The People v. WolfThe People v. Wolf
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Duncan
delivered the opinion of the court:
Plaintiff in error, Ulysses S. Wolf, was tried and convicted of arson by a jury in the circuit court of Clay county. Motions for a new trial and in arrest of judgment were overruled.
The first count of the indictment charges that Wolf on the 5th day of July, 1926, “unlawfully, feloniously, willfully and maliciously did set fire to and burn a certain barn of one Everett Steele.” The second count charges that Wolf on said date “unlawfully and feloniously, willfully and maliciously, did set fire to and cause to be burned a certain building, to-wit, a barn of one Everett Steele.” Plaintiff in error contends that the indictment is defective in that it does not allege that the barn burned was the property of Everett Steele or of anyone else. Section 19 of division x of the Criminal Code provides that in an indictment for arson, “if the building was occupied, it shall be sufficient to allege the building to be the property of the owner, lessee or occupant thereof; if unoccupied, to allege simply that such building was at such time unoccupied, giving a description thereof in general terms.” One meaning of the word “of” given in Webster’s New International Dictionary is, “belonging to.” The plain meaning of the words “a barn of one Everett Steele,” is that it is a barn belonging to or the property of Everett Steele. This is the view that has been adopted in other jurisdictions where the question has arisen. (5 Corpus Juris, 564.) The court did not err in overruling the motion to quash the indictment.
At the time the barn burned, Everett Steele lived about three miles north of Louisville, in Clay county, in a house located about one-half mile east of State hard-surfaced highway No. 25, which runs north and south. Plis house was located on the south side of a highway running east and west and intersecting with State highway No. 25. His barn was located about 75 feet east of his dwelling. On the north side of this highway running east and west, in a northeasterly direction from Steele’s house and barn, was the dwelling house of plaintiff in error, Wolf. Wolf’s house
About one o’clock in the morning of July 5 John Galoway and his wife, Reuben Bateman, Roy Murray and Leona Householder were driving south on State highway No. 25, north of Louisville, in an automobile. They had been visiting in Mansfield, Illinois, and were returning to their homes in Olney, Illinois. When several miles north of Steele’s place they saw the glow of a fire. Murray and Bateman were riding in the front seat and Galoway and his wife and Miss Householder were in the rear seat. As they slowed down at the intersection of the highway running by Steele’s house with State highway No. 25, according to Bateman, a car passed them going north on the State highway. At this intersection Galoway and those with him turned east and
As soon as his car stopped Murray got out and went to Steele’s house. He knocked on the front door and tried to get in through a window. Pie then went around to the back door, which he found standing open. The house was full of smoke. Two other men then came up, and the three went into the house and found bedding against the west window, with a mattress and some chairs against it, and a straw bed up against the front door. These things were all on fire and the men drew water and put out the fire.
Mrs. Galoway and Miss Householder did not get out of the car. They both testified that at the time their car stopped they saw a man on the east side of Wolf’s house carrying a ladder to the house from a garage or barn east of the house. They stated that while they were there in the car other people came up, some of them buttoning their clothes as they came.
Edward Cogswell, the sheriff, arrived at Steele’s premises about daylight on the morning of the fire. His deputy, Audley Jackson, arrived there about three o’clock. Both of them testified that when they got to Steele’s house there was a feather bed propped against the west window, a rocking chair
Jackson, the deputy sheriff, testified that from Wolf’s place he went back to Steele’s house, where he met Charles ICanatzer, from St. Elmo, and he and Kanatzer went out back of Steele’s barn about 20 feet to a wire fence and found a place where the wire had been mashed down, and the marks showed that somebody had gone over the fence. The}‘- followed these prints in the grass and dew to a post south of the well and then directly north to the wire fence across the road and south of Wolf’s house, and there was some buck brush in the fence and the brush showed it had been disturbed. The wire there was mashed down, and from this brush a man’s tracks led across the road a little bit northeast to a point between the public highway and the driveway at Wolf’s house. There the ground was so hard they could not tell which way the tracks went from that point. The tracks were made by a shoe with a narrow last, and looked to be about a No. 7. He stated that he made a comparison of the tracks they followed with others around Wolf’s place that were made by Wolf. Pie said the tracks which he knew to be Wolf’s tracks were made by a narrow shoe, size about No. 7. He also saw tracks in the road west of those he followed from Steele’s place, but those tracks were made by people walking angling across the road, more in an east and west than a north and south direction, and were of various sizes. On cross-examination
Kanatzer testified for the People that he operated a detective agency in St. Elmo. He was called by the sheriff and arrived at Steele’s premises about daylight. In Steele’s dwelling he found bedding against the west window and front door that had been on fire. He looked at the tracks about the premises. East of the barn he found where the fence had been pressed down and someone had climbed over it. From this place he followed tracks in the grass and dew leading in a northeasterly direction. The tracks were located by dirt left on the dewy grass by shoes. This witness said: “Following the tracks up the incline you could distinguish something had gone through it. Couldn’t tell whether it was a hog, a cow or a horse, but about one-half way up we could tell it was shoe tracks, and at the fence the wire was pushed down, and you could tell from the print made at the fence row that shoes had made those where they had stepped on the buck brush and pushed them apart, and from there just about two of the steps were made and they’ stepped out in the road. The first two tracks you couldn’t get a measurement but the next possibly three steps as I found them I put a mark around them. I cut a stick and with it measured the length and breadth across the ball of the foot. I measured the heel both ways. I couldn’t tell whether it was a rubber heel or not The tracks went into where the little grass plot was in front of the yard at Wolf’s house.” Witness went to the Wolf premises and asked Wolf if there were any strangers there during the night, to which Wolf replied “Yes.” Witness then asked if any of them had been across the pasture, and Wolf replied, “I haven’t, and I really don’t know whether they were or not.” He said that he had not been over to the fire but that the strangers
Plaintiff in error did not testify and there is no conflict in the testimony as above set forth. To all of the evidence concerning the fire in Steele’s dwelling house and the condition of its contents plaintiff in error objected. He contends that the court erred in overruling his objections. The purpose of this evidence was to show that the burning of the barn was caused by human agency, or, in other words, that the fire was of incendiary .origin. The fire in the house and the fire in the barn occurred at the same time. The conditions in the house were such as to indicate clearly that the fire there was of an incendiary nature, and therefore also tended to prove that the barn had been set on fire. The rule as stated in 16 Corpus Juris at page 594 is, that evidence of other fires is admissible when it tends to show that they, with the fire in question, were part of one connected scheme or purpose of defendant, or when it tends to show that the fire in question was of incendiary origin. In State v. Thompson, 97 N. C. 496, 1 S. E. 921, where the charge was setting fire to an outhouse, evidence that on the same night when the outhouse was burned there was an attempt to burn the dwelling by means of faggots of wood tied
The evidence objected to was pertinent on the question of the fire in the barn having been started by human agency,- and was therefore properly admitted.
It is also urged that the court erred in allowing evidence of statements made by plaintiff in error to be introduced before the corpus delicti was proved. It is true that proof of the corpus delicti must be made by evidence independent of admissions
When Steele testified concerning the trouble between himself and Wolf he said, “I gave him a whipping, and he had me arrested for assault and battery and disturbing the peace, and I beat him in both cases.” When Cogswell, the ex-sheriff, was testifying and was asked about the trouble, he said: “There was a warrant sworn out for Wolf and placed in my hands — I meant for Mr. Steele and placed in my hands. I arrested him. ITe gave bond. We had a trial here and Mr. Steele came clear.” On motion this testimony of Cogswell was stricken and the jury instructed to disregard it. No motion was made to strike the statement of Steele above set forth, but the question that brought it forth was objected to and the objection overruled. It is contended that the court erred in allowing the evidence of the outcome of the cases in which Steele was charged with assault and battery and disturbing the peace to go to the jury. It is always proper in a criminal case to prove motive. (People v. Looney, 324 Ill. 375.) The evidence of ill-feeling, unfriendly relations and trouble between plaintiff in error and Steele was proper for this purpose and also as tending to show malice on the part of plaintiff in error toward Steele. Proof of the outcome of the cases in which Wolfe had charged Steele with assault and battery and disturbing the peace added nothing to the evidence in that respect. The court struck out Cogswell’s evidence on that point and instructed the jury to disregard it. Had the motion been made the court would, doubtless, have stricken that part of Steele’s testimony referring to the outcome of those trials.
In his testimony Kanatzer stated that when he had followed the trail from the barn across the pasture to Wolf’s place he asked Wolf if he might come in. Wolf asked him to come in and he went into the yard. Wolf asked him what kind of dogs were the ones he had, and witness replied, “Blood-hounds.” Wolf then said that they were . mighty nice dogs. No objection was made to this evidence and no motion was made to strike it, and yet plaintiff in error contends the judgment should be reversed because this reference to blood-hounds appears in the evidence of the witness. The law is, as stated by plaintiff in error and as laid down in People v. Pfanschmidt, 262 Ill. 411, that testimony of the trailing of either man or animal by a bloodhound should never be admitted in evidence in any case. There is nothing in this case that violates that principle. Here the only reference to blood-hounds is the one above mentioned. There is no evidence or offer of evidence that they followed any trail.
Plaintiff in error objected to Jackson and Kanatzer testifying because their names were not indorsed on the indictment. After the State’s attorney had furnished counsel for plaintiff in error with a statement of what he expected to prove by each of these witnesses the court allowed them to testify. It is within the discretion of the court to allow witnesses whose names are not indorsed on the back of the indictment to testify, and the exercise of that discretion will not be reviewed unless it appears that the defendant has been taken by surprise. People v. Weil, 243 Ill. 208; People v. Williams, 240 id. 633.
It is urged by plaintiff in error that the court erred in giving to the jury, for the People, improper and erroneous instructions, in refusing to give proper instructions offered by the defendant, and in modifying certain instructions offered
Plaintiff in error also contends that the judgment should be reversed on the facts. In this connection it is urged that there is not sufficient proof of the corpus delicti. The proof in that regard is certainly as strong and satisfactory in this case as was the proof in the cases of Carlton v. People, supra, and People v. Hannibal, 259 Ill. 512, where judgments of conviction for the crime of arson were affirmed. In People v. Callahan, 324 Ill. 101, this court said: “Often the facts and circumstances from which the corpus delicti is proved are those which connect the accused with the commission of the offense. There is no invariable rule as to the quantum of proof necessary to establish the corpus delicti. Each case must depend, in a measure, upon its own particular circumstances.” It is seldom that the crime of arson can be established by direct and positive testimony of witnesses who actually saw the fire set. The inference of guilt must be drawn in most cases from circumstances satisfactorily proved. A court of review should not disturb the verdict of a jury unless the verdict appears to have been the result of passion or prejudice or unless the evidence is so unreasonable, improbable or unsatisfactory as to warrant a reasonable doubt of guilt. (People v. Hicketts, 324 Ill. 170.) After an examination of the record in this case we are satisfied that the verdict is supported by the evidence and that there is no reasonable doubt of defendant’s guilt.
The judgment of the circuit court is affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.