State Ex Rel. Spire v. StodolaState Ex Rel. Spire v. Stodola
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- White
This is an appeal from an order of the district court for Dodge County affirming a judgment entered by the county court.
Appellant, Randall J. Stodola, was a patient at the Hastings Regional Center from February 14toMarch7,1983.
In this case DPI determined that appellant was liable for the full cost of his care. This determination was based on a presumption of “ability to pay” which arose out of appellant’s failure to provide DPI with complete information regarding his assets, specifically, an insurance authorization form.
Subsequent to DPI’s determination, no payments were made by appellant on the amount due. Consequently, the State filed an action against Stodola, pursuant to
Appellant’s sole assignment of error alleges that the court erred in not finding DPI rule 2-(3) (1975) invalid as being broader than
The statutes and DPI rule relevant to the question on appeal in this matter are set out below. Section 83-368 (Reissue 1981) provides:
The department shall determine the ability of a patient to pay by consideration of the following factors: (1) Taxable income reportable under Nebraska law; (2) the patient’s age; (3) the number of his dependents and their ages and mental and physical conditions; (4) the patient’s length of care or treatment; (5) his liabilities; and (6) his assets.
DPI rule 2-(3) provides as follows:
FAILURE TO FURNISH INFORMATION. When any patient or relative willfully fails to furnish financial information (includes but is not necessarily limited to a copy of their state tax return and a completed financial questionnaire) to the Department within 20 days from the date requested, such person/s shall be deemed to have the ability to pay the full cost of any care, support, maintenance and treatment rendered to the patient. The Department may give consideration to extenuating circumstances with regard to the 20 day limitation.
(Emphasis supplied.)
At trial appellant argued that DPI’s determination of his ability to pay was improper and invalid because it did not comport with the statutes which authorize such determinations. The question to be answered on this appeal is whether there existed a valid and proper DPI determination of ability to pay which could constitute the basis for a money judgment against appellant. We find that the determination was improper and thus cannot be the basis for a judgment against appellant.
Section 83-368, quoted above, sets forth factors to be considered in determining a
patient’s
ability to pay.
There is no doubt that the Legislature can delegate to an administrative agency the power to make rules and regulations to implement the policy of a statute. County of Dodge v. Department of Health, 218 Neb. 346, 355 N.W.2d 775 (1984). However, the agency is limited in its rulemaking authority to the powers delegated to it by the statute which it is to administer. Id. In order to be valid, a rule or regulation must be consistent with the statute under which the rule or regulation is promulgated. Id.; United States v. Larionoff, 431 U.S. 864, 97 S. Ct. 2150, 53 L. Ed. 2d 48 (1977).
DPI has promulgated a rule, rule 2-(3), which enables that agency to exercise powers beyond those
actually
delegated to it by the Legislature. Furthermore, rule 2-(3) is not consistent with
This court has previously held that in the absence of anything indicating to the contrary, statutory language is to be given its plain and ordinary meaning. It is not within the province of this court to read a meaning into a statute which is not warranted by the legislative language.
Niedbalski v. Board of Ed. of Sch. Dist. No. 24,
227 Neb. 516, 418 N.W.2d 565 (1988). Had the Legislature intended a presumption of a patient’s ability to pay full cost of care if such person failed to provide certain financial information, it clearly could have included a provision such as
Reversed and remanded with DIRECTIONS TO DISMISS.