Stewart v. MillikenStewart v. Milliken
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Benham
Lead Opinion
In September 2001, the habeas corpus court found that Leonard Scott Milliken received ineffective assistance of appellate counsel at his trial and ordered that Milliken be given a new appeal. The State did not file an appeal from this ruling, see
Regarding the only ruling properly before us, the State does not enumerate any error as to the habeas corpus court’s July 2003 order. Our review of that order revealing nothing to indicate error, see generally In the Interest of H. A. M., 201 Ga. App. 49, 50 (410 SE2d 319) (1991), we affirm the habeas corpus court.
Judgment affirmed.
All the Justices concur, except Benham, Carley and Hines, JJ, who dissent.Notes
The State argues that it did not directly appeal from the habeas corpus court’s ruling because it had no objection with the remedy originally granted by that court, i.e., a new appeal, and that it was only when Milliken’s conviction was vacated and a new trial ordered by the court that it needed to assert its objections to the habeas corpus court’s ruling on ineffective assistance of appellate counsel. The State’s acquiescence in the original remedy fashioned by the habeas corpus court, however, does not excuse it from failing to file a timely appeal on the merits of issues the State would now contest. Furthermore, we note that the State knew that this Court was concerned with the remedy fashioned by the habeas corpus court when we granted Milliken’s appeal; that Milliken was asserting on appeal that he should have received a new trial; and that vacation of Milliken’s conviction would necessarily follow if (as indeed it did) this Court agreed with Milliken. The State’s argument thus falters in light of its inexplicable failure to file a cross appeal challenging the merits of the habeas corpus court’s ruling after Milliken’s appeal was granted. See Birts, supra (declining to reach merits of State’s arguments to merits of habeas corpus relief on basis that State did not file either a timely direct appeal or a timely cross appeal).
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting.
The majority summarily affirms the grant of habeas corpus relief in this case, concluding that the order of July 2003 is “the only ruling properly before us, [and Warden Stewart] does not enumerate any error as to . . . [that] order.” Majority opinion, page 660.1 submit that this holding violates the applicable statutory provisions which control the scope of our appellate jurisdiction.
The original order, which found certain grounds of Milliken’s habeas petition to be meritorious and ordered a new appeal, was entered in September of 2001. Milliken appealed and, in Milliken v. Stewart, 276 Ga. 712 (583 SE2d 30) (2003), this Court reversed solely on procedural grounds and held that the proper habeas remedy is the grant of a new trial, rather than a new appeal. Accordingly, the case was remanded with direction that the habeas court enter a new order granting a new trial. In so doing, we expressly noted that “[t]hat order will be subject to appeal by [the Warden].
Although the majority asserts that the original order of September 2001, which contains the findings and conclusions upon which the habeas court based its grant of relief, is not properly before us,
The majority chooses simply to ignore
The fallacy in the majority’s analysis becomes apparent once it is recognized that, on remand, the habeas court could have entered a new order which granted Milliken a new trial and restated the findings and conclusions upon which it relied for holding that he was entitled to habeas relief. Had such an order been entered, we unquestionably would have jurisdiction to consider the merits of the Warden’s claim that the restated findings and conclusions are erroneous and that Milliken is not entitled to a new trial. The habeas court, however, apparently made the logical determination that the order entered on remand in July 2003 did not need to contain a restatement of its findings and conclusions, since the original ruling of September 2001 remained in effect insofar as it set forth the reasons for its holding. The procedurally correct ruling entered on remand *662grants Milliken a new trial for the substantive reasons set forth in the original order entered in September 2001, which thus far have not been addressed on appeal. The remand order has now become the “final” judgment in this case. The Warden’s appeal from that final order necessarily encompasses all earlier rulings entered in the action, including the order of September 2001. Accordingly, the majority’s assertion that the Warden’s appeal is untimely under
As evidenced by footnote 1, what motivates the majority is the Warden’s failure to file either a direct appeal from the September 2001 order or a cross-appeal from Milliken’s appeal of that order. Clearly, the interest of judicial economy may have been promoted had either of those routes been followed by the Warden. However, the majority can cite no authority which supports the proposition that a litigant’s previous failure to follow an open avenue of appellate review is a valid ground for the appellate court to decline to exercise its jurisdiction over an otherwise valid current appeal. In fact, this Court has held otherwise. In Culwell v. Lomas & Nettleton Co., 242 Ga. 242 (248 SE2d 641) (1978), we made it clear that a party could appeal the grant of summary judgment under
The effect of today’s holding is to render meaningless this Court’s express recognition of the Warden’s right to bring this appeal pursuant to
I am authorized to state that Justice Benham and Justice Hines join in this dissent.