entitled to an annual fee for the duration of the bond issues, Fischer rejected the offer and filed suit.
II
Applying Illinois law, which both parties agree governs this case, the district court dismissed Fischer’s suit. The court held that the contested paragraph was not sufficiently definite and certain to be an enforceable contract. Instead, “the final paragraph simply preserved the parties’ positions for future negotiations.” The court also rejected Fischer’s alternative theory of recovery, the doctrine of promissory estoppel. The court found that Fischer was unable to show detrimental reliance separate from the performance that supplied the consideration for the written agreement, as required by Illinois law, and because recovery under a promissory estoppel theory was defeated by the Illinois statute of frauds. Because the district court resolved these issues on a motion to dismiss, our review is de novo. Hentosh v. Herman M. Finch University of Health Sciences/Chicago Medical School, 167 F.3d 1170, 1173 (7th Cir.1999).
On appeal, Fischer concedes that FCCM did not breach the written agreement. He argues, however, that the parties entered into a subsequent oral agreement that entitles him to payment. According to Fischer, both before and after the July 11, 1995 letter, Vallrugo assured him that after the hourly fee arrangement concluded, Fischer was to continue to market and service the Program in exchange for basis points for the life of the St. Francis and ServantCor bonds.
FCCM does not challenge Vallrugo’s authority to bind it. Instead, it argues that the parol evidence rule bars Fischer from introducing evidence of the alleged oral agreement. But the parol evidence rule applies only to agreements made prior to or contemporaneous with the signing of a written contract; it does not bar evidence tending to show later modifications of the contract.
Williams v. Jader Fuel Co.,
944 F.2d 1388, 1394-95 (7th Cir.1991); see also
Barille v. Sears Roebuck & Co.,
289 Ill.App.3d 171, 224 Ill.Dec. 557, 682 N.E.2d 118, 123 (1997);
Vuagniaux v. Korte,
273 Ill.App.3d 305, 210 Ill.Dec. 38, 652 N.E.2d 840, 844 (1995).
Fischer has a significantly larger problem, however, in the form of the statute of frauds. Although the parol evidence rule does not prevent the parties from orally modifying their contract subsequent to its signing, the Illinois statute of frauds precludes enforcement of a services contract that cannot be performed within a year “unless the promise or agreement upon which such action shall be brought, or some memorandum or note thereof, shall be in writing, and signed by the party to be charged therewith.”
Moreover, although Fischer performed his servicing obligations without pay for nine months before FCCM terminated the contract, this partial performance does not take the oral agreement outside of the statute of frauds. Under the partial-performance exception to the statute of frauds, it must be impractical to compensate the performing party for only the value of the partial performance. Prodromos v. Howard Savings Bank, 295 Ill.App.3d 470, 229 Ill.Dec. 718, 692 N.E.2d 707, 712 (1998); see also Monetti 931 F.2d at 1184 (“The partial-performance exception to the statute of frauds is often explained (and its boundaries fixed accordingly) as necessary to protect the reliance of the performing party, so that if he can be made whole by restitution the oral contract will not be enforced.”). Accordingly, the partial performance exception is not applicable to a normal employment contract such as the one here. Prodromos, 692 N.E.2d at 712, citing Mariani v. School Directors of Dist. 40, 154 Ill.App.3d 404, 107 Ill.Dec. 90, 506 N.E.2d 981, 983 (1987). As we explain in a moment, Fischer has an adequate extracontractual remedy under the theory of quantum meruit. Moreover, the partial performance exception is an equitable remedy and therefore is unavailable to Fischer, who seeks only money damages. See Vuagniaux, 210 Ill.Dec. 38, 652 N.E.2d at 844; Dickens v. Quincy College Corp., 245 Ill.App.3d 1055, 185 Ill.Dec. 822, 615 N.E.2d 381, 385 (1993), citing Gibbons v. Stillwell, 149 Ill.App.3d 411, 102 Ill.Dec. 864, 500 N.E.2d 965, 969 (1986). The district court therefore correctly concluded that the alleged oral agreement is unenforceable under the statute of frauds.
As an alternate theory of liability, Fischer argues that he is entitled to recover under the doctrine of promissory estop-pel. To state a claim for promissory es-toppel in Illinois, Fischer must allege: (1) an unambiguous promise; (2) reasonable and justifiable reliance by the party to whom the promise was made; (3) the reliance was expected and foreseeable by the promisor; and (4) the promisee relied upon the promise to her detriment.
A-Abart Elec. Supply, Inc. v. Emerson Elec. Co.,
956 F.2d 1399, 1404 (7th Cir.1992).
The district court believed that Fischer was unable to satisfy the detrimental reliance prong because “the performance which is said to satisfy the requirement of detrimental reliance is the same performance which supplied the consideration for the contract,” precluding an action for promissory estoppel. See Prentice v. UDC Advisory Services, Inc., 271 Ill.App.3d 505, 207 Ill.Dec. 690, 648 N.E.2d 146, 151 (1995) (“Promissory estoppel cannot be based upon a promise which only induces plaintiffs to do that which they were already bound to do.”). We disagree. As we understand Fischer’s allegations, FCCM promised him the annual fee based upon his continuing provision of administrative services over the life of the bonds. That he continued to service and market the program after June 1996—after his hourly compensation agreement ceased—is enough to demonstrate detrimental reliance.
Once again, however, Fischer’s claim ultimately fails, because the district court’s alternate theory for rejecting promissory estoppel—the statute of frauds—was sound. Under Illinois law, the statute of frauds is applicable to a promise claimed to be enforceable by virtue of the doctrine of promissory estoppel. Architectural Metal Systems, Inc. v. Consolidated Systems, Inc., 58 F.3d 1227, 1231 (7th Cir.1995), citing First Nat. Bank v. McBride, 267 Ill.App.3d 367, 204 Ill.Dec. 676, 642 N.E.2d 138, 142 (1994), and Dickens, 615 N.E.2d at 386. The fact that Fischer cannot perform the promised services within one year precludes recovery under a promissory estoppel theory.
Even though the two theories under which Fischer might have received, in essence, a full loaf were properly rejected, Fischer is not entirely out of luck. The nonenforceability of the alleged oral agreement under either traditional contract principles or the doctrine of promissory estoppel leaves open the possibility of recovering, in a sense, half a loaf (or more accurately much less than half a loaf), under quantum meruit, a form of restitution. See Monetti, 931 F.2d at 1183. Count II of Fischer’s complaint specifically requests “[a]n amount to fairly compensate him for his services based upon the time and skill involved, and the amount [by which] FCCM has been unjustly benefited and enriched.” Although Fischer did not make specific reference to this theory in his briefs on appeal, his general argument is that the complaint stated claims on which relief could be granted, which in this one respect is correct. Furthermore, FCCM did not argue waiver. Because our review is plenary, and because Fischer does argue that FCCM knowingly accepted his services without paying for them, we are satisfied that Fischer has not forfeited this point.
To be successful on a
quantum meruit
theory under Illinois law, Fischer must prove (1) performance of services, (2) the reasonable value
of
the services, and (3) the receipt by the defendant from the plaintiff of a benefit which it would be unjust to retain without paying compensation.
North American Lighting, Inc. v. Hopkins Mfg. Corp.,
37 F.3d 1253, 1259 (7th Cir.1994), citing
Van C. Argiris & Co. v. FMC Corp.,
144 Ill.App.3d 750, 98 Ill.
As a final note, we mention the possibility that, should Fischer prevail in the end, it is at least possible that he may recover less than the $75,000 required to confer federal diversity jurisdiction.
For the foregoing reasons, we Reveese and REMAND for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.