Stockard v. HamiltonStockard v. Hamilton
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Raynolds
(after stating the facts as above).
The question of garnishment of the salary of a state officer has been before this court on previous occasions, and it has been held that, in the absence of a statute clearly authorizing such action, a public, officer could not be summoned as garnishee, nor could the salary of a state officer be subject to garnishment. See First National Bank v. Scott, 22 N. M. 411, 163 Pac. 1084; Owen v. Terrell, 22 N. M. 373, 162 Pac. 171; S. W. Loan Co. v. Awalt, 22 N. M. 607, 166 Pac. 1181, L. R. A. 1917F, 1117.
A distinction is made in the last case cited, namely, S. W. Loan Co. v. Awalt, between a public officer whose
The act, so far as is material to this case, is as follows:
“In all cases where the plaintiff has a judgment in some court of the state against any public official or any employe of the state of New Mexico, any county, city, town, village, municipality or school district thereof, the salaries of any such public officials and the salaries or whges of any such person so employed by said state of New Mexico, or any such county, city, village, town, municipality or school district thereof, shall be subject to garnishment: Provided, nothing in this act shall be construed to impair the rights of such public officials or such employe of said state, county, city, town, villag‘e, municipality or school district to claim exemption of wages or salaries as provided herein. In all cases where the plaintiff has a judgment in some court of the state against the defendant, any public officer may be summonsed as garnishee and the return of such public officer shall be by a statement over his official signature of the amount due the defendant, which said statement shall be filed by such public officer without costs in the action.”
Section 2 repeals chapter 26, Laws 1915, and paragraph 2546, New Mexico Statutes Ann., Codification 1915.
From the plain language of the statute it is apparent that the Legislature intended that public officers could be summoned as garnishees, and also that the salary of public officials therein enumerated could be garnished, and unless such an enactment is contrary and repugnant to constitutional provisions, we are bound to uphold the
In support of his contention that these provisions are unconstitutional, the appellant urges that the office of district attorney is a constitutional one, created by the Constitution, and that the disbursing officers of the state have the right to pay the salary of this office for the purpose only for which it is designated, and that the Legislature cannot legislate that it shall be disbursed otherwise. The Contention is true, in case the office is one created by the Constitution, and when the qualifications, tenure, and emoluments therefor are fixed by that instrument ; but this does not apply to the office of district attorney. The Constitution itself makes no provision as to the emoluments of the office in question, but specifically provides that the district attorneys shall receive such salaries as may be provided by law, thereby giving to the Legislature the plenary power in this respect. Const, art. 6, § 24.
“No act of the Legislature shall affect the right or remedy of either party, or change the rules of evidence or procedure, in any pending’ case.”
The authorities as to what is a “pending case” are by no means uniform, and are of no great aid to the court in
Finding no error in the record, the judgment of the district court is affirmed; and it is so ordered.
Parker, C. J., and Eoberts, J., concur.