12 La. Ann. 384 | La. | 1857
Jean Pierre Thorcmie, by his will made in Paris, and duly admitted to probate and execution in New Orleans, devised and bequeathed one-third of the net total of his estate to the asylum for male orphans established in the Third District of the city of New Orleans.
There are two charitable corporations answering the description of this clause of the will of Thorame, both being located or established within the corporate limits of the Third District of New Orleans. Each of these institutions claims, to the exclusion of the other, to have the benefit of this legacy.
The corporate appellation of one of these claimants is “ The Mylne Asylum for Destitute Orphan Boys.”
That of the other is “ The St. Mary’s Catholic Orphan Boys Asylum.”
In interpreting this will, our first duty is to ascertain, as far as practicable, the intention of the testator. C. O. 1705.
And in thfe outset of this investigation we are satisfied that the intention of Thora/me was to make one orphan asylum, and no more, the object of his bounty; the singular number of the substantives “hospice” and “asyle” being the grammatical form of an olographic will, whose every sentence bespeaks its author to have been a man of education and of high intelligence. The clause of the will which is the subject of consideration, is, indeed, a model of diction as well as of sentiment; a noble thought finely expressed. It reads as follows:
“ Je donne et légue le tiers du total net de ma succession á l’hospice ou asyle des orphelins dont l’institution est établie dans le Troisieme District de la Nouvelle-Orléans, en témoignage de ma reconnaissance pour la terre hospitaliére qui, aprés l’année 1815, dont les événements politiques d’Europe avaient brisé une carriére pleine d’espérances, est venue m’offrir les moyens d’en créer une nouvelle et d’acquérir honorablement les biens que je laisse aprés moi.”
It is apparent that the testator had a particular asylum in view. The District Judge concluded from the evidence that the contemplated object of the testator’s charity was the St. Mary’s Catholic Orphan Boys’ Asylum, and we think the balance of probabilities preponderates strongly in favor of that interpretation.
The testator was a resident of New Orleans from the year 1817 to the year 1835 or 1836. Having amassed a competency by the industrious exercise of an honorable profession, he left this city in 1835 or 1836, and spent the remain
He describes himself in' his will as a naturalized citizen of the United States, and makes particular mention of the day of his naturalization and of the court in which he was naturalized. His fortune remained, to the day of his death, invested in real estate, bank stock and mortgages in the city of New Orleans, administered by agents with whom we must presume he was in constant correspondence, and besides whom we find mentioned in the will and in the testimony on trial the names of many respectable citizens of New Orleans, with whom the testator was on terms of intimacy.
It is thus perceived that Mr. Thorame had abundant opportunities of being well informed in relation to the charitable institutions existing in the Third District of the city of New Orleans at the time of making his will, which was the 15th October, 1854, nearly two years previous to his death.
We are next to enquire to which of the two institutions which claim to be the object of this charity, it is most likely, from the evidence, that Mr. Thorame's attention should have been directed, either by personal observation during his sojourn in New Orleans, or by his correspondents, after his departure ?
The Mylne Asylum for Destitute Orphan Boys certainly came into existence after Thorame's departure from Louisiana. It was founded by the last will of Alexander Mylne, whose succession was opened in October, 1888, and was incorporated by Act of the Legislature of February, 1839. This asylum is proved to have been first opened in June, 1839. It was discontinued a short time afterwards, and remained closed until the 15th August, 1854, when it was reopened, and from that time to the present, it has supported about thirty orphans at a time. This asylum was richly endowed by the will of its founder, and is now in the possession of property estimated at $24,000.
The St. Mary’s Catholic Male Orphan Asylum was incorporated by the Legislature of this State in March, 1886, under a different name, and may therefore have been in existence previous to Thorame's departure from Louisiana. It was founded by an association of charitable persons, has been in active operation from the date of its incorporation, without intermission, and has always depended solely upon contributions of its corporators and upon collections made for its benefit at religous ceremonies and elsewhere. It has also received assistance from the city, and is the institution to which the Mayor, as dispenser of the municipal charity, has been in the habit for many years of sending destitute male orphans for shelter and sustenance. With means thus .derived entirely from voluntary contributions, and under the superintendence of an aged and respectable citizen, Mr. Anthony Basch, who has for many years devoted himself to this work, this institution shelters and supports upwards of two hundred male orphans of all ages, from the earliest infancy to fourteen years.
Established at first on the Bayou St. John, within the Second District of this city, the St. Mary’s Catholic Boys’ Asylum was removed in April, 1840, to the Third District, where it has ever since remained.
With these faets before us, we cannot doubt that the St. Mary’s Asylum was that which was intended by the testator. In point of fact, the Mylne Asylum had no actual existence for the purposes of its foundation until within precisely two months of the period when Thorame penned his will on the other side of
Judgment affirmed, with costs.