2 E.D. Smith 184 | New York Court of Common Pleas | 1853
This judgment cannot be sustained. Dudderidge paid his fare for Canada at the defendant’s depot in New York, the only place where through
This witness’ testimony was of the most unreliable kind. He first swore that he delivered his baggage to the baggage master of the New York and New Haven train—that he demanded his valise when he arrived at New Haven, and was told by the baggage master that they were responsible if it could not be found—that he showed the check to the baggage master at New Haven, and asked him if the same check would be good for going any further, and was told that it would answer; and yet, upon his cross-examination, he swore that he took the valise with him into the cars at New York, and had it checked by a baggage master at New Haven. Taking his last statement to be the true one, his
Judgment reversed.