State v. Orsi/GauthierState v. Orsi/Gauthier
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- De Muniz
In these two appeals, consolidated for opinion, defendants challenge departure sentences imposed under the sentencing guidelines.
Under the sentencing guidelines, a trial court must impose the presumptive sentence provided by the guidelines unless “the judge finds substantial and compelling reasons to impose a departure,” which must be stated “on the record at the time of sentencing * * *.”
“shall be limited to whether the sentencing court’s findings of fact and reasons justifying a departure from the sentence prescribed by the rules of the State Sentencing Guidelines Board:
“(a) Are supported by the evidence in the record; and
“(b) Constitute substantial and compelling reasons for departure.”ORS 138.222(3) .
The trial court in
Orsi
stated that the departure sentence was imposed in order that defendant, who suffers from a manic-depressive condition, could undergo a mental health treatment program. In
Gauthier,
the trial court imposed a departure because of defendant’s “ongoing involvement” in similar crimes; because the victim
The state argues that defendants failed to preserve any alleged error. We agree. Before the 1989 enactment of sentencing guidelines, the scope of review of an appeal from a sentence after a plea of guilty was limited to a challenge that the sentence exceeded the maximum allowable by law or was unconstitutionally cruel and unusual.
The argument that the court’s reasons for departure are not “substantial and compelling” is not an error of law that may be reviewed as “apparent on the face of the record.” ORAP 5.45(2); see State v. Brown, 310 Or 347, 800 P2d 259 (1990); cf State v. Montgomery, 106 Or App 150, 806 P2d 183 (1991) (question of authority of sentencing court to order car to be sold is apparent on the face of the record and could be considered notwithstanding a failure to object).
Imposition of a departure sentence is a discretionary determination by the sentencing court.
Affirmed.