267 F. 686 | 2d Cir. | 1920
April 4, 1916, about 7 a. m., in perfectly clear weather, the tide strong flood, about midstream in the East River between the Brooklyn Navy Yard and Corlears Hook Park, where there is a width of water of from 1,600 to 1,800 feet, and where there was no other shipping to embarrass the vessels, the double-decked cattle barge 103 in tow on the starboard side of the tug Henry S. Beard, subsequently named the Agnes Moran, at a point about 25 feet forward of her stern, came into collision with the stern of the Coamo,
The steamer was engaged in backing and filling, so as to round to on a port helm and head down stream against the tide. The tug W. F. Dalzell was at her port bow and the tug Ackerman at her starboard bow; it being the duty of the Dalzell to push ahead and of the Ackerman to pull astern when the steamer was moving ahead under her own steam, so as to help her round to. The purpose of the maneuver was to let the steamer drop back on the flood tide and go broadside into a basin between piers at the foot of South Third and South Fifth streets, Williamsburgh, where she was to lie alongside the bulkhead and discharge her cargo. The master of the tug Dalzell was on the bridge in charge of the navigation, and with him were the captain, third officer at the telegraph, and a quartermaster at the wheel. The first officer was at the bow, and the second officer was at the stern.
No one on the steamer seems to have seen the Beard coming up the river with her tow until the collision was imminent, except the captain of the Dalzell, who says he saw her when she was passing under the Brooklyn Bridge and the steamer had begun her turning movement. The master of the Beard says, when he was passing under the Brooklyn Bridge, he saw the steamer beginning this maneuver and he understood exactly what the purpose was. The distance between the vessels was at that time over a half a mile. The cattle barge was much longer and much higher than the Beard, so that her pilot was placed on top of the barge, in order to give the captain at the wheel directions as to the navigation on the starboard side, while the captain himself navigated for the port side.
The steamer blew no signals and heard none from the Beard, though her witnesses say that when within 700 or 800 feet away she blew a signal of two blasts to indicate her intention to go under the steamer’s stern, and afterwards an alarm. We are satisfied that these signals were not blown until the collision was imminent. The steamer, still making stemway, though her engines were going full speed ahead, struck the starboard side of the cattle float about 20 feet forward of her stern, so that it is evident that a little more care on the -part of either or both vessels would have enabled them to pass clear.
The first suit was by the owner of the cattle barge against the steamer C'oamo, whose claimant brought in under the Fifty-Ninth rule (29 Sup. Ct. xlvi) F. B. Dalzell & Co., Incorporated, and the tug Dalzell, whereupon F. B. Dalzell & Co., Incorporated, brought in the tug Beard under the same rule. The second suit was by the New York & Porto Rico Steamship Company, owner of the steamer Coamo,
Both cases were tried together, and the oral opinion of the judge, delivered at the close of the case, indicates that his attention was centered upon the disputed question whether the navigation of the steamer was in charge of her master or of the captain of the tug Dalzell. On this point he found that it was in charge of the captain of the tug, and a decree was entered against F. B. Dalzell & Co., Incorporated, and the tug Dalzell.
Plainly a most insufficient lookout was maintained on the steamer. The second officer was especially negligent for not advising the bridge to go ahead on the engines when the vessels were in dangerous proximity, which he could have done either by voice or by using the telegraph which connected the poop deck with the bridge. He was in the best possible position to appreciate' how near to each other the sterns of the cattle float and the steamer were. On the other hand, the Beard was at fault for a bad lookout and for keeping ahead at full speed on a course close to the steamer’s stern. She did nothing to prevent the collision in the way of slowing, stopping, or giving timely danger signals.
The court below is directed to enter a decree in favor of the cattle float, with interest and costs, against F. B. Dalzell & C’o., Incorporated, the steamer Coamo, and the tug Henry S. Beard, and in favor of the New York & Porto Rico Steamship Company, claimant of the steamer Coamo, for two-thirds of its damages and costs, with interest, against F. B. Dalzell & Co., Incorporated, and the tug Henry S. Beard.
Decree reversed.