The People v. SmithThe People v. Smith
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Farmer
delivered the opinion of the court:
Clinton Smith, plaintiff in error, (hereafter called defendant,) was indicted by the grand jury of Coles county for feloniously, willfully and maliciously damaging the residence occupied by Charles C. Lee and family in Charleston, Coles county, Saturday night, May 10, 1924, by means of dynamite or some explosive the name of which was to the grand jurors unknown. He was tried, convicted and sentenced to the penitentiary and has sued out this writ of error.
Charles C. Lee is a lawyer residing in Charleston, Coles county. He had some time prior to the damage to his residence, as an attorney for Joe Rogers, secured a judgment against Smith for $6000 for alienating Rogers’ wife’s affections and had collected the judgment. The night of May 10, Lee, a little girl he had adopted, and a niece, were occupying the residence. About 12 ¡25 A. M. he and the other occupants of the house were aroused by a loud explosion, which tore away porches, cracked and broke stone, broke windows, and damaged the brick walls and plastering of the building. None of the family were injured. He found a hole under the porch floor about two and one-half feet deep and a hole in the sitting room wall about a foot in diameter. All together the house was pretty badly damaged. It was heavily shaded by trees and there was no light at that street intersection. Lee had -no idea who had exploded the bomb and did not think it was intended for him. He said it
“Mr. C. C. Lee — There was no mistaken identity. We tried to kill your wife and girl. We watched you in the east room where you read a book until about 9 o’clock. We still expect to get revenge. If your wife ever comes back we will kill or cripple her and the girl and then in a few years we will kill you, you blackhearted thief. Give this to some detective or P. O. inspector but you will see your family die just the same.
“To kill you outright would let you off to easy.
“You must pay the price.”
A few days after Lee received the letter he saw defendant on a street in Charleston. Defendant called Lee, who stopped and defendant came up, facing him. Lee testified defendant said: “I want to know if you are going to pay me my money back; if you don’t I am going to collect in blood.” Witness said, “That is what you were trying to do when you bombed my house, was it?” Defendant said, “Don’t you accuse me of doing that or I will smash you.” Witness said, “No, you won’t smash me; you are the one who is going to get smashed; a man can’t do what you have done and make this kind of talk and not get into trouble and plenty of it.” Defendant said, “I will have my money back or I will collect in blood.” Witness said: “I will pay you nothing; I don’t owe you anything; I never did do anything to you but what I had a legal right to do.” Defendant said: “Oh, yes, you did; you all went into a conspiracy against me and bought Charlie Jones on the jury.” Witness said, “You are talking foolish talk like a school boy; you know I didn’t do a thing like that in my life.” Defendant said, “Well, you will pay me my money back or I will collect in blood,” and then turned and went away. Lee said he came fast and went away fast; that when he got between the cars, as he was going away, he turned his head around and said, “You remember, I am going to have my money back or collect in blood.” Lee said, “You will get
The evidence abundantly shows Lee’s house was wrecked by the explosion of dynamite under one of the porches. Wiley, the deputy sheriff who arrested defendant, said he had a talk with him that night and asked him where the dynamite was, and he said it was in the hog house. Later in the night the witness went to defendant’s house and secured a small pine box containing dynamite. It was overhead in a building, but the witness did not know whether it was a hog house or not. He found fuses in another place, wrapped in a piece of paper, and found caps in another place. There were eight sticks and one part of a stick of dynamite. There were about twenty-five or thirty feet of fuse and four or five caps. The witness testified he had had experience with dynamite, and that the fuse would take forty or fifty seconds to burn a foot. A. J. Pleshner, a mine engineer of eighteen or twenty years’ experience with dynamite, examined the fuse, caps and dynamite found on defendant’s premises and introduced in evidence. He explained the method used in exploding the dynamite, and testified the fuse would burn a foot in from thirty to forty seconds and a yard in from ninety to one hundred twenty seconds. If damp it would burn a little slower. W. J. Williams, supervisor of explosives for the Madison Coal Company, testified to the same effect.
The anonymous letter received by Lee on May 25 was introduced in evidence, together with the envelope in which it was received. The envelope was marked Exhibit A and the letter Exhibit B. It was the theory of the State that
Defendant testified in his own behalf that he was in Charleston the forenoon of May 10. He went home about ten o’clock and returned to Charleston that night. He did not notice the hour when he returned, but the street lights were on when he arrived there. He went home and went to bed, he thought, between eleven and twelve o’clock. He remained at home the balance of the night. He testified to seeing Lee in Charleston afterwards and to having a talk with him. He said he asked Lee if he (Lee) had been telling that witness had dynamited his house. Lee said he didn’t
Ellen Smith, defendant’s mother, testified she and her son lived on a farm. She is seventy years old. They lived about seven miles from Charleston. She was at home Saturday night, May 10, 1924. She awoke that night between eleven and twelve o’clock with a spell of heart trouble and called defendant and had him start a fire. She looked at the clock and it was five minutes after twelve. She told the circumstances of the arrest of defendant the night of June 7. On cross-examination she testified she did not know what time defendant got home the night of May 10. It was getting dark when he left home and witness went to bed about eight o’clock. She did not hear him come in. He would have to pass through her bed-room to go to his bed, but she was asleep and did not hear him. After defendant built the fire for her he went to bed and she did not see him any more that night. She fixed the date by a field meet held May 10. She has heart trouble, and there is not a day that she doesn’t have a spell. She didn’t know before June 7 that her son was accused of dynamiting Lee’s house. Recalled by defendant, she testified that Wiley and Decker came
Ross Hutton testified he farmed land adjoining defendant’s. He saw defendant dynamiting stumps on about an acre of ground on defendant’s farm.
Mrs. J. O. Eubanks testified she saw defendant in the theatre in Charleston Saturday night, May 10. She could not say what time it was. She left the theatre before defendant left it.
J. A. Hutton testified he is a farmer and lives ten miles south of Charleston and about two miles from the house of defendant. He was handed Exhibits 6 to 11 and said he had seen them before, — especially Exhibit 6. He was asked if in his opinion the person who wrote Exhibit 6 wrote the anonymous letter. The People objected on the ground that witness had shown no qualifications better than the jury possessed for answering that question. The objection was sustained. Afterwards, in answer to a question, he testified he could read and write some; that he studied the Spencerian system of writing when he went to school; that he wrote checks; that he never saw defendant write and never saw any writings which defendant admitted to him he had written; that he never made a study of handwriting. He was then asked by defendant’s counsel whether in his opinion the person who wrote Exhibit 6 wrote People’s Exhibits A and B. Counsel for the People objected, and the court inquired of defendant’s counsel whether he thought the witness was qualified to give the jury any assistance, and counsel replied, “There is some question about it, I will admit.” The court ruled the witness was not competent to testify.
It is contended by defendant that the court erred in overruling a motion to quash the indictment; that defendant was overwhelmed by outside counsel representing the People; that witnesses were wrongfully permitted to testify whose names
Counsel who represents defendant in this court did not represent him and was not present at the trial, and many objections argued in defendant’s brief were not preserved for review by objections made during the trial or were not mentioned in the motion for a new trial or are not mentioned in the assignment of errors. In view of that fact we shall not take the time to discuss many of the questions argued in defendant’s brief.
We will first mention the motion to quash the indictment. There is a dispute whether any written motion to quash was ever filed. It was not marked filed by the clerk, but defendant contends, and supports the contention by affidavits,- that a written motion was made, and after it was overruled was deposited with the clerk, and after the trial was found by him in a drawer in his office but had no file-mark on it. It appears from the record that defendant entered a plea of not guilty before any motion to quash the indictment was made and that the plea was never withdrawn. A motion to quash after plea cannot be considered unless leave is obtained to withdraw the plea. (People v. Munday, 280 Ill. 32; McKevitt v. People, 208 id. 460.) While that is true, we have investigated the objections made to the indictment and are convinced the court did not err in overruling the motion to quash. We will therefore not further discuss the objections of defendant to the sufficiency of the indictment.
One of the grounds of the motion for a new trial was that the statute under which defendant was indicted and convicted is unconstitutional. The constitutional provision which the statute is alleged to violate is section 13 of article
During the hearing before the court on the motion to impound the writings, defendant’s counsel objected to them on the ground they were letters from defendant to his lawyers and were privileged communications. The court held that objection was not good, and after the conclusion of the hearing on the motion to impound, made an order, based upon the evidence and the stipulation of the parties, that the writings be impounded with the clerk ‘for the purpose of establishing standards of comparison of writings on the trial of the case.
It is very strongly urged by defendant that the court erred in admitting Exhibits 6 to 11 in evidence on the trial for use as standards of comparison of handwriting. The exhibits were letters written by defendant, before Lee’s house was bombed, to lawyers with whom he had business
Defendant contends that the letters were admitted in violation of the rule that handwriting cannot be proved by a comparison
Hutton, a witness for defendant, did not qualify to express an opinion as to handwriting. Defendant’s counsel, in reply to an inquiry by the court, expressed his doubt as to the witness’ qualification to testify. The court did not err in refusing to permit him to testify.
The criticism of instructions given for the prosecution and the modification and refusal of instructions for defendant is of a highly technical character and without merit. Only nine instructions were given for the People, and instructions in substantially the same language as practically all of them have been approved by decisions of this court. The modification made of defendant’s instructions did not prejudice him, and the instructions refused did not correctly state the law or were covered by other instructions given. Defendant has no just cause of complaint of the court’s action in giving, refusing or modifying instructions.
Two outside counsel assisted the State’s attorney in the prosecution of the case but no objection was made at the trial to their doing so, and that point was not mentioned in the motion for a new trial and is not raised in the assignment of errors. Besides, we have repeatedly held a court may permit counsel employed for that purpose to assist the State’s attorney. People v. Donaldson, 255 Ill. 19; People v. O’Farrell, 247 id. 44; People v. Hartenbower, 283 id. 591.
Defendant claims, but does not argue the point, that the court erred in refusing to permit defendant to state the contents of an anonymous letter he claimed to have received June 7, the day of his arrest. The letter was not produced, and its loss or destruction was not sufficiently proved to permit oral proof of its contents.
No question of the court’s permitting witnesses for the People to testify whose names had not been furnished the defendant is preserved, and there would be no merit in that contention of defendant if it had been preserved.
The record is free from substantial error. The question of defendant’s guilt of the crime was fairly and properly submitted to the determination of the jury. A consideration of the evidence convinces us that a reviewing court would not be justified in reversing the judgment.
The judgment is affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.