STATE EX REL., WILCOX v. StrandSTATE EX REL., WILCOX v. Strand
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Morgan
Lead Opinion
The South Dakota Department of Social Services, Child Support Enforcement Division (Department) appeals from an order denying its request to modify a child support determination between Raymond Wilcox (Raymond) and Judy Strand (Judy). We affirm.
This action appears to be the latest in a series of disputes between the biological parents of a male child (Child) born on August 1, 1978. Litigation began with a hotly contested paternity suit. The result was a determination of Raymond’s paternity of Child and the imposition of the result*257ant requirement for support. Shortly thereafter, Raymond sought termination of Judy’s parental rights and permanent custody of Child. He also sought to change Child’s surname. After trial in that action, Judy was awarded custody subject to Raymond’s right to reasonable visitation. In 1982, at Raymond’s instigation, Judy signed a stipulation agreeing to permanent custody in Raymond, with reasonable visitation rights in her. It also authorized change of Child’s surname. The stipulation further provided that Raymond would be “solely and exclusively financially liable and responsible for the temporal welfare” of Child and that “[Judy] shall owe no child support to [Raymond].” Although the stipulation was filed, it was not presented to the court for approval. Nevertheless, the parties apparently abided by it for several years.
In 1986, however, Raymond petitioned the trial court to require Judy to make child support payments. Judy’s response was a request that the court enforce the earlier judgment vesting custody in her. Following an adversarial hearing at which both parties were represented by counsel, the trial court determined that Child’s best interests were served by continuing custody with Raymond. The trial court further found that Raymond was financially able to support Child at a high standard of living; that Judy, on the other hand, was a full-time housewife and mother, with no income, and that Judy’s financial condition was such that she was unable to make a financial contribution to Child’s support beyond that which she made during his visits with her. The trial court denied Raymond’s request for child support beyond the requirement that Judy pay the costs of travel for Child’s visits with her.
That judgment was entered on September 21, 1987. Almost immediately thereafter, on October 18, 1987, Raymond sought the aid of Department to overturn the judgment. By means of an affidavit signed by a Special Assistant Attorney General, Department secured an order to show cause why Judy should not pay child support. The basis for the order was the allegation in the affidavit that the trial court had violated
On appeal, Department raises one issue: Whether
We strongly suggest, however, that it is not the province of this court to brief the cases for delinquent counsel who are happy to jump into the fray but unwilling to continue to see it out to the end. Nor do we deem it the office of a Special Assistant Attorney General to make a determination that an issue is so frivolous or unlikely to succeed that the issue can merely be ignored. Some aspects of this child support scheme have been called into question on constitutional grounds so that Department and the attorney general are on notice that some doubts do exist.
*258Returning to State’s issue on appeal, our standard of review has traditionally been whether the trial court exercised discretion in setting child support obligations. We have refused to disturb child support obligations unless it appears that the trial court has abused its discretion. Rykhus v. Rykhus, 319 N.W.2d 167 (S.D.1982). This discretion has centered on the reasonable needs of the child and the obligor’s ability to pay. Gross v. Gross, 355 N.W.2d 4 (S.D.1984).
In 1984, the legislature enacted the statute providing for minimum child support guidelines, now codified as
Department contends that the trial court abused its discretion by not ordering Judy to pay child support in spite of the fact that she was then unemployed, was caring for her children, ages five and three, and her husband was at that time also unemployed. It argues that the trial court may not deviate from the statutory guidelines of
The deviation factors, five in number, set out in
The trial court found that (1) Raymond and his new spouse earn between $24,600 and $27,600 a year; (2) Judy has no income and her husband earns less than $12,000 a year and (3) Judy has four persons in her household including two small children, while Raymond has three persons in his household, including Child. The trial court also recognized that Judy provides transportation and support for Child when he visits. These findings are clearly supported by the evidence and we find no abuse of discretion on the part of the trial court. We do, however, find a kind of arrogance on the part of counsel for Department in pressing this appeal. It is obvious that he would have the courts apply the statute with the same blind ineptitude that we decried on the part of the hearing examiner in Bruning, supra.
Further, we do not believe that the child support enforcement scheme was enacted to give a parent another tool to harass the other parent. When there has been a recent judicial determination, in this case within one month, without any change of circumstances, it would appear to us that Department has sufficient caseload without creating more. We suggest that it apply its efforts to enforcement against parents who have not been adjudicated or who have failed to make the payments previously mandated. The burden on the judicial caseload enhanced by this sort of action and appeal is not appreciated.
We affirm the judgment of the trial court.
SABERS, J., concurs. HENDERSON, J., concurs with writing. WUEST, C.J., and MILLER, J., concur in result.Notes
The trial court judgment provided that, if and when Judy obtained employment, she shall pay child support in accordance with
Concurrence Opinion
(concurring).
In concurring, I note, with agreement, the majority’s reference to Bruning v. Jeffries, 422 N.W.2d 579, 581 (S.D.1988), wherein this Court held that the passage of
The child support guidelines of
Recognizing that this is not the occasion to knead the wrinkles out of the statutory cloth woven during the 1989 legislative session, I observe the extensive revision of SDCL Ch. 25-7 contained in 1989 S.D.Sess. L. Ch. 220, effective July 1, 1989 (H.B. 1081). Section 10 of that act provides that deviation from the child support guidelines, if raised by either party, may be made upon entry of specific findings based upon, inter alia, “[a]ny financial condition of either parent which would make application of the schedule inequitable.” (emphasis supplied). This statutory language appears to indicate that the legislature has recognized the necessity for equity in these cases, in derogation of the lockstep mentality disapproved in both the majority’s and this author’s writings in Bruning.
On the basis that the trial court reached an equitable result by exercising its discretion, I concur.
Concurrence Opinion
(concurring in result).
I concur in the result reached by the majority, but write specially to disassociate myself from the remarks directed at counsel and the Department.
Concurrence Opinion
(concurring in result).
I agree with the majority’s holding, but like the Chief Justice, I specifically disassociate myself from the last three sentences of the concluding paragraph.