State ex rel. Sullivan v. Mount

21 La. Ann. 755 | La. | 1869

Wtly, J.

Tbe Attorney General, on tbe information of James P. Sullivan and otliors claiming to be members of the “ Board of School Directors for the city of New Orleans,” under act of tenth March, 1809, instituted this proceeding against the defendants under act No. 156 of the acts of 1808; commonly known as the “ intrusion act,” alleging that the defendants have intruded into or unlawfully hold and exercise the office of “Board of Directors of the Public Schools of the city of New Orleans,” which said office it is averred belongs to said informers, James r. Sullivan and others, together with all the.books, papers and other propelty pertaining thereto. The court a qua gave judgment for the defendants, from which plaintiff took no appeal. N. C. Kendall, however, claiming to be the secretary of the “Board of School •Directors of the city of New Orleans,” organized under the act of tenth March, 1809, took a devolutive appeal, alleging that his salary is $1800 per annum, “ and that he has an interest of more than five hundred dollars pending on the result of this suit.”

The case is now presented on a motion to dismiss the appeal on various grounds; the most important ones seem to be, viz :

First — The want of jurisdiction, the matter in dispute not exceeding five hundred dollars, and appellant’s interest in the matter in dispute not exceeding five hundred dollars.

Second — That as the proceeding is by the State under the ‘^intrusion act,” no appeal can be taken by N. C. Kendall, a third person.

It is quite evident that the motion to dismiss is well taken.

What is the matter in dispute t

It is the office of School Directors, and books and papers and other property pertaining thereto.

To these the appellant sets up no claim whatever.

His office, secretary of the board, is not in dispute.

From his own statements we cannot perceive that he has any interest whatever in the matter..

It is therefore ordered that this appeal be dismissed at appellant's costs.