History
  • No items yet
midpage
State v. Davis
58 S.E.2d 355
N.C.
1950
Check Treatment
Stacy, C. J.

Tbe following excerpt from tbe charge forms tbe basis of one of tbe defendant’s exceptive assignments of error:

“Tbe defendant further contends and says that be has offered evidence that be bears tbe general reputation of being a man of good moral character. Tbe court instructs you that that is substantive evidence bearing upon tbe defendant’s credibility as a witness, that is, bis worthiness of belief when be testified in this case for himself.”

It seems quite probable that something may have been omitted by tbe reporter in transcribing tbe portion of tbe charge here assigned as error. However this may be, tbe record imports verity and we are bound by it. S. v. Dee, 214 N.C. 509, 199 S.E. 730; Gorham v. Ins. Co., 215 N.C. 195, 1 S.E. 2d 569.

Speaking to a similar instruction in the case of S. v. Moore, 185 N.C. 637, 116 S.E. 161, Hoke, J., delivering tbe opinion of tbe Court, commented as follows:

“It is fully recognized in this jurisdiction that in an indictment for crime, a defendant may offer evidence of bis good character and have same considered as substantive testimony on tbe issue of bis guilt or innocence. And where in such case a defendant has testified in bis own behalf and evidence of bis good character is received from him, it may be considered both as affecting tbe credibility of bis testimony and as substantive evidence on the issue. In re McKay, 183 N.C. 226-228; S. v. Morse, 171 N.C. 777; S. v. Cloninger, 149 N.C. 578; S. v. Traylor, 121 N.C. 674; S. v. Hice, 117 N.C. 782.” See, also, S. v. McMahan, 228 N.C. 293, 45 S.E. 2d 340; S. v. Wagstaff, 219 N.C. 15, 12 S.E. 2d 657; S. v. Ferrell, 202 N.C. 475, 163 S.E. 563; S. v. Whaley, 191 N.C. 387, 132 S.E. 6.

Following tbe precedent set in tbe Moore Case, a new trial will be ordered here.

New trial.

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Davis
Court Name: Supreme Court of North Carolina
Date Published: Mar 20, 1950
Citation: 58 S.E.2d 355
Docket Number: 289
Court Abbreviation: N.C.
AI-generated responses must be verified and are not legal advice.