State v. LinvilleState v. Linville
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Schultz
OPINION
SCHULTZ, ** Judge.The state appeals the district court’s pretrial order dismissing the complaint against appellant for carrying a pistol without a permit. We reverse and remand.
FACTS
On August 7, 1998, respondent Ronald Clifford Linville was at the Minneapolis/St. Paul airport en route from his home in Victoria, Minnesota, to Portsmouth, Rhode Island. Respondent was traveling to Rhode Island to attend a staff meeting at his employer’s headquarters. While at the airport, security personnel discovered a handgun in respondent’s carry-on suitcase as it went through the x-ray scanner. Upon request, respondent was unable to produce a permit for the gun.
Respondent was charged with possession of a pistol without a permit, a gross misdemeanor, in violation of
ISSUES
I. Is the state entitled to bring this appeal?
II. Did the district court err in ruling that respondent was not required to have a permit for his handgun?
ANALYSIS
I. Right to Appeal
The state may appeal from any pretrial order “except an order dismissing a complaint for lack of probable cause.”
Here, the district court interpreted
II.
The interpretation of a statute presents a legal issue, which we review de novo. Hibbing Educ. Ass’n v. Public Employment Relations Bd., 369 N.W.2d 527, 529 (Minn.1985) (statutory construction is question of law); see Frost-Benco Elec. Ass’n v. Minnesota Pub. Utils. Comm’n, 358 N.W.2d 639, 642 (Minn.1984) (appellate court need not defer to district court’s analysis of purely legal issues).
When interpreting a statute, an appellate court must “ascertain and effectuate the intention of the legislature.”
A person ⅜ * ⅜ who carries, holds or possesses a pistol * * ⅜ on or about the person’s clothes or the person, or otherwise in possession or control in a public place or public area without first having obtained a permit to carry the pistol is guilty of a gross misdemeanor.
A permit is not required, however, for the person “[t]o carry a pistol between the person’s dwelling house and place of business.”
intended to prevent the possession of firearms in places where they are most likely to cause harm in the wrong hands, i.e., in public places where their discharge may injure or kill intended or unintended victims. The only exception to this rule is for persons who have demonstrated a need or purpose for carrying firearms and have shown their responsibility to the police in obtaining a permit.
State v. Paige, 256 N.W.2d 298, 303 (Minn.1977). Further, the subdivision 9(c) exception is to be “construed narrowly to avoid negating the general rule that a permit is required to carry a handgun.” State v. Poupard, 471 N.W.2d 686, 691 (Minn.App.1991).
Here, the district court interpreted
Under the district court’s interpretation, any person traveling between home and the person’s place of employment, no matter how far away or how indirect the route, could carry a handgun without a permit. Such an interpretation, we believe, could result in a substantially increased number of persons carrying handguns without a permit and, therefore, must be rejected. See Poupard, 471 N.W.2d at 690 (rejecting expansive interpretation that “would substantially broaden the spectrum of conduct” not requiring a permit).
Further, to allow a person to possess a handgun without a permit in a public place, such as an airport, directly contradicts the statute’s intended prohibition against guns in public places. And to accept the interpretation in its entirety would mean condoning the possession of handguns on commercial airliners, a violation of federal law.
See
One other permit exception also addresses carrying handguns from one place to another. Under MinmStat.
We conclude that the legislature intended to limit the subdivision 9(c) exception to travel between home and place of business when the two are in reasonable proximity to each other. Accordingly, respondent’s conduct did not fit within the subdivision 9(c) exception.
DECISION
The district court erred in ruling that, under
Reversed and remanded.
Notes
Retired judge of the district court, serving as judge of the Minnesota Court of Appeals by appointment pursuant to