19 F. 798 | E.D.N.Y | 1883
It is conceded on the part of the libelant that there can be no recovery in this action unless the libelant’s ownership of the cargo proceeded against has been proved. This has not been done. It has been shown that the libelant, one Jewett, had obtained from the government of Brazil permission to extract, for his own use, from Bat island, a cargo of guano or mineral phosphate. He sent out the brig Katie to obtain such cargo, but she was condemned in Rio Grande do Sul, and her voyage broken up. At the time of the ■condemnation of the Katie, Williams, the claimant in this action, learned of the destination of the Katie and the obj ect of her voyage, and, acting upon such information, proceeded to Bat island with his vessel, the Dauntless, and there obtained the cargo now proceeded
Let a decree be entered dismissing the libel, with costs.
See opinion on argument of exceptions to libel in same case. The Dauntless, 7 Fed. Rep. 366.