110 F. 372 | U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Northern Ohio | 1901
It appears from the proof in this case that the complainant, the Sterling Remedy Company, shortly before the year 1895, introduced into the market a laxative remedy containing the drug called in Spanish “cascara sagrada,” meaning “bitter bark,” combined with other ingredients calculated to produce the purgative or laxative effect upon persons using the remedy. The remedy was made up into dark brown, flat, slightly elongated, octagonal tablets, upon which, in a raised form, were the initials “C. C. C.” These tablets were put up in rectangular tin boxes, with rounded 'corners, the boxes having a gray-colored background. The boxes were lithographed in this color, with gilt and blue letterpress work. The name most prominently appearing in this letter press was “Cascareis,” with underneath, in gilt and somewhat similar letters, “Candy Cathartic.” There was other lettering upon the box in smaller type. The proof further shows that the defendant is a lawyer, and that in the year 1900 he prepared to make sales of cathartic remedies in a way which the complainant says is unfair, and which operates as an invasion of rights in business which it has acquired by extensive advertising. I, need not go closely into the matter of the comparison between the boxes and the tablets sold by the defendant and those introduced to the market prior thereto by the complainant. When a box sold by the defendant is compared with that. introduced by the complainant, such dissimilarities appear that there would be no difficulty in distinguishing the one from the other. There are similarities of effect upon the observer produced by the markings of the two boxes, and the ways in which they are