State v. AlmenteroState v. Almentero
- Before:
- Zamora, David K. Thomson, Michael E. Vigil, C. Shannon Bacon, Julie J. Vargas
DECISION
ZAMORA, Justice.
I. INTRODUCTION
{1} Defendant, Julio Almentero, appeals his convictions for two counts of first-degree felony murder, contrary to
II. BACKGROUND
{2} Defendant was convicted of two counts of first-degree felony murder for the killing of Lateef and Romero and now appeals his sentence of life imprisonment. See
{3} We adopt the recitation of facts as provided in State v. Goldman, discussing the circumstances surrounding the killings and Defendant‘s ensuing trial. See S-1-SC-40100, dec. ¶¶ 3-7 (N.M. June 30, 2025) (nonprecedential).
III. DISCUSSION
{4} “The propriety of jury instructions given or denied is a mixed question of law and fact” which we review de novo. State v. Salazar, 1997-NMSC-044, ¶ 49, 123 N.M. 778, 945 P.2d 996. We review Defendant‘s preserved arguments for reversible error and the unpreserved arguments for fundamental error. State v. Benally, 2001-NMSC-033, ¶ 12, 131 N.M. 258, 34 P.3d 1134.1
A. The District Court‘s Response to the Jury‘s Question Was an Accurate Statement of the Law That Did Not Result in Reversible Error
{5} Defendant argues the district court erred by misstating the law when it responded “yes” to the jury‘s question about whether it could return convictions for both second-degree murder and felony murder. The State argues the district court did not err because it accurately responded to the jury‘s question, which was based on the jury instruction it had been provided. We considered the identical argument in Goldman and agreed with the state. See S-1-SC-40100, dec. ¶¶ 10-11. We reach the same conclusion here, based on the same analysis, which we adopt by reference. See id.
B. Defendant‘s Remaining Challenges to the Jury Instruction Did Not Result in Fundamental Error
{6} Defendant‘s remaining challenges to the jury instructions were unpreserved. We therefore review them for fundamental error. See Benally, 2001-NMSC-033, ¶ 12. Fundamental error analysis requires that the Court first determine “whether error occurred” and, if so, “whether the error is fundamental.” State v. Romero, 2023-NMSC-014, ¶ 6, 533 P.3d 735 (internal quotation marks and citations omitted). Because we conclude there was no error in this case, we hold there was no fundamental error.
1. The lack of a jury instruction for second-degree murder as a lesser-included offense of felony murder did not result in fundamental error
{7} Defendant argues that the district court erred in failing to instruct the jury on second-degree murder as a lesser-included offense of felony murder, which resulted in fundamental error because it amounted to a failure to instruct on the essential element of causation for felony murder. Specifically, Defendant argues that the district court erred in not giving
{8} First, the district court did not err in failing to give a jury instruction that was not requested by the parties. Our case law has consistently held that it is the defendant‘s “duty to make the tactical decision whether or not to seek jury instructions on lesser degrees of homicide supported by the evidence, and we repeatedly have held that the defendant cannot be heard to complain if the trial court instructed the jury as he desired.” State v. Boeglin, 1987-NMSC-002, ¶ 10, 105 N.M. 247, 731 P.2d 943 (citing decades of cases in support).
{9} Second, as explained in Goldman, Defendant‘s argument lacks merit because the felony-murder instruction includes an explicit causation element, which Defendant has not challenged as an incomplete or misleading statement of the law. See Goldman, S-1-SC-40100, dec. ¶ 13; see also
2. Defendant failed to show fundamental error in the felony-murder and aiding-and-abetting jury instructions
{10} Defendant argues that the use of alternatives within the felony murder and aiding-and-abetting felony murder instructions made “them [im]possible to be properly
a. The use of and/or to separate predicate felonies of kidnapping and armed robbery did not result in fundamental error
{11} Defendant argues his conviction must be reversed under State v. Taylor because “[i]t is impossible to tell what ground the jury relied on” where both the felony-murder and aiding-and-abetting instructions used and/or to separate the predicate felonies of kidnapping and armed robbery. See Taylor, 2024-NMSC-011, ¶ 21, 548 P.3d 82. The State disagrees with Defendant‘s characterization of Taylor and its application to this case. Again, Defendant‘s argument is identical to that presented in Goldman, where we agreed with the state. See Goldman, S-1-SC-40100, dec. ¶¶ 15-17. We therefore reach the same conclusion in this case for the reasons set forth in Goldman. See id.
b. The aiding-and-abetting instruction on both Romero‘s and Lateef‘s murders did not result in fundamental error
{12} Defendant also argues that the aiding-and-abetting instruction caused juror confusion because the single instruction required the jury to determine whether Defendant aided and abetted both Lateef‘s and Romero‘s murders. The aiding-and-abetting instruction required the jury to find, that “[d]uring the commission of the felony . . . Romero and/or . . . Lateef was killed.” Defendant argues the reference to both murders in the same jury instruction departed from the UJI, which is written to apply to a single crime. See
{13} Again, Defendant‘s argument mirrors the argument presented in Goldman, and we therefore adopt the relevant analysis from that case. As in Goldman, Defendant has failed to establish that the instructions given in this case were erroneous or resulted in jury confusion. Goldman, S-1-SC-40100, dec. ¶ 19.
{14} In sum, the jury instruction‘s use of and/or and its reference to multiple felony murders, victims, and predicate felonies did not result in error, let alone fundamental error, under the facts of this case. See Adamo, 2018-NMCA-013, ¶ 27 (noting that when there is no reversible error, there can be no fundamental error).
IV. CONCLUSION
{15} For the reasons stated above, we affirm the district court on all issues raised in this appeal.
{16} IT IS SO ORDERED.
BRIANA H. ZAMORA, Justice
WE CONCUR:
DAVID K. THOMSON, Chief Justice
MICHAEL E. VIGIL, Justice
C. SHANNON BACON, Justice
JULIE J. VARGAS, Justice