94 F. 365 | N.D. Ill. | 1899
The facts in this case are as follows; The steamer Puritan was during the navigation season of 1895 operated by petitioners, its owners, upon Lake Michigan and adjoining waters. Upon different voyages during the months of August and {September of that year coal was furnished to said steamer by the O. 8. Richardson Fueling Company, claimant herein. The la.st delivery of coal by claimant was on September 28, 1895, subsequent to which date the steamer made no voyage. On November 20, 1895, petitioners paid claimant $250 on account of the sum due for coal furnished as aforesaid, leaving a balance of $1,071.03. On December 31, 1895, the steamer was burned at Manistee, where it was put up for the winter, without fault of any one, so far as this record shows. On March 17, 1898, said claimant commenced a suit in the circuit court of Cook county, 111., against petitioners, for the collection of the aforesaid balance of account On April 9, 1898, petitioners filed their petition herein to limit their liability under the act of congress of June 26, 1884 (23 Stat. 53), in which they offer to surrender the remains of said steamer, alleged to be lying at the bottom of the lake at Manis-tee, and ask that said claimant be restrained from the further prosecution of the aforesaid suit in the Cook county circuit court.
The question for decision in this case is, can vessel owners, under the said act, avoid personal liability for indebtedness incurred oh behalf of the vessel for an indefinite number of preceding voyages, or does the act only cover liabilities incurred during the last voyage, allowing a reasonable time after knowledge of such lia