Thomas F. Smith, Jr. v. Cumberland School CommitteeThomas F. Smith, Jr. v. Cumberland School Committee
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Campbell
This is an appeal from an award of attorneys’ fees in an action brought to secure a free appropriate public education for a handicapped child. Plaintiff Thomas F. Smith, III is a handicapped child suffering from cerebral palsy and a variety of physical and emotional handicaps. Since December 1974 he has been enrolled in the Day Hospital Program at Emma Pendelton Bradley Hospital, which all parties agree provides him with an appropriate education. The Cumberland School Committee, Thomas’s local education agency,
On November 26, 1976 plaintiffs commenced the present action in the United States District Court for the District of Rhode Island. The complaint as amended charged the Cumberland School Committee with violating the fourteenth amendment to the Constitution, the Education for All Handicapped Children Act (EAHCA),
On December 22, 1978 the district court decided that the controversy before it might be resolved by a determination as to which agency was responsible under Rhode Island law for Thomas’s education. Accordingly it certified this issue to the Rhode Island Supreme Court, 2 which ruled that the school committee, and not the MHRH, was responsible under state law for paying for Thomas’s education. Smith v. Cumberland School Committee, R.I., 415 A.2d 168 (1980). The Rhode Island Supreme Court stated that a contrary result risked placing the state’s law in conflict with the federal EAHCA.
After the Rhode Island Supreme Court rendered its decision, the district court found that plaintiffs won all they sought under state law and granted a permanent injunction. Federal statutory and constitutional issues were not reached. We affirmed the district court’s judgment in an unpublished decision.
Plaintiffs then sought attorneys’ fees. An agreement was reached with the school committee whereby the committee paid $8,000 in attorneys’ fees for the costs plaintiffs incurred in securing the preliminary injunction and arguing before the school committee. The district court decided the question of attorneys’ fees with regard to the other defendants. The district court, relying on its decision in
Turillo v. Tyson,
535 F.Supp. 577 (D.R.I.1982), found that plaintiffs were entitled to fees under
Appellants raise three issues on appeal. First, they argue that neither
*7
A.
Under what is labelled the American Rule, attorneys’ fees are only available as a general matter when statutory authority so provides. Alyeska Pipeline Service Co. v. Wilderness Society, 421 U.S. 240, 95 S.Ct. 1612, 44 L.Ed.2d 141 (1975). Since the narrow exceptions under the American Rule are not applicable here, our task is to determine whether or not there is statutory authority for awarding attorneys’ fees in the present case.
This action and the relief granted fall within the parameters of EAHCA, a federal statute which establishes a comprehensive federal-state scheme for the provision of special education to handicapped children. The complaint alleged that the school committee’s refusal to fund Thomas’s placement at Bradley denied him a free appropriate public education as defined by the EAHCA.
Yet while EAHCA provides expressly for the bringing of private enforcement actions such as this one,
But even if plaintiffs’
Support for our view is found in the Supreme Court’s recent discussion of
This principle precludes
This is not to say that the EAHCA in any way limits the substantive scope of a handicapped child’s constitutional rights. Should a handicapped child have a constitutional claim that is not provided for by the EAHCA,
B. The Rehabilitation Act
This district court also found that attorneys’ fees were available under section 505 of the Rehabilitation Act,
The existence of any private action under section 504 is in doubt. Several circuits have implied such a right,
e.g., United Handicapped Federation v. Andre,
622 F.2d 342;
Coleman v. Darden,
595 F.2d 533, 538 (10th Cir.),
cert. denied,
444 U.S. 927, 100 S.Ct. 267, 62 L.Ed.2d 184 (1979);
Kampmeier v. Nyquist,
553 F.2d 296 (2d Cir.1977), but recent Supreme Court dicta suggests otherwise.
Pennhurst State School and Hospital v. Halderman,
451 U.S. 1, 27, 101 S.Ct. 1531, 1545, 67 L.Ed.2d 694 (1981). We need not resolve the question, however. Even if there is generally a private right of action under section 504, we hold that attorneys’ fees are unavailable here under the accompanying fees provision.
We reach this conclusion for substantially the same reasons that we reject an attorneys’ fees award under
Reversed.
Notes
. The original complaint only charged that the school committee violated the Constitution by refusing to fund Thomas’s education at Bradley pending administrative review of the committee’s decision. In May 1978 the complaint was amended to include claims under the newly
*6
effective EAHCA,
. Two questions were certified concerning the construction and interaction of
. To the extent plaintiffs’ securing of a preliminary injunction fell outside any relief available under EAHCA, the attorneys’ fees relative thereto might be reimbursable on such a theory. See Hymes v. Harnett County Board of Education, 664 F.2d at 410. We need not decide this question, however, because plaintiffs received attorneys’ fees from the Cumberland School Committee for the work done obtaining the preliminary injunction, and those fees are not on appeal.
. Section 504 states:
No other qualified handicapped individual in the United States, as defined in section 706(7) of this title, shall, solely by reason of his handicap, be excluded from the participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance or under any program or activity conducted by any Executive agency or by the
United States Postal Service. The head of each such agency shall promulgate such regulations as may be necessary to carry out the amendments to this section made by the Rehabilitation, Comprehensive Services, and Developmental Disabilities Act of 1978. Copies of any proposed regulations shall be submitted to appropriate authorizing committees of the Congress, and such regulation may take effect no earlier than the thirtieth day after the date on which such regulation is so submitted to such committee.
. Regulations promulgated under section 504 by the Secretary of Education require school boards to provide handicapped children with a free appropriate public education. 34 C.F.R. 104.34. Compliance with the EAHCA is deemed to satisfy the Rehabilitation Act regulation.