State v. MezinsState v. Mezins
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Parks
This is an interlocutory appeal taken by the State pursuant to
Trooper Stackhouse of the Kansas Highway Patrol arrived at an accident scene on January 18, 1979, to find a car stuck in a snowbank. He was informed by a “good Samaritan,” who stopped to lend assistance, that defendant Arwit Mezins was the only person who got out of the car. Defendant, however, stated he was only a passenger and that his friend, Jerry, was the driver of the vehicle. The physical evidence at the scene — one set of footprints in the snow by the wrecked vehicle and condensation on the driver’s side of the floorboard — also indicated that the defendant was alone in the car. The officer observed Mezins to have a strong odor of alcohol, slurred speech and coordination difficulty, leading him to believe defendant was intoxicated. After Mezins was transported to the hospital, Stackhouse placed him under arrest, informed him of his
Miranda
rights, and requested a blood sample. Defendant signed a consent form and a blood sample was taken by a physician. A later analysis revealed a .27
*293
percent blood alcohol content by weight. When advised that defendant was to be admitted to the hospital, Stackhouse testified that he “unarrested” the defendant and asked the hospital staff to notify the Kansas Highway Patrol when defendant was released because there would be charges pending against him. On January 23,. 1979, Trooper Stackhouse picked up the defendant at the hospital and transported him to jail where he was charged with felony theft (this charge was later dismissed) and driving under the influence of intoxicating liquor (
Although neither party has raised the issue, we note that the district court failed to make findings of fact and conclusions of law pursuant to Rule 165 of the Supreme Court and
The governing statute in this case is
“(a) Any person who operates a motor vehicle upon a public highway in this state shall be deemed to have given consent to submit to a chemical test of breath or blood, for the purpose of determining the alcoholic content of his or her blood whenever he or she shall be arrested or otherwise taken into custody for any offense involving operating a motor vehicle under the influence of intoxicating liquor in violation of a state statute or a city ordinance and the arresting officer has reasonable grounds to believe that prior to arrest the person was driving under the influence of intoxicating liquor. The text shall be administered at the direction of the arresting officer ....
“(c) If the person so arrested refuses a request to submit to a test of breath or blood, it shall not be given and the arresting officer shall make to the division of vehicles of the state department of revenue a sworn report of the refusal, stating that prior to the arrest the officer had reasonable grounds to believe that the person was driving under the influence of intoxicating liquor. Upon receipt of the report, the division immediately shall notify such person of his or her right to be heard on the issue of the reasonableness of the failure to submit to the test . . . .”
Defendant contends that an arresting officer has a duty to inform an accused of his right to refuse a blood alcohol test, and failure to do so renders the test results inadmissible. In Hazlett v. *294 Motor Vehicle Department, 195 Kan. 439, 442, 407 P.2d 551 (1965), our Supreme Court considered a similar question of whether an arresting officer is required to explain the consequences of a refusal to submit to a blood alcohol chemical test. In holding that no such duty existed, the Court noted:
“In the first place a careful scrutiny of the statuteK.S.A. 8-1001 . . . fails to reveal any mandate directing the arresting officer to inform the accused of the consequences of refusal.”
We, like the Supreme Court, are reluctant to write something into the statute not included by the legislature. We conclude that there is no statutory authority compelling an arresting officer to inform a motorist of his right to refuse a chemical test under
Defendant also argues that the test results were the product of an involuntary consent and therefore inadmissible.
We interpret the “implied consent statute,”
*295
The final issue presented is whether Officer Stackhouse’s “unarrest” of defendant voided the initial arrest thereby rendering the seizure of defendant’s blood inadmissible. Stackhouse testified that if defendant remained in the hospital under arrest he would have to be under continuous guard; his reason for “unarresting” defendant was to obviate the requirement for a guard. It is clear Stackhouse did not inform defendant of the “unarrest” but requested hospital authorities to notify the patrol of defendant’s release. It is equally clear that Stackhouse still had reason to believe defendant had committed the crime at the time of the “unarrest”; therefore
Here the blood sample was taken incidental to defendant’s valid arrest and consent. What took place later had no bearing upon that arrest or the admissibility of the chemical test. In an analogous situation the Court in People v. Superior Court In and For the County of San Mateo, 35 Cal. App. 3d 1, 6, 110 Cal. Rptr. 504 (1973), said that the failure to maintain close police custody oyer a hospitalized suspect, or to place a police hold on him, did not reasonably or retroactively affect the validity of an otherwise lawful arrest at the accident scene. We agree with that ruling and hold that Officer Stackhouse’s statement that he “unarrested” defendant did not vitiate the legality of defendant’s arrest or the results of the blood test.
We conclude that the suppression of the results of defendant’s blood test was erroneous.
Judgment is reversed.