Case Information
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - x
: IN RE: : ORDER : 03 MDL 1570 (GBD) (SN) TERRORIST ATTACKS ON : SEPTEMBER 11, 2001 :
: - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - x This document relates to:
Morris v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-05321 (GBD)(SN) Schlissel v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-05331 (GBD)(SN) Ades v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-07306 (GBD)(SN) Abel v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-11837 (GBD)(SN) Jimenez v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-11875 (GBD)(SN) Rivelli v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-11878 (GBD)(SN) Hemenway v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-12277 (GBD)(SN) Rowenhorst v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-12387 (GBD)(SN) BNY Mellon v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:19-cv-11767 (GBD)(SN) Bernaerts v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:19-cv-11865 (GBD)(SN) Hargrave v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:20-cv-09387 (GBD)(SN) Asaro v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:20-cv-10460 (GBD)(SN) Amato v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:21-cv-10239 (GBD)(SN) King v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:22-cv-05193 (GBD)(SN) Strauss v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:22-cv-10823 (GBD)(SN) Kone v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:23-cv-05790 (GBD)(SN) Lopez v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:23-cv-08305 (GBD)(SN) Burnett v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:15-cv-09903 (GBD)(SN) Moody-Theinert v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-11876 (GBD)(SN) Aamoth v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-12276 (GBD)(SN) Bodner v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:19-cv-11776 (GBD)(SN) Fennelly v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:23-cv-10824 (GBD)(SN) Bianco v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:20-cv-10902 (GBD)(SN) Kelly v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:23-cv-07283 (GBD)(SN) Jelnek v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:24-cv-05520 (GBD)(SN)
ORDER GRANTING PARTIAL FINAL JUDGMENT BY DEFAULT AGAINST THE ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN FOR THE PLAINTIFFS LISTED IN EXHIBITS A, B, AND C
GEORGE B. DANIELS, United States District Judge: The Plaintiffs listed in Exhibits A, B, and C move for entry of partial final default judgment against Defendant the Islamic Republic of Iran (“Iran”). (ECF No. 10524, 10822, 10883, and 1 Upon consideration of the evidence and arguments set forth in the Declarations of Jerry 10917.) 0F S. Goldman, Esq. and Robert Morgan, and the exhibits thereto (ECF No. 10526, 10824, 10885,
and 10924), and in light of the default judgment as to liability against the Iran (
see In re Terrorist
Attacks on Sept. 11, 2001
, No. 03-md-1570 (GBD), 2011 WL 13244047, at *39 (S.D.N.Y. Dec.
2 , together with the entire record in this case, it is hereby 22, 2011)) 1F 1 Unless otherwise stated, all ECF citations included herein refer to documents filed on the 9/11 multidistrict
litigation docket.
See In re Terrorist Attacks on September 11, 2001 , No. 03-md-1570 (GBD) (SN). 2 Additional default judgments of liability are:
•
Morris v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-05321 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 4595
•
Schlissel v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-05331 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 4598
•
Ades v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-07306 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 4594
•
Abel v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-11837 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 5048
•
Jimenez v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-11875 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 5056
•
Rivelli v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-11878 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 5047
•
Hemenway v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-12277 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 5054
•
Rowenhorst v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-12387 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 5053
•
BNY Mellon v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:19-cv-11767 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 7522
•
Bernaerts v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:19-cv-11865 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 7522
•
Hargrave v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:20-cv-09387 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 7522
•
Asaro v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:20-cv-10460 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 7522
•
Amato v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:21-cv-10239 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 8978
•
King v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:22-cv-05193 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 9416
•
Strauss v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:22-cv-10823 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 9416
•
Kone v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:23-cv-05790 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 10306
•
Burnett v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:15-cv-09903 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 9733
•
Moody-Theinert v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-11876 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No.
5055 • Aamoth v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-12276 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 5050
•
Bodner v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:19-cv-11776 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 7522
•
Bianco v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:20-cv-10902 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 7522
•
Kelly v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:23-cv-07283 (GBD)(SN) - MDL ECF No. 10306
ORDERED that service of process in the above-captioned case was properly effectuated
3
upon Iran in accordance with 28 U.S.C. § 1608(a)(4); 2F ORDERED that judgment as to liability is entered on behalf of all Plaintiffs identified in the attached Exhibits A, B, and C against the Islamic Republic of Iran; and it is ORDERED that partial final judgment is entered on behalf of the Plaintiffs identified in Exhibits A, B, and C against the Islamic Republic of Iran; and it is ORDERED that the Plaintiffs identified in Exhibit A are awarded economic damages as 4 and it is set forth therein; 3F 3 The affidavits attesting to service are at:
•
Morris v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-05321 (GBD)(SN), ECF No. 55
•
Schlissel v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-05331 (GBD)(SN), ECF No. 53
•
Ades v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-07306 (GBD)(SN), ECF No. 31
•
Abel v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-11837 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 4687
•
Jimenez v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-11875 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 4685
•
Rivelli v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-11878 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 4692
•
Hemenway v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-12277 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 4694
•
Rowenhorst v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-12387 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 4693
•
BNY Mellon v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:19-cv-11767 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 6899
•
Bernaerts v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:19-cv-11865 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 6895
•
Hargrave v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:20-cv-09387 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 6898
•
Asaro v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:20-cv-10460 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 6901
•
Amato v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:21-cv-10239 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 8407
•
King v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:22-cv-05193 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 8887
•
Strauss v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:22-cv-10823 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 9234
•
Kone v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:23-cv-05790 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 10070
•
Lopez v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:23-cv-08305 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 10285
•
Burnett v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:15-cv-09903 (GBD)(SN), ECF No. 64
•
Moody-Theinert v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-11876 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No.
4691 • Aamoth v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:18-cv-12276 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 4686
•
Bodner v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:19-cv-11776 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 6897
•
Fennelly v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:23-cv-10824 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 10781
•
Bianco v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:20-cv-10902 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 6896
•
Kelly v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:23-cv-07283 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 10094
•
Jelnek v. Islamic Republic of Iran , No. 1:24-cv-05520 (GBD)(SN) – MDL ECF No. 10826 4 Christopher Cuomo’s claim is denied without prejudice because Cuomo is not the correct Personal Representative for Vanessa Lang Langer. The Public Administrator of Westchester County is the listed Personal Representative for Langer. ( See ECF No. 10486.) Plaintiffs may refile.
ORDERED that the Plaintiffs identified in Exhibit B are awarded pain and suffering 5 and it is damages as set forth therein; 4F ORDERED
that the Plaintiffs identified in Exhibit C are awarded solatium
damages as set forth therein; and it is ORDERED that Plaintiffs receiving economic damages identified in Exhibit A are awarded prejudgment interest of 4.96 percent per annum, compounded annually, running from the date as indicated in the “Date of Report” column in Exhibit A until the date of judgment; and it is further
ORDERED that Plaintiffs identified in Exhibits B and C are awarded prejudgment interest of 4.96 percent per annum, compounded annually, running from September 11, 2001 until the date of judgment; and it is
ORDERED that the Plaintiffs identified in Exhibits A, B, and C may submit future applications for punitive or other damages at a later date consistent with any future rulings of this Court; and it is Hillary Hans’ and Leslie Reuben’s claims are denied without prejudice because only Hillary Hans is properly listed in the complaint as Ronald J. Ruben’s Personal Representative. Plaintiffs may submit a motion at a later time to properly list Leslie Ruben as a Personal Representative as well. Theresa Russo-Kempf’s claim is denied without prejudice. Plaintiffs provide a citation to a motion to substitute which shows that Russo-Kempf was substituted as the Personal Representative for the Estate of Edward Rowenhorst, not the Estate of Michael Russo. Therefore, Theresa Russo-Kempf is not the proper Personal Representative for the Estate of Michael Russo. Plaintiffs may refile. Ayleen Arroyo’s claim is denied without prejudice. The proposed order lists both Ayleen Arroyo and George Santiago as the co-Personal Representatives of the Estate of Ayleen J. Santiago. While the cited motion to substitute properly lists Ayleen Arroyo, the cited amendment improperly lists Ayleen Arroyo and George J. Santiago as co-Personal Representatives of the Estate of George Santiago. Plaintiffs can refile with Ayleen Arroyo alone as the Personal Representative, or refile the amendment to include both Ayleen Arroyo and George J. Santiago as co-Personal Representatives of the Estate of Ayleen J. Santiago. 5 Christopher Cuomo’s claim is denied without prejudice because Cuomo is not the correct Personal Representative for Vanessa Lang Langer. The Public Administrator of Westchester County is the listed Personal Representative for Langer. ( See ECF No. 10486.) Plaintiffs may refile.
ORDERED that the Plaintiffs not appearing in Exhibits A, B, or C may submit in later stages applications for damages awards to the extent they have not done so already. The Clerk of Court is directed to enter partial final default judgment for the Plaintiffs listed in Exhibits A, B, and C. The Clerk of Court is further directed to close the motions at: • ECF Nos. 10524, 10822, 10883, and 10917 in 03-md-1570;
•
ECF Nos. 296, 319 in 1:18-cv-05321;
•
ECF Nos. 239, 257 in .1:18-cv-05331;
•
ECF Nos. 242, 263 in 1:18-cv-07306;
•
ECF No. 234 in 1:18-cv-11837;
•
ECF No. 246 in 1:18-cv-11875;
•
ECF Nos. 230, 246 in. 1:18-cv-11878;
•
ECF Nos. 311, 330, 334, 340 in 1:18-cv-12277;
•
ECF Nos. 263, 279 in. 1:18-cv-12387;
•
ECF Nos. 205, 224 in. 1:19-cv-11767;
•
ECF Nos. 255, 279 in 1:19-cv-11865;
•
ECF Nos. 191, 207 in 1:20-cv-09387; • ECF No. 198 in 1:20-cv-10460;
•
ECF No. 135 in 1:21-cv-10239;
•
ECF Nos. 168, 191, 196, 201 in 1:22-cv-05193;
•
ECF Nos. 78, 98 in 1:22-cv-10823;
•
ECF Nos. 67, 86, 94 in 1:23-cv-05790;
•
ECF No. 46 in 1:23-cv-08305;
•
ECF No. 960 in 1:15-cv-09903; • ECF No. 185 in 1:18-cv-11876;
• ECF Nos. 276, 280 in
1:18-cv-12276; • ECF No. 217 in 1:19-cv-11776; • ECF Nos. 49, 53 in 1:23-cv-10824; • ECF Nos. 196, 202 in 1:20-cv-10902; • ECF No. 65 in 1 :23-cv-07283; • ECF Nos. 50, 55 in 1 :24-cv-05520
Dated: May 2-j, 2025 New York, New York SO ORDERED. United Sta es District Judge
Exhibit A Personal Representative 9/11 Decedent Claim Information Economic Damages First Middle Last Suffix First Middle Last Suffix Nationality on 9/11 Date of Death 9/11 Site Case Complaint Amendments & Substitutions Report Date of Report Prior Award Amount Notes $8,025,616.00 1 Elizabeth Rick Scott Daniel Bart United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 10 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 1. 11/1/24 N/A $3,134,248.00 2 Eve Bucca Ronald Paul Bucca United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 10 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 24. 11/1/24 N/A $2,902,310.00 3 Paulina Cardona Jose Manuel Cardona United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv10823 22cv10823, 1 at 2 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 42. 12/1/24 N/A D'Allara 4 Carol L. D'Allara John United States 9/11/2001 NY 19cv11767 19cv11767, 5 at 3 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 66. 11/1/24 N/A $3,848,793.00 5 Florence Kneff Matthew Diaz United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv11837 18cv11837, 1 at 7 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 84. 10/1/24 N/A $6,380,315.00 Jose Espinal $828,248.00 6 Maria Alayo Aguilar United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv05790 23cv05790, 10 at 3 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 108. 12/1/24 N/A Theodore 7 Barbara Haskell Thomas Haskell United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv07306 18cv07306, 1 at 1 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 131. 10/1/24 N/A $8,930,087.00 $2,550,325.00 8 Michael R. Kuo Frederick Kuo Jr. United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 9 8725; 8728 (granting 8725) See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 149. 11/1/24 N/A $2,973,057.00 9 Angelina Jimenez Elena Fernanda Ledesma United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 10 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 173. 11/1/24 N/A Luis Manuel 10 Gladys Lopez Lopez United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv08305 23cv08305, 12 at 1 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 197. 5/1/24 N/A $1,126,440.00 11 Ali Mohamed Malahi Abdu Ali Malahi United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv11875 18cv11875, 6 at 4 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 1. 10/1/24 N/A $1,610,133.00 Mardovich 12 Laura Edward J. Mardovich United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv11875 18cv11875, 6 at 4 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 24. 10/1/24 N/A $26,113,854.00
a/k/a Balemian 13 Colleen Golden Richard J. Morgan United States 9/11/2001 NY 19cv11865 19cv11865, 1 at 3 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 51. 12/1/24 N/A $2,230,263.00 14 John J. Buro Laura Ragonese-Snik United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv12277 18cv12277, 1 at 9-10 5548; 5641 (granting 5548) See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 196. 12/1/24 N/A $2,107,150.00 Aida Rosario 15 Minerva Rosario United States 9/11/2001 NY 20cv10460 20cv10460, 1 at 5 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 74. 12/1/24 N/A $1,276,444.00 16 Rita L. Ruback Paul G. Ruback United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv11878 18cv11878, 1 at 2 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 97. 11/1/24 N/A $2,441,805.00 17 Cedric Pitt, Sr. Jacquelyn Patrice Sanchez United States 9/11/2001 NY 21cv10239 21cv10239, 1 at 6-7 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 138. 11/1/24 N/A $4,181,969.00 18 Denise Schrang Gerard P. Schrang United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv11878 18cv11878, 1 at 4 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 162. 11/1/24 N/A $2,900,464.00 Gary Francis Smith $2,589,261.00 19 Ann Smith United States 9/11/2001 VA 21cv10239 21cv10239, 1 at 7 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 180. 11/1/24 N/A $4,218,556.00 20 Dean Taylor Kip Taylor United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 8 10502; 10510 (granting 10502) See Exhibit C-3c to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 1. 12/1/24 N/A Perez a/k/a 21 Jennica David Vera United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv12387 18cv12387, 1 at 5 See Exhibit C-3c to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 16. 11/1/24 N/A $1,365,460.00
Vera 22 Anthony Vola Maria P. Vola United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv05331 18cv05331, 5 at 10 9439; 9443 (granting 9439) See Exhibit C-3c to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 39. 12/1/24 N/A $518,271.00 The Personal Representative's name on the Complaint is Karin Charles; a Motion to Correct to change Kenneth Zelman 23 Karin Giansanti United States 9/11/2001 NY 19cv11865 19cv11865, 1 at 8 See Exhibit C-3c to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 62. 10/1/24 N/A $4,987,958.00
her last name to Giansanti is pending at MDL ECF No. 10518 DeMartini 24 Nicole Francis Albert DeMartini United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv12276 18cv12276, 1 at 5 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 1. 12/1/2024 N/A $2,177,861.00 a/k/a Fasnacht- 25 John T. Genovese Steven Gregory Genovese United States 9/11/2001 NY 19cv11767 19cv11767, 5 at 6 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 24. 1/1/2025 N/A $30,789,724.00 26 Terri Langone Peter Langone United States 9/11/2001 NY 19cv11776 19cv11776, 5 at 3 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 69. 11/1/2024 N/A $5,218,129.00 27 Reza Mashayekhi Darya Lin United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv05790 23cv05790, 10 at 1-2 10222 at 3 (granted at 10227) See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 87. 12/1/2024 N/A $2,925,648.00 28 Bradley D. Noack Katherine McGarry Noack United States 9/11/2001 NY 19cv11865 19cv11865, 1 at 4 8074 at 3 (granted at 8079) See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 110. 3/1/2025 N/A $4,855,324.00 29 Alana McKenzie Molly Lou McKenzie United States 9/11/2001 VA 23cv05790 23cv05790, 10 at 4 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 133. 4/1/2025 N/A $1,416,213.00 30 John Capodanno Mario Nardone Jr. United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv11876 18cv11876, 1 at 2 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 156. 1/1/2025 N/A $7,950,931.00 31 Teresa J. Pycior Joseph J. Pycior United States 9/11/2001 VA 18cv11876 18cv11876, 1 at 7 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 1. 4/1/2025 N/A $2,715,670.00 32 Debra Roberts Leo Arthur Roberts United States 9/11/2001 NY 15cv09903 15cv09903, 53 at 119 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 17. 3/1/2025 N/A $6,401,059.00 33 Josephine Romito James Romito United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv12277 18cv12277, 1 at 11 7461 at 3 (granted at 7477) See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 40. 4/1/2025 N/A $1,900,202.00 34 Yubelly Santos Rafael Humberto Santos United States 9/11/2001 NY 19cv11865 19cv11865, 1 at 6 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 93. 1/1/2025 N/A $2,401,344.00 35 Patricia Rafter Bonnie Smithwick United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv11878 18cv11878, 1 at 6 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 117. 12/1/2024 N/A $2,745,019.00 36 Alfredo Bordenabe Krystine Bordenabe United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv10824 23cv10824, 1 at 1 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 1 5/1/2025 N/A $3,875,807.00
Public MDL ECF No. 10482 (granted at 37 Kings County Rosemarie Carlson United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 7 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 24 5/1/2025 N/A $2,602,999.00 Administrator 10486) 38 Sunny Chiang Alexander Chiang United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 3 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 48 3/1/2025 N/A $1,263,550.00 39 Beth Schutte Patricia A. Cody United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv12276 18cv12276, 1 at 3-4 MDL ECF No. 9145 (granted at 9170) See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 72 5/1/2025 N/A $3,743,961.00
Beard- 40 Jacqueline Michael Edwards United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 1 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 95 12/1/2024 N/A $18,531,917.00 Edwards 41 Veronica Morris Eileen Flecha United States 9/11/2001 NY 20cv10902 20cv10902, 1 at 3-4 MDL ECF No. 7459 (granted at 7476) See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 119 5/1/2025 N/A $705,030.00 42 Christine O'Reilly Howard Gelling Jr. United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 142 12/1/2024 N/A $7,632,538.00
MDL ECF No. 10843 (granted at 43 Susan Fennell Edwin J. Graf III United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv05790 23cv05790, 10 at 2 See Exhibit C-3a to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 165 10/1/2024 N/A $2,646,041.00 10848) 44 Deborah Ivory Lacey B. Ivory United States 9/11/2001 VA 23cv05790 23cv05790, 10 at 6 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 1 5/1/2025 N/A $2,601,106.00 MDL ECF No. 10843 (granted at 45 Gregory Taylor Nehamon Lyons United States 9/11/2001 VA 18cv07306 18cv07306, 1 at 11 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 16 8/1/2021 N/A $1,047,068.00 10848) 46 Mary Lou Moss Brian Moss United States 9/11/2001 VA 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 38 11/1/2024 N/A $2,359,001.00 47 Catherine Lyn-Shue Francisco Munoz United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 1 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 53 12/1/2024 N/A $2,204,230.00 48 Jean Oitice Samuel Oitice United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv12277 18cv12277, 1 at 7 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 76 4/1/2025 N/A $2,242,832.00 49 Tara Felice Glen Pettit United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv05321 18cv05321, 6 at 11 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 93 5/1/2025 N/A $2,272,808.00 50 Elias Rodriguez Mayra V. Rodriguez United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv05321 18cv05321, 6 at 13 MDL ECF No. 8078 (granted at 8084) See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 111 5/1/2025 N/A $1,435,103.00 51 Mary Jelnek Vincent Slavin United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 1 See Exhibit C-3b to Declaration of Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. at page 135 12/1/2024 N/A $14,936,937.00
Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-SN Document 10997 Filed 05/29/25 Page 9 of 12
Exhibit B
*9 Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-SN Document 10997 Filed 05/29/25 Page 10 of 12 Personal Representative 9/11 Decedent Claim Information Pain & Suffering Damages Notes: First Middle Last Suffix First Middle Last Suffix Nationality on 9/11 Date of Death 9/11 Site Case Complaint Amendments & Substitutions Prior Award Amount MDL ECF No. 10913 (motion to substitute is 1 Johanna Kmetz Margaret Echtermann US 9/11/2001 NY 20cv10902 20cv10902, 1 at 3 N/A $2,000,000.00 pending) MDL ECF No. 10915 (motion to substitute is 2 Kyler Lake William D. Lake US 9/11/2001 NY 18cv12277 18cv12277, 1 at 3 N/A $2,000,000.00 pending) Public 3 Kings County Rosemarie C. Carlson US 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 7 10482; 10486 (granting 10482) N/A $2,000,000.00 Administrator 4 Alfredo Bordenabe Krystine Bordenable US 9/11/2001 NY 23cv10824 23cv10824, 1 at 1 N/A $2,000,000.00 Personal Representative's first name is Alfredo. 5 Deborah Ivory Lacey Bernard Ivory US 9/11/2001 VA 23cv05790 23cv05790, 10 at 6 N/A $2,000,000.00 6 Debra Roberts Leo Arthur Roberts US 9/11/2001 NY 15cv09903 15cv09903, 53 at 119 N/A $2,000,000.00 7 Patricia Fennelly Robert Caufield US 9/11/2001 NY 20cv10902 20cv10902, 1 at 2 MDL ECF No. 10874 (granted at 10878) N/A $2,000,000.00 *10 8 Sunny Chiang Alexander Chiang US 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 3 N/A $2,000,000.00 9 Jacqueline Beard-Edwards Michael Edwards US 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 1 N/A $2,000,000.00 10 Christine O'Reilly Howard Gelling Jr. US 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 N/A $2,000,000.00 11 Susan Fennell Edwin J. Graf III US 9/11/2001 NY 23cv05790 23cv05790, 10 at 2 MDL ECF No. 10843 (granted at 10848) N/A $2,000,000.00 12 Gregory Taylor Nehamon Lyons US 9/11/2001 VA 18cv07306 18cv07306, 1 at 11 MDL ECF No. 10843 (granted at 10848) N/A $2,000,000.00 13 Mary Lou Moss Brian Moss US 9/11/2001 VA 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 N/A $2,000,000.00 14 Catherine Lyn-Shue Francisco Munoz US 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 1 N/A $2,000,000.00 15 Mary Jelnek Vincent Slavin US 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 1 N/A $2,000,000.00 16 Gladys Lopez Luis Manuel Lopez US 9/11/2001 NY 23cv08305 23cv08305, 12 at 1 N/A $2,000,000.00
Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-SN Document 10997 Filed 05/29/25 Page 11 of 12
Exhibit C
*11 Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-SN Document 10997 Filed 05/29/25 Page 12 of 12 Personal Representative Claimant 9/11 Decedent Claim Information Solatium Damages # Name First Middle Last Suffix Nationality on 9/11 First Middle Last Suffix Nationality on 9/11 Date of Death 9/11 Site Case Complaint Amendments & Substitutions Relationship Documentation Prior Award Amount Notes [1] Roya Bolourchi Touran US Touran Bolourchi United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv08305 23cv08305, 12 at 1 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [2] Patricia Fennelly US Robert John Caufield United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv08305 23cv08305, 12 at 1 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 [3] Deborah King Lloyd US Amy King United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 1 [10423] Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 Because Timothy Langer is deceased, the Court has approved a Personal Westchester County Public Timothy Langer Vanessa Lang United States $12,500,000.00 [4] US Langer 9/11/2001 NY 23cv05790 23v05790, 10 at 7 10482; 10486 (granting 10482) Spouse (Deceased) N/A N/A Representative for them (Westchester County Public Administrator), Administrator please see ECF No. 10486. Heily Fortuna Luis Manuel United States 23cv08305 23cv08305, 12 at 1 Child $8,500,000.00 [5] Dominican Republic Lopez 9/11/2001 NY N/A N/A [6] Lester Fortuna US Luis Manuel Lopez United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv08305 23cv08305, 12 at 1 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [7] Gladys Lopez Dominican Republic Luis Manuel Lopez United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv08305 23cv08305, 12 at 1 Spouse N/A N/A $12,500,000.00 Previously listed as "Derrick McKenley" in ECF No. 1 at 4 in No. 22-cv- Derrick McKenly Jacqueline 22cv10823 22cv10823, 1 at 5 Sibling $4,250,000.00 [8] US Young United States 9/11/2001 NY N/A N/A 10823. [9] Terrance Young US Jacqueline Young United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv10823 22cv10823, 1 at 4 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 Previously listed as "Terrence Young" in ECF No. 1 at 4 in No. 22-cv-10823. [10] Alfredo Bordenabe Krystine Bordenabe United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv10824 23cv10824, 1 at 1 Spouse N/A N/A $12,500,000.00 [11] Andrew Thomas Godsil US Krystine Bordenabe United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv10824 23cv10824, 1 at 1 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [12] Julia Elise Ciccone US Alex F. Ciccone United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv05790 23cv05790, 10 at 1 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [13] Stephen Ciccone US Alex F. Ciccone United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv05790 23cv05790, 10 at 1 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 Cristian Michael Diaz-Piedra Michael Angelo Diaz-Piedra III [14] US United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv10823 22cv10823, 1 at 2 10671 at 3 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [15] Kenneth Foster US Sandra N. Foster United States 9/11/2001 VA 18cv12276 18cv12276, 1 at 8 10807 at 3 Spouse (Deceased) N/A N/A $12,500,000.00 [16] Deborah Ivory US Lacey B. Ivory United States 9/11/2001 VA 23cv05790 23cv05790, 10 at 6 Spouse N/A N/A $12,500,000.00 [17] Suzanne Ledee Garcia US Kenneth Charles Ledee United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv10823 22cv10823, 1 at 1 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 [18] Neanta McCants Trisha Diaonne McCants US Judy Rowlett United States 9/11/2001 VA 22cv10823 22cv10823, 1 at 2 Child (Deceased) N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [19] John Ruddle US David Michael Ruddle United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 3 10806 at 3 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 [20] Mary Migliaccio James Schuler US Susan Lee Schuler United States 9/11/2001 NY 18cv05331 18cv05331, 5 at 7 10805 at 3 Spouse (Deceased) N/A N/A $12,500,000.00 [21] Donald B. Smith US Gary Francis Smith United States 9/11/2001 VA 22cv10823 22cv10823, 1 at 1 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 [22] Debra Andreacchio US John Andreacchio United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv05790 23cv05790, 10 at 5 MDL ECF No. 10842 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 MDL ECF No. 10863 [23] Pamela Bittner-Conley Donald Bittner US Jeffrey Bittner United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 3 Parent (Deceased) N/A N/A $8,500,000.00
(granted at 10867) [24] Pamela Bittner-Conley US Jeffrey Bittner United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 3 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 [25] Devonte Carter US Marcia Cecil-Carter United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 3 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 Andre Carter US Marcia Cecil-Carter United States 9/11/2001 NY Spouse (Deceased) N/A N/A $12,500,000.00 [26] Devonte Carter 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 3 [27] Sunny Chiang US Alexander Chiang United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 3 Spouse N/A N/A $12,500,000.00 [28] Jacqueline Beard-Edwards US Michael Edwards United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 1 Spouse N/A N/A $12,500,000.00 [29] Howard Gelling Sr. US Howard Gelling United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 MDL ECF No. 10841 Parent N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [30] William Gelling US Howard Gelling United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 [31] Deborah Mulford US Howard Gelling United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 [32] Christine O'Reilly US Howard Gelling United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 Spouse N/A N/A $12,500,000.00 [33] Thomas Kelly US Maurice Kelly United States 9/11/2001 NY 23cv07283 23cv07283, 15 at 1 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [34] Catalina Louie US Chet Louie United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 3 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [35] Cassandra Louie US Chet Louie United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 3 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [36] Ken Yazawa Reibman US Chet Louie United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 3 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [37] Mary Lou Moss US Brian Moss United States 9/11/2001 VA 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 Spouse N/A N/A $12,500,000.00 [38] Connor Moss US Brian Moss United States 9/11/2001 VA 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [39] Ashten Moss US Brian Moss United States 9/11/2001 VA 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [40] Catherine Lyn-Shue US Francisco Munoz United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 1 Spouse N/A N/A $12,500,000.00 [41] Christopher Pohlmann US William H. Pohlmann United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 9 MDL ECF No. 10840 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [42] Darren Pohlmann US William H. Pohlmann United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 9 MDL ECF No. 10840 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [43] Jayme Salinardi US Richard Salinardi Jr. United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 5-6 MDL ECF No. 10840 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 [44] Grace Salinardi US Richard Salinardi Jr. United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 5-6 MDL ECF No. 10840 Parent N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [45] Jason Salinardi US Richard Salinardi Jr. United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 5-6 MDL ECF No. 10840 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 MDL ECF No. 10865 [46] Anthony Stewart Dorothy Belcher US Chapelle Sarker United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 Parent (Deceased) N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 (granted at 10869) [47] Anthony Stewart US Chapelle Sarker United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 2 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 [48] Michael Slavin US Vincent Slavin United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 1 Child N/A N/A $8,500,000.00 [49] Mary Jo Slavin US Vincent Slavin United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 1 Spouse N/A N/A $12,500,000.00 [50] Marcella Bittner Michael Bittner US Jeffrey Bittner United States 9/11/2001 NY 24cv05520 24cv05520, 1 at 3 MDL ECF No. 10887 Sibling (Deceased) N/A N/A $4,250,000.00 [51] Deirdre Ruddle US David Ruddle United States 9/11/2001 NY 22cv05193 22cv05193, 1 at 3 MDL ECF No. 10912 Sibling N/A N/A $4,250,000.00