State v. SmithState v. Smith
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Carpenter, Zachary, Collins
Attorney General Jeff Jackson, by Special Deputy Attorney General Dorian Woolaston, for the State.
Appellate Defender Glenn Gerding, by Assistant Appellant Defender Katy Dickinson-Schultz, for Defendant-Appellant.
CARPENTER, Judge.
Diante Smith (“Defendant”) appeals after the trial court revoked his probation and activated his sentence. On appeal, Defendant files a petition for writ of certiorari (“PWC”) and argues that the trial court erred by: (1) extending Defendant’s probation; and (2) revoking Defendant’s probation without jurisdiction. After careful review, we grant Defendant’s PWC and vacate the judgment revoking his probation and activating his sentence.
I. Factual & Procedural Background
On 5 January 2018, a grand jury in Craven County Superior Court indicted Defendant on twenty-two counts. On 19 November 2020, Defendant submitted an Alford plea on sixteen of those counts: one count of assault with a deadly weapon with intent to kill inflicting serious injury (“AWDWIKISI”), one count of extortion, three counts of larceny of a firearm, three counts of breaking or entering a motor vehicle, five counts of felony larceny, one count of felony breaking or entering, one count of possession of a stolen firearm, and one count of larceny of a firearm. In his plea, Defendant stipulated to restitution. The trial court sentenced Defendant to various terms of imprisonment for each charge, suspended the sentences for thirty-six months of supervised probation, and imposed court costs for each count. Evidence from the violation reports and hearings tended to show the following.
On 17 December 2021, the State filed a probation violation report, stating that Defendant had made no payments toward his supervision fees and was $130 in arrears. On 18 April 2022, at a hearing, the State asked to extend the probation by twenty-four months to reset the payment plan for Defendant’s restitution. Defendant’s counsel agreed with the State and said that he thought “this order [would] set it up so that any payments made [would] go towards restitution.” The trial court waived probation supervision fees, ordered Defendant to find gainful employment, and extended Defendant’s probation by twenty-four months. The trial court did not explicitly state that it found good cause under
In 2022, the State filed two more probation violation reports. On 21 June 2022, the State asserted that Defendant had tested positive for marijuana, methamphetamines, and amphetamines. On 21 October 2022, the State claimed that Defendant had failed to provide proof of employment and missed one payment toward court costs. Later, the trial court modified Defendant’s probation, ordering him to pay $200 per month in restitution “on each case that has restitution,” striking many court costs, and waiving supervision fees.
In 2024, the State filed three additional violation reports. The reports stated that Defendant violated several other conditions of his probation by: not obtaining employment, not reporting for an office appointment, moving to a new address without prior approval, refusing to provide the new address, not being in compliance, and absconding. During the probation revocation hearing, Defendant denied absconding.
On 20 December 2024, the trial court revoked Defendant’s probation and activated
II. Jurisdiction
As an initial matter, we must determine whether we have jurisdiction to review Defendant’s appeal. Defendant requests that this Court grant his PWC.
A. Untimely Appeal
Rule 4(a) states that “[a]ny party entitled by law to appeal from a judgment or order of a superior or district court rendered in a criminal action may take appeal by . . . filing notice of appeal with the clerk of superior court and serving copies thereof upon all adverse parties” within fourteen days of the judgment.
Here, Defendant failed to timely file his notice of appeal. See
B. PWC
Although Defendant may not appeal by right, this Court in its discretion may consider the matter by granting a PWC. See
Accordingly, a petitioner must satisfy a two-factor test. Id. at 572, 887 S.E.2d at 851. “First, a writ of certiorari should issue only if the petitioner can show ‘merit or that error was probably committed below.’ ” Id. at 572, 887 S.E.2d at 851 (quoting State v. Ricks, 378 N.C. 737, 741, 862 S.E.2d 835, 839 (2021)). “Second, a writ of certiorari should issue only if there are ‘extraordinary circumstances’ to justify it.” Id. at 572–73, 887 S.E.2d at 851 (quoting Moore v. Moody, 304 N.C. 719, 720, 285 S.E.2d 811, 812 (1982)). For example, an extraordinary circumstance may be “an unwarranted extension of probation . . . .” State v. Barton, 295 N.C. App. 182, 187, 905 S.E.2d 230, 234 (2024).
Here, in his PWC, Defendant has met his burden in showing that an error was probably committed below and that there are extraordinary circumstances. See Cryan, 384 N.C. at 572–73, 887 S.E.2d at 851. The trial court probably erred by extending Defendant’s probation before the final six months of his original period and by failing to check the box on its judgment form that good cause was shown. See id. at 572, 887 S.E.2d at 851. Defendant has also shown that this is an extraordinary circumstance because the trial court erroneously extended his probation. See id. at 572–73, 887 S.E.2d at 851; Barton, 295 N.C. App. at 187, 905 S.E.2d at 234. Accordingly, we grant Defendant’s PWC.
III. Issues
The issues on appeal are whether the trial court erred by: (1) extending Defendant’s probation; and (2) revoking Defendant’s probation without jurisdiction.
IV. Analysis
A. Standard of Review
“ ‘Alleged statutory errors are questions of law’ reviewed de novo on appeal.” State v. Porter, 282 N.C. App. 351, 352, 870 S.E.2d 148, 150 (2022) (quoting State v. Mackey, 209 N.C. App. 116, 120, 708 S.E.2d 719, 721 (2011)). Also, “[t]his Court reviews de novo the issue of whether a trial court had subject matter jurisdiction to revoke a defendant’s probation.” State v. Moore, 240 N.C. App. 461, 462, 771 S.E.2d 766, 767 (2015)
B. Probation Extension
First, Defendant argues that the trial court erred because it did not have his consent or good cause to extend his probation in 2022. We agree.
1. Consent under Section 15A-1342(a)
“[T]he court with the consent of the defendant may extend the period of probation beyond the original period . . . for the purpose of allowing the defendant to complete a program of restitution . . . .”
Here, the trial court was without statutory authority to extend Defendant’s probation in accordance with the special extension statute. See
2. Good Cause under Section 15A-1344(d)
Additionally, “[a]t any time prior to the expiration or termination of the probation period . . . the court may after notice and hearing and for good cause shown extend the period of probation up to the maximum allowed . . . .”
Here, the trial court did not make a finding of good cause for the extension. See
Consequently, the trial court lacked authority under
C. Probation Revocation
Next, Defendant contends that, because the trial court improperly extended his probation in 2022, the trial court did not have jurisdiction to revoke his probation in 2024. We agree.
A trial court can extend or modify probation at “any time prior to the expiration or termination of the probation period . . . .”
Here, the trial court did not maintain jurisdiction over Defendant. See
IV. Conclusion
We grant certiorari and conclude the trial court lacked jurisdiction to revoke Defendant’s probation. Accordingly, we vacate and remand for further proceedings.
VACATED AND REMANDED.
Judges ZACHARY and COLLINS concur.