State v. Superior Lumber & Mill Co.State v. Superior Lumber & Mill Co.
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Parker
OPINION OP THE COURT.
.PARKER, J.This is an appeal by the State of New Mexico from a judgment entered by the District Court of Bernalillo county, dismissing the complaint of the state.
The complaint, filed by the state, alleges that property, real and personal, of the appellee, the Superior Lumber & Mill Company, a corporation, located in the county of Bernalillo, was assessed for taxation for the year 1915, for state, county, and other purposes and a
To this answer tbe district attorney filed a general demurrer, which simply stated that tbe answer did
The following propositions are raised and argued by the state*: (1) The state tax commission may make orders without having taken sworn evidence and on any information satisfactory to it; (2) the commission had power to make the order referred to in the answer at the alleged special meeting held in September; (3) the commission may certify omitted, incorrectly described, or inadequately described property without giving notice thereof to persons affected thereby; (4) that appellee was not deprived of due process of law, nor denied the equal protection of the law, nor was the order raising individual assessments arbitrary or made without authority; and (5) that the commission possessed authority to certify omitted property and assess the same. The appellee contends that as the demurrer was general it might have been disregarded by the trial court, but that having been considered it must be overruled if the facts stated, or facts properly inferable therefrom, will support the action of the court; that the denial of the indebtedness alleged to be due by appellant joined an issue which was not affected by the demurrer to the new matter alleged in the answer; that there is no admission in apXiellee’s second defense of the valid levying of an additional assessment against the proj>erty; and that the second defense does not admit that the commission raised appellee’s assessment • legally under section 6 of chapter 54, Laws 1915.
From this extended statement of the facts and the X>osition taken by counsel for the parties hereto it will be seen that the x>arties agree that the most important question in the case concerns the right and power of the state tax commission to raise individual assessments, or to certify and assess property which x>rima facie appears to have been omitted or incorrectly or inadequately described on the assessment rolls transmitted to the commission by the assessor; such action being taken by the commission at an alleged “special meeting.’ The
On the tax schedule, under the head of “Personal Property,” appears an item designated as “Merchandise, average stock for 1914.” Appellee asserts that its stock, furniture, and fixtures were returned under the latter head. Evidently the state tax commission, upon an investigation and inspection of the assessment rolls of Bernalillo county, concluded that the furniture and fixtures of the appellee had not been returned for taxation. Thereupon it made the order to which reference has heretofore been made.
The view we take of this case makes it unnecessary to detrmine many of the questions presented by the parties hereto. The issue tendered by the complaint was that appellee was indebted to the state in a certain sum on account of delinquent taxes levied upon an assessment of its property. This issue was met by a denial thereof on the part of appellee, and a defense by way of new matter alleging facts tending to show that appellee had paid all taxes legally assessed against it and disclosing that illegal acts on the part of the said commission resulted in increasing the amount of taxes chargeable against it.
We shall assume, for the purposes of this case, that the procedure adopted by said commission was according to law, and that its action was in all respects legal. Notwithstanding that assumption, however, the judgment of the trial court must be affirmed. In the answer by way of new matter it is alleged that the original assessment laid against its property included its stock, furniture, and fixtures, and was assessed at $6,100, and that such valuation plus the additional assessment of $26,422.05 thereon “is greatly in excess of the actual value of said property.” The general demurrer filed by the state, through the district attorney, of course admitted the truth of this allegation. Therefore, independent of all questions concerning the legality of the action of the commission in proceeding to certify the property of
“It is to be noticed that the word ‘injustice’ to the taxpayer is employed in this section. The word ‘injustice’ would seem to be the broadest term which the Legislature could have employed in this connection. Any case of overvaluation of the property by the taxpayer would seem clearly to be an injustice within the meaning of the act. It is to be further noticed that an injustice which is discovered after the tax rolls come into the hands of the collector is to be relieved against, under the terms of the section. *• * *”
We then proceeded to state that the action of the state board of equalization was not final, and that the action of the district attorney on the petition presented to him by the taxpayer is likewise not final, but that the aggrieved person, after resorting to all the means provided by law for the correction of the tax, might seek redress in the courts; the court saying:
‘The taxpayer who has been wronged by over-valuationof his property and who has had no notice of the action which results in injury, and who has applied to the district attorney without avail, certainly has the right to relief in the courts. If the taxpayer presents to the district attorney substantial evidence of the injustice complained of, and the district attorney refuses to act, his arbitrary refusal to submit the matter to the court would amount to legal fraud. This would bring the taxpayer clearly within the right to equitable relief against the excessive portion of the tax. * * *”
The appellee, in the ease at bar; was not required to resort to an injunction suit to obtain this relief. The defense was responsive to the issue tendered in the complaint by the state, and appellee’s right to relief was identical with the right if asserted in an equitable proceeding or suit. The demurrer having admitted that the property of appellee as finally assessed by the taxing officials was over-valued, and as such defense was clearly responsive to the issue tendered by the complaint of the state, the trial court did not err in sustaining the demurrer.
The judgment of the trial court will therefore be affirmed, and it is so ordered.
HANNA, C. J., and ROBERTS, J., concur.