State v. HarmonState v. Harmon
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Lagesen, Tookey, Jacquot
LAGESEN, C. J.
Remanded for resentencing; otherwise affirmed.
LAGESEN, C. J.
Defendant appeals a judgment of conviction, entered after a conditional guilty plea, for one count of driving under the influence of intoxicants,
Motion to Suppress. Defendant argues that the trial court erred when it determined that the officer who stopped him had probable cause to believe that defendant had failed to stay within a lane in violation of
Reviewing for legal error and accepting the trial court‘s explicit and implicit findings of fact that are supported by the record, Husk, 288 Or App at 739 (setting forth our standard of review), we conclude that the trial court did not err.
As relevant here, when operating a vehicle on “a roadway that is divided into two or more clearly marked lanes for traffic,” a driver “commits the offense of failure to drive within a lane” if the driver does not “[o]perate the vehicle as nearly as practicable entirely within a single lane.”
We disagree. We need not definitively resolve what it means to be a “momentary and minor lane deviation” under Little and we acknowledge, as did the trial court, that defendant‘s lane deviation was temporally short. Defendant‘s departure from his lane as described by the officer and illustrated by photographs entered into evidence, although quick in time, cannot plausibly be characterized as “minor.” The officer testified that he first observed defendant‘s truck approaching when the truck was nearly 200 feet away from where the officer was parked in the shoulder. At the time, defendant‘s truck was rounding a slight curve, and more than half of defendant‘s truck was driving over the fog line. As one of the photos entered into evidence indicates, defendant‘s conduct reasonably could be described as driving mostly in the shoulder, and mostly outside of the designated lane. When the truck reached the officer‘s location, defendant‘s truck was, in the officer‘s words, “more in its lane of travel” but still over the fog line. Considering those circumstances—the degree to which defendant‘s truck was over the fog line and the distance that defendant covered while his truck was not “entirely” within its lane—defendant‘s lane deviation was not in any sense minor. Compare Little, 326 Or App at 790 (deviation from traffic lane “minor” when one tire on the defendant‘s car crossed a fog line by approximately six inches), with State v. Koteen, 344 Or App 533-34, ___ P3d ___ (2025) (deviation from traffic lane not “minor” where, among other facts, approximately “half” of defendant‘s car was in a bicycle lane and it was “occupying much of, if not most of, that bicycle lane“). On those facts, the trial court was correct to conclude that the officer‘s observations of defendant gave him probable cause to believe defendant violated
Remanded for resentencing; otherwise affirmed.