State v. FernState v. Fern
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Richardson
Defendant pled no contest to a charge of assault.
Defendant first assigns error to the trial court’s alleged failure to allow him his right of allocution at his sentencing hearing. Or Const, Art I, § 11. He relies on DeAngelo v. Schiedler, 306 Or 91, 757 P2d 1355 (1988), in which the trial court had refused to hear the defendant when she tried to speak at her sentencing. The Supreme Court held that the Oregon Constitution gives a defendant the right to be heard at sentencing and that that right had been violated by the trial court’s action. However, it did not hold that a defendant may claim a denial of the right to speak without having objected in the sentencing court. To the contrary, it noted that “[the defendant] should have attempted to make an ‘offer of proof of what she was going to say to the court,” 306 Or at 98, although, under the circumstances of that case, the court concluded that an offer of proof would have been futile.
Review of a claim that a sentencing court failed to follow a constitutional mandate in imposing the sentence is subject to review under
Defendant was sentenced within the presumptive range and he assigns error to the trial court’s failure to impose a downward departure sentence.
2
See
Affirmed.
Notes
There is no error “apparent on the face of the record.” Defendant’s failure to speak at sentencing, without more, does not show that defendant was denied the right to speak. ORAP 5.45(2).
At the sentencing hearing, witnesses testified and defendant’s counsel presented arguments in support of mitigation.