| E.D.N.Y | Mar 15, 1877
This is an action to enforce a lien for supplies furnished to the steamboat Long Branch. The answer avers that at the. time the supplies were furnished the vessel was owned by the New Jersey Southern Railroad Company, and that the supplies were furnished solely upon the credit of that corporation. Under the decision of The Plymouth Rock LCase No. 11,237]. this vessel was a foreign vessel, and therefore subject to a lien for the supplies in question, which are admitted to have been furnished to and necessary for the use of the vessel, provided the articles were furnished upon the credit of the vessel. The facts bearing upon this question are similar to those proved in the case of the Plymouth Rock above referred to, and in accordance with that decision it must be held that the proofs are sufficient to sustain the averment of the libel that the articles were furnished upon the credit of the vessel, and not solely upon the credit of the railroad company. A point is made in this ease that it appears that some of the articles were intended to be used in a bar kept on the steamboat, and were designated on the bills as for the bar. and that such articles are not within the denomination of necessaries for the vessel. 1 can imagine a state of facts that would not warrant holding that a lien upon the vessel is created by articles furnished to a bar maintained on the vessel. But upon the meagre facts here shown no distinction can be drawn between the articles to be used on the table at the restaurant and those used in the bar. The employment of the vessel in the absence of other proof warrants the inference that the bar was a part of the restaurant, and no more than a convenient method of supplying the ordinary wants of the class of passengers transported on the boat. Accordingly there must be a decree in favor of the libellants for the amount claimed, with interest and costs.