The People v. BrunerThe People v. Bruner
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- DeYoung
Lead Opinion
the opinion of the court:
An indictment was returned in the criminal court of Cook county charging Ben Bruner with robbery while armed with a dangerous weapon. A jury found him guilty and he was sentenced to the penitentiary. He prosecutes this writ of error for a review of the record.
Upon the trial, counsel for the plaintiff in error requested the court to give the jury the following instruction: “The court instructs the jury that they, are the judges of the law as well as of the-facts in. the case, and if they can say upon their oaths that they know the law better than the court does, they have a right to do so; but before assuming so solemn a responsibility, they should be assured that they are not acting from caprice or prejudice, that they are not controlled by their wills or their wishes, but from deep and confident conviction that the court is wrong and that they are right. Before saying this upon their oaths, it is their duty to reflect whether, from their study and experience, they are better qualified to judge of the law, than the court; if, under all the circumstances, they are prepared to say that the court is wrong in its exposition of the law, the statute has given them the right.” This instruction was refused, but instead of it, upon the motion of the State’s attorney, the jury were instructed,that: “The jury is the sole judge of the facts in the case, the credibility of the witnesses, and of
The refused instruction was based upon section 11 of division 13 of the Criminal Code (Cahill’s Stat 1929, p. 953; Smith’s-Stat. 1929, p. 1068), which provides that “Juries in all criminal cases shall be judges of the law and the fact.” This statutory provision was originally enacted in 1827 as a part of section 176 of the act entitled “An act relative to criminal jurisprudence” (Laws of 1827, p. 163), and continuously since has been a part of the Criminal Code of this State. The defendant in error justifies the refusal of the first and the giving of the second instruction on the ground that the statute which the plaintiff in error invokes contravenes (a) section 5 of article 2 of the constitution of 1870, that the right of trial by jury as heretofore enjoyed shall remain inviolate, and (b) the third article of the constitution which distributes the powers of the State government among the legislative, executive and judicial departments and prohibits the exercise, except as expressly directed or permitted, by any person or collection of persons constituting one of these departments, of any power properly belonging to either of the other departments. The trial court’s rulings with respect to these instructions form the basis of the only errors assigned and relied upon by the plaintiff in error for a reversal of the judgment.
Limiting our inquiry to the purposes of the present case, it may be stated that under the English common law, the court instructed the jury upon the law and the jury determined the issues of fact. This principle was succinctly expressed by Lord Coke: “Ad qucestionem facti non respondent judices, ad qucestionem juris non respondent juratores.” (Coke on Littleton, 155b). “It was very early provided,” says Forsyth in his History of Trial by Jury, (Morgan’s ed. p. 216), “that the jury should not entangle themselves with questions of law, but confine themselves simply and exclusively to facts.” Likewise, Professor Austin W. Scott, in 31 Harvard Law Review, page 677, observed: “It mar‘safely be said that át the time of the American Revolution the general principle was well
The courts of this country have recognized and applied this principle of the common law and reference to a few of the leading cases may be useful. An indictment for a capital offense was returned in United States v. Battiste, 2 Sumner, 240, and the question was directly presented whether, in criminal cases, juries were the judges of the law as well as of the facts. Judge Story, in rendering judgment, said, at pages 243, 244: “My opinion is that the jury are no more judges of the law in a capital or other criminal case, upon the plea of not guilty, than they are in every civil case, tried upon the general issue. In each of these cases, their verdict, when general, is necessarily compounded of law and of fact; and includes both. In each they must necessarily determine the law, as well as the fact. In each, they have the physical power to disregard the law, as laid down to them by the court. But I deny, that, in any case, civil or criminal, they have the moral right to decide the law according, to their own notions, or pleasure. On the contrary, I hold it the most sacred constitutional right of every party accused of a crime, that the jury should respond as to the facts, and the court as to the law. It is the duty of the court to instruct the jury as to the law; and it is the’ duty of the jury to follow the law, as it is laid down by the court. This is the right of every citizen; and it is his only protection. If the jury were at liberty to settle the law for themselves, the effect would be, not only that the law itself would be most uncertain, from the different views, which different juries might take of it; but in case of error, there would be no remedy or redress by the injured party; for the court would not have any right to review the law as it had been settled by the jury. Indeed, it would be almost impracticable to ascertain, what the law,
The contention was made in United States v. Morris, 1 Curtis, 23, that juries, impaneled in’ the courts of the United States, were the rightful and final judges of the existence, construction and effect of the laws that were material in criminal cases and could of right, and in the performance of their duty necessarily should, decide finally upon the constitutional validity of the acts of Congress which the trials brought in question. In answering this contention, Mr. Justice Curtis said, at page 52: “The sixth article, after declaring that the constitution, laws, and treaties of the United States shall be the supreme law of the land, proceeds, ‘and the judges, in every State, shall be bound thereby.’ But was it not intended that the constitution, laws, and treaties of the United States should be the supreme law in criminal as well as in civil cases ? If a State law should make it penal for an officer of the United States to do what an act of Congress commands him to do, was not the latter to be supreme over the former? And if so, and in such cases, juries finally and rightfully determine the law, and the constitution so means when it speaks of a trial by jury, why was this command laid on the judges alone, who are thus mere advisers of the jury, and may be bound to give sound advice, but have no real power in the matter ? It was evidently the intention of the constitution that all persons engaged in makingj expounding, and executing the laws, not only under the authority of the United States
In the trial of the Seven Bishops, 12 How. St. Tr. 183, and in Rex v. St. Asaph, 3 T. R. 428, the principal issue was whether the jury in a prosecution for criminal libel had the right to return a general verdict, or whether a special verdict concerning only the publication of the alleged libelous matter was required to be rendered, leaving the question whether the matter was libelous to the court for determination. This controversy led to the enactment in the year 1792, by the English Parliament, of Fox’s Libel Bill (St. 32 Geo. III, c. 60), which declared that, in a prosecution for criminal libel the jury had the right to render a general verdict. In United States v. Morris, supra, it-was argued that this act declared that, on trials for criminal libel, the jury should be allowed to pass on the law as well as the facts.
Subsequent to the decision of the foregoing Federal cases, the question was considered by the Supreme Court of the United States, and after an elaborate review of the authorities, both English and American, that court, in Sparf and Hansen v. United States, 156 U. S. 51, Mr. Justice Gray and Mr. Justice Shiras dissenting, decided that, following- the rule and practice at common law, it was the duty of the jury in every criminal case in the courts of the United States to take the law from the court and to apply the law so received to the facts as they found them from the evidence. The court, in the course of its opinion, which
The great preponderance of authority in the courts of the several States likewise denies that by the common law, jurors in criminal cases are the judges of the law. Among these authorities may be cit$d: Pierson v. State, 12 Ala. 149; Batre v. State, 18 id. 119; Washington v. State, 63 id. 135; Pleasant v. State, 13 Ark. 360; Sweeney v. State, 35 id. 585 ; People v. Anderson, 44 Cal. 65; People v. Ivey, 49 id. 56; State v. Icandell, 5 Harr. (Del.) 475 5 Ridenhour v. State, 75 Ga. 382; Danforth v. State, 75 id. 614; State v. Miller, 53 Iowa, 154; State v. Truskett, 85 Kan. 804; Commonwealth v. VanTuyl, 1 Metc. (Ky.) 1; State v. Ford, 37 La. Ann. 443; State v. Hannibal, 37 id. 619; State v. Wright, 53 Me. 328; Commonwealth v. Porter, 10 Mete. (Mass.) 263; Commonwealth v. Anthes, 5 Gray, (Mass.) 185; Commonwealth v. Rock, 10 id. 4; Plamilton v. People, 29 Mich. 173; Williams v. State, 32 Miss. 389, 66 Am. Dec. 615; Hardy v. State, 7 Mo. 607; *State v. Hosmer, 85 id. 553; Parrish v. State, 14 Neb. 60; Pierce v. State, 13 N. H. 536; People v. Pine, 2 Barb. (N. Y.) 566; Carpenter v. People, 8 id. 603; Duffy v. People, 26 N. Y. 588; State v. Drawdy, 48 S. C. L. 87; State v. Sypkrett,
Perhaps the most complete examination of the question, both upon principle and authority, to be found in the decisions of the State courts was made in ‘Commonwealth v. Anthes, supra. In that case, Chief Justice Shaw, speaking for the majority of the court said that, the fundamental-principle of the common law, both in civil and criminal cases, was, that the judges should adjudicate finally upon the whole question of law, and the jury upon the whole question of fact. An extensive examination of the authorities led the court in State v. Wright, 53 Me. 328, to say that the doctrine that the jury are judges of the law as well as the facts in criminal cases is contrary to reason, to the fundamental principles of the common law and to the vast preponderance of judicial authority. Another exhaustive review of the authorities, English and American, was made by the Supreme Court of Vermont, and that court, overruling-State v. Croteau, 23 Vt. 14, and prior decisions in accord with it, said, in State v. Burpee, 65 Vt. 1, at pages 34 and 35 : “We are thus led to the conclusion that the doctrine that jurors are the judges of the law in criminal cases is untenable; .that it is contrary to the fundamental maxims of the common law from which it- is claimed to take its origin; contrary to the uniform practice and decisions of the courts of Great Britain, where our jury system had its beginning and where it matured; contrary to the great weight of authority in this country; contrary to tire spirit and meaning of the constitution of- the United States; repugnaht to the constitution of this State; repugnant to our statute relative to the reservation of questions of law in criminal cases, and passing the same to the Supreme Court for final decision; and, as was said by Walton, J., in State v. Wright, supra, ‘Contrary to reason and fitness, in withdrawing the interpretation of the laws from those who make it the
The foregoing authorities amply show that, by the common la-gr, the jurors in a criminal trial had no right to decide ^any question of law, and that if they rendered a general verdict, their duty and their oath required them to ■ apply to the facts, as they found them, the law as stated by thq court. Section u of division 13 of the Criminal Code, which makes juries in all criminal cases judges of the law as well as the facts, therefore abrogates an essential attribute of the trial of a criminal case by a jury as known to the common law and results in the deprivation of a right which lias been uniformly guaranteed by our successive constitutions.
The statute under review, the defendant in error contends, also violates the third-article of the constitution which provides: “The powers of the government of this State are divided into three distinct departments — the legislative, executive and judicial; and no person, or collection of persons, being one of these departments, shall exercise any power properly belonging to either of the others, except as hereinafter expressly directed or permitted.” By the words “except as hereinafter expressly directed or permitted,” the constitution recognizes certain exceptions to the separation of powers required by the third article. Among these exceptions are section 9 of article 4 which authorizes either house of the General Assembly to imprison persons, not members, who shall be guilty of disorderly or contemptuous behavior in its presence; section 24 of the same article which provides that all impeachments found or returned by the house of representatives shall be tried by the senate, and section 30 of article
Section 1 of article 6 of the constitution vests the judicial powers in a supreme court and certain subordinate courts. The grant of judicial power to the department created for the purpose of exercising it is an exclusive grant and exhausts the whole and entire power. (People v. Smith, 327 Ill. 11; People v. Fisher, 340 id. 250.) The phrase judicial power has been variously defined. Judge Cooley, in his work on Constitutional Limitations, 8th ed. p. 184, defined it as the power which adjudicates upon and. protects the rights and interests of individual citizens, and to that end construes and applies the laws. This definition was quoted with approval in Land Owners v. People, 113 Ill. 296, People v. Chase, 165 id. 527, and People v. Simon, 176 id. 165. To the same effect are: Mitchell v. Lowden, 288 Ill. 327, and Arms v. Ayer; 192 id. 601. Other definitions of judicial power are, in 2 Bouvier’s Law Dictionary, 8th ed., p. 1740, the authority exercised by that department of government which is charged with the declaration of what the law is and its construction so far as it is written law, and in People v. Salsbury, 134 Mich. 537, 546, the power to interpret the constitution and the laws and make decrees determining controversies. Judicial power is exercised for the purpose of giving effect, not to the will of the judge, but to the law. (Osborn v. United States Bank, 9 Wheat. (U. S.) 738). If the power is judicial in its nature, it necessarily follows that the legislature is expressly prohibited from exercising it. In re Day, 181 Ill. 73.
The framers of the constitution sought to promote certainty and uniformity in the interpretation and declaration of the law. To that end they committed the exercise of these judicial functions to the- judicial department. Correct and uniform interpretation of the law are of the first importance to secure stable and orderly government. Mr. Justice Harlan, in delivering the opinion of the court in Sparf and Hansen v. United States, supra, pages 101-103, well said: “Public and private safety alike would be in peril, if the principle be established that juries in criminal cases may, of right, disregard the law as expounded to them by the court and become a law unto themselves. Under such a system, the principal function of the judge would be to preside and keep order while jurymen, untrained in the law, would determine questions affecting life, liberty, or property according to such legal principles as in their judgment were applicable to the particular case being tried. If because, generally speaking, it is the function of the jury to determine the guilt or innocence of the accused according to the evidence, of the truth or weight of which they are to judge, the court should be held bound to instruct them upon a point in respect to which there was no evidence whatever, or to forbear stating what the law is upon a given state of facts, the result would be that the enforcement of the law against criminals and the protection of citizens against unjust and groundless prosecutions, would depend entirely upon juries uncontrolled by any settled, fixed, legal principles. * * * if it be held that the court may not authoritatively decide all questions of law arising in criminal cases — the result will be that when a new trial in a criminal case is ordered, even by this court, the jury, upon such trial, may of right return a verdict based upon the assumption that what this court has adjudged to be the law is -not law. We cannot give our sanction to any rule
To support his contention that the court erred in refusing to give the first and in giving the second instruction, the plaintiff in error relies upon Schnier v. People, 23 Ill. 17; Pisher v. People, 23 id. 283; People v. Mirabella, 294 id. 246; People v. Stephens, 297 id. 91, and People v. Pilewski, 295 id. 58, in each of which it was held that the jury had the right under the statute in question to disregard the court’s instructions; upon Mullinix v. People, 76 Ill. 211; Davison v. People, 90 id. 221, and People v. Campbell, 234 id. 391, which recognized the rule that it was proper to tell the jury that they were bound to act on the law as laid down by the court unless they could say on their oaths that they were better judges of the law than the court; upon People v. Kuchta, 296 Ill. 180, and People v. Manida, 314 id. 536, in which it was held that the jury might be instructed that they were the judges of the law as well as the facts in a criminal case, provided they upon their oaths considered that they knew the law; upon People v. Zurek, 277 Ill. 621, and People v. Karpovich, 288 id. 268, in which it was decided that, because of the statute under review, a
The fact that the statute in question has been construed and applied during a considerable period of time does not necessarily render it immune from constitutional attack. In Neiberger v. McCullough, 253 Ill. 312, Mr. Justice Cartwright, in delivering the opinion of the court, said : “It is true that where a constitutional .provision is doubtful and there is need of interpretation, the practical exposition of it by departments of government called upon to act under it, acquiesced in by the people, especially for a considerable period of time, raises a strong presumption that it is correct and will generally be adopted by the courts. (Nye v. Foreman, 215 Ill. 285; People v. Olson, 245 id. 288; Cook County v. Healy, 222 id. 310). Where, however, the language of the constitution is not ambiguous it is not permissible to interpret it differently from its plain meaning, and a construction contrary to its terms, for any period of time, will be disregarded.”
Section 11 of article 13 of the Criminal Code not only deprives a jury trial at common law of one of its essential attributes, but it also violates article 3 of the constitution and is void. The cases which have heretofore interpreted and applied the statute, to the extent that they conflict with this opinion, are therefore overruled.
The judgment of the criminal court of Cook county is affirmed.
T , Judgment affirmed.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting:
Section 176 of the, revised and private laws of Illinois of 1827, pages 162, 163, is in the following language: “All trials for criminal offenses, shall be conducted according to the course of the common law, except where this act points out a different mode; and the rules of evidence of the common law shall also, unless changed by this act, be binding upon all courts and juries in criminal cases. Juries shall in all cases be judges of the law and the fact.” The last provision of said section that juries shall in all cases be judges of the law and the fact has been several times reenacted and declared by the legislature of Illinois, as recognized by the decision of the court in this case, and it has been the recognized law of Illinois for more than one hundred and three years. There is no other decision by this court in which it has been held that the legislature of this State did not have the right and power to enact that provision. Wherever that right and power have been referred to or discussed in the previous decisions of this court it has never been held or intimated that the legislature was without right or power to enact that provision. There has never been a constitutional provision in this State that denied or challenged the right and power of the legislature to enact said provision of the statute of 1827. Section 6 of article 8 of the constitution of 1818 simply provided “that the right of the trial by jury shall remain inviolate.” Section 6 of article 13 of the constitution of 1848 provided “that the right of trial by jury shall remain inviolate, and shall extend to all cases at law, without regard to the amount in controversy.” Section 8 of article 8 of the constitution of 1818 and of article 13 of the constitution of 1848 provide “that no freeman shall be imprisoned or disseized of his freehold, liberties or privileges* or outlawed or exiled, or in any manner deprived of his life, liberty or property, but by the judgment of his peers or the law of the land.” Section u of article 8 of the constitution of 1818 and of article 13 of the constitution of 1848
In the case of Ross v. Irving, 14 Ill. 171, decided in December, 1852, this court held that the statute of this State commonly called the Occupying Claimants’ law was consti: tutional, and that the mode of assessing the value of improvements under that law by seven commissioners, as provided by that statute, did not infringe upon that clause of the constitution which guaranteed the right of trial by jury. It was further held in that case that the guaranty in the constitutions of 1818 and 1848 that the “right of trial by jury shall remain inviolate” was to be construed as preserving the right of that mode of trial as it was understood to exist at the time of the adoption of those constitutions; that trial by jury is only required on issues of fact in civil and criminal cases in courts of justice, and cannot be extended so as to embrace the case of a mere assessment of damages or the valuation of property made out of court, though done under an order of court directing the assessment of valuation. The court in arriving at its decision referred to the fact that at the time of the adoption of the constitution of 1848 said apt, which it held valid, was of near forty years’ standing, had been “repeatedly re-enacted by different legislatures, and had been recognized as valid by the Supreme Court in directing proceedings under it,” and that the constitution of 1848 did not in any provision thereof declare the act invalid. It seems to me that the above case is one of the strongest of all of our Illinois cases on the proposition
When the adoption of section 5 of article 2 of the constitution of 1870 was the question before the constitutional convention
The provision of the constitutions of 1818 and 1848 that no person should for the same offense be twice put in jeopardy was adopted as part of the constitution of 1870 by section 10 of article 2 of that instrument. This provision of the three constitutions shows that it has always been the constitutional law of this State that the jury in a criminal case
The history of the right of trial by jury in criminal cases is discussed at length in the very learned dissenting opinion of Mr! Justice Gray, in which Mr. Justice Shiras concurred, in the case of Sparf v. United States, 156 U. S. 51 and 715, 15 Sup. Ct. 273. It is there pointed out that by the provisipn of Magna Charta no person could be taken or imprisoned, or deprived of his freehold or of his liberties or free customs, unless by the lawful judgment of his peers or the law of the land; that by the law of England at the time of the settlement of this country by Englishmen, every subject (not a member of the House of Lords) indicted for
As shown above by reference to the opinion of Mr. Justice Gray in the Sparf case, supra, it was not the settled law of England, nor was it the law in this country at the time the Ordinance of 1787 was enacted, that juries in criminal cases were judges of the fact, only. There seems to
The conclusion that the legislature had, or has, no power to say by law that juries in criminal cases shall be the judges ■ of the law and the fact because of the provision of article 3 of the constitution of 1870, which declares that the powers of government shall be divided into three distinct departments, the legislative, executive and judicial, seems to me not tenable. The provisions of article 3 of the constitution of 1870 were contained in substantially the same language in the constitution of 1818 and the constitution of 1848. If the statute declared by the court to be unconstitutional is in violation of article 3 of the constitution of 1870 it was also unconstitutional under the provisions of the constitutions of 1818 and 1848 declaring that the powers of government should be divided into three distinct departments. It has always been recognized that the legislature in this State has the power to pass laws concerning the mode of practice and procedure in the courts. The practice in the trial of common law cases is regulated by the Practice act, the practice in chancery cases is regulated by the Chancery act, and the mode of practice and procedure in criminal cases is regulated by the Criminal Code. Section 29 of article 6 of the constitution of 1870 provides: . “All laws relating to courts shall be general, and of uniform operation; and the organization, jurisdiction, powers, proceedings and practice of all courts, of the same class or grade, so far as regulated by law, and the force and effect of the process, judgments and decrees of such courts, severally, shall be uniform.” It seems to me that
If.it be admitted to be the fact (I deny that it is the fact) that the statute of 1827 which provided that the jury in a criminal case should be the judges of the law and the’ fact did make a change in the law as it had theretofore existed, it does not follow that the statute is unconstitutional. It should be noted that the jury, when sitting as a part of the court in the trial of a criminal case, are as much a part of the court as is the presiding judge, and the fact that the jury are vested with the power to decide the question of law as well as of fact involved in the plea of the general issue in a criminal case does not vest judicial power in a non-judicial body.
Where an act of the legislature has been recognized, sanctioned and acquiesced in by the different departments
For the foregoing reasons I respectfully dissent from the opinion of the court in this case.