State Ex Rel. Speener v. GudmansonState Ex Rel. Speener v. Gudmanson
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Dykman
¶ 1. William Speener appeals from a circuit court order denying his motion for reconsideration of an order dismissing his petition for a writ of certiorari. On certiorari, Speener seeks reversal of the decision of the warden of Oshkosh Correctional Institution at the time, Donald Gudmanson, affirming the prison adjustment committee‘s finding that Speener was guilty of using marijuana. Speener argues that the circuit court erred by basing its decision on incorrect information. He also contends that the adjustment committee should not have held a second disciplinary hearing after we remanded the case because the second hearing exceeded the time limits of Wis. Admin. Code § DOC 303.76 and was beyond the scope of our directions on remand. The circuit court‘s reasoning is not relevant to our review on certiorari and we disagree with Speener‘s other contentions. *466 Based upon our independent review of the record before the adjustment committee, we affirm.
¶ 2. On appeal, Speener submitted an affidavit of indigency and requested that his filing fees be waived. At the time, he had been transferred to an out-of-state county jail. We conclude that an inmate in an out-of-state county jail is not a “prisoner” for purposes of WlS. Stat. § 814.29 (1997-98). 1 Therefore, we review Speener‘s request under § 814.29(1) and grant his petition for a fee waiver.
I. Background
¶ 3. In July 1996, the adjustment committee at Oshkosh Correctional Institution found Speener guilty of using marijuana, in violation of Wis. Admin. Code § DOC 303.59. Speener appealed to the warden, arguing, among other things, that the adjustment committee had denied him the opportunity to present his case by refusing to allow his statement of facts and a set of documents he had compiled in his defense into the record. The warden affirmed the adjustment committee‘s decision and the circuit court denied Speener‘s petition for a writ of certiorari.
¶ 4. Speener appealed the circuit court‘s decision, arguing that the adjustment committee had improperly prohibited him from introducing the documents in his defense at his hearing. See State ex rel. Speener v. Gudmanson, No. 97-1762, unpublished slip op. at 2-3 (Wis. Ct. App. Oct. 1, 1998). We reversed because we concluded that the record returned by the adjustment committee was insufficient to determine whether the proceedings before it were procedurally *467 proper. See id. at 4. The record did not establish whether Speener had offered the documents, and if he had, why the committee had not considered them. See id. at 3. We remanded with the following directions:
[W]e reverse and remand only for a limited purpose: supplementation of the record concerning the compliance with procedural rules. We remand the case to the circuit court with instructions to remand to the adjustment committee. On remand, the committee shall supplement the record with an indication of whether Speener sought to introduce the documents as he asserts. If he did offer them, the committee must include them in the record and explain why the committee did not accept them. If he did not offer them, the committee should so state.
Id. at 4 (citation omitted).
¶ 5. On October 9, 1998, the adjustment committee held another hearing based on our directions on remand. At this hearing, the committee allowed Speener to introduce the statement of facts and documentation that he alleged he had tried to introduce at the original hearing. The committee again found Speener guilty of violating Wis. Admin. Code § DOC 303.59 and the warden affirmed the committee‘s decision. The. Oshkosh Correctional Institution Registrar sent the supplemented record back to the circuit court with a letter stating that Speener did not have his statement of facts and documentation compiled at the time of the original hearing. The Registrar stated that the original hearing took place on July 15, 1996. However, the original disciplinary hearing form indicates that Speener‘s first hearing took place on July 23,1996, the same date Speener had on his statement of facts.
¶ 6. On November 19, 1998, the circuit court ordered that Speener‘s case be dismissed. The court‘s *468 only reasoning was that it “appears from the record that the petitioner created, compiled and offered the additional documents after the original hearing held on July 15, 1996.” Speener filed a motion for reconsideration arguing that: (1) he had been unable to respond to the Registrar‘s allegation that he compiled his documents after the date of the original hearing because he did not receive the supplemented record until after the circuit court entered its order; (2) the court erred in concluding that he compiled his documents after the original hearing because the hearing took place on July 23, 1996, and not July 15; (3) the adjustment committee‘s second hearing exceeded the scope of our directions on remand and violated Wis. Admin. Code § DOC 303.76 because it was held over two years after he received the adult conduct report regarding his offense. The circuit court denied the motion for reconsideration and Speener appeals. 2
¶ 7. Speener has submitted an affidavit of indi-gency and requested a waiver of the filing fee for his appeal. At the time Speener filed his notice of appeal, although he was still a Wisconsin inmate, he was confined at a county jail in Texas, as permitted by
II. Analysis
A. Fee Waiver
¶ 8. As we have explained, our analysis of Speener‘s request for a fee waiver turns on whether he was a “prisoner,” as defined in
*470 [A]ny state or local facility that incarcerates or detains any adult accused of, charged with, convicted of, or sentenced for any crime. A correctional institution includes a Type 1 prison, as defined in s. 301.01(5), a Type 2 prison, as defined in s. 301.01(6), a county jail and a house of correction.
Thus, in order to resolve whether Speener was a “prisoner” for purposes of Wis. STAT.
¶ 9. Statutory construction presents a question of law that we review de novo. See State ex rel. Frederick v. McCaughtry, 173 Wis. 2d 222, 225, 496 N.W.2d 177 (Ct. App. 1992). When we interpret a statute, our purpose is to ascertain the intent of the legislature and give it effect. See id. Our first step is to examine the language of the statute, and, absent ambiguity, give the language its ordinary meaning. See id. at 225-26. If the language is ambiguous, we examine the scope, history, context, subject matter and purpose of the statute in order to determine the legislative intent. See id. at 226. “Statutory language is ambiguous if reasonable people could disagree as to its meaning.” Id.
¶ 10. We conclude that the words “any state or local facility,” as used in the definition of “correctional facility” in
¶ 11. Construing the words “any state or local facility” within their context in
¶ 12. Gudmanson argues that the use of the word “includes” in the second sentence of
¶ 13. Gudmanson contends that the Prisoner Litigation Reform Act (PLRA), 1997 Wis. Act 133, under which
¶ 14. We disagree with Gudmanson‘s contentions. Wisconsin Stat.
¶ 15. Finally, Gudmanson points out that WlS. Stat.
¶ 16. Since the definition of “correctional institution” in
B. Merits of the Appeal
¶ 17. Speener argues that the trial court erred when it dismissed his case, because it based the dismissal on incorrect information regarding the date of his original hearing. He contends that he did not compile the documents in his defense after his original hearing date because the hearing was held on July 23, 1996, and not July 15. Speener also asserts that the adjustment committee should not have held a new hearing on remand because the new hearing exceeded the time *476 limits in Wis. Admin. Code § DOC 303.76 and was beyond the scope of our directions.
¶ 18. On certiorari, we review the decision of the prison adjustment committee independently of the trial court. See State ex rel. Whiting v. Kolb, 158 Wis. 2d 226, 233, 461 N.W.2d 816 (Ct. App. 1990). Our review is limited to: (1) whether the committee‘s decision was within its jurisdiction; (2) whether it acted according to law; (3) whether its decision was arbitrary, oppressive or unreasonable and represented the committee‘s will and not its judgment; and (4) whether the evidence was sufficient to demonstrate that the committee‘s decision was reasonable. See id. In reviewing the evidence, we apply the substantial evidence test, “under which we determine whether reasonable minds could arrive at the same conclusion the committee reached.” Id. “Our review is limited to the record created before the committee.” Id.
¶ 19. Gudmanson concedes that the trial court misunderstood the date of the original hearing. However, since we review the decision of the adjustment committee independently of the trial court, the basis on which the trial court rested its decision is not relevant.
¶ 20. We conclude that the adjustment committee stayed within its jurisdiction and did not act contrary to law. We do not agree that the committee exceeded the time limits imposed by Wis. Admin. Code § DOC 303.76 when it held the hearing on remand. WlS consin Admin. Code § DOC 303.76(3) provides:
Time limits. A due process hearing shall be held no sooner than 2 working days or later than 21 days after the inmate receives a copy of the conduct report and hearing notice. An inmate may waive *477 these time requirements in writing if the security director agrees to the waiver. The inmate may request additional time to prepare for the hearing, and the security director shall grant the request unless there is a good reason to deny it.
In this case, the hearing on remand, occurred over two years after Speener received his conduct report and hearing notice. However, Speener waived the twenty-one day time limit on his notice of hearing form, as allowed by Wis. Admin. Code § DOC 303.76(3). In addition, the new hearing took place after Speener petitioned the circuit court for a writ of certiorari and appealed the circuit court‘s decision, and after we remanded the case so that the record could be supplemented. Considering the time involved in judicial proceedings, we do not agree that the twenty-one day limit applies to hearings held on remand.
¶ 21. We also do not agree that the adjustment committee exceeded the scope of our directions on remand. We remanded the case so that the committee could supplement the record with either the documents Speener offered in his defense or with a statement that Speener had not offered the documents at the original hearing. The committee followed our instructions and made Speener‘s documents part of the record at the rehearing. It did not accept any additional evidence other than that which it reviewed at the original hearing in 1996. The committee did not exceed our instructions when it reaffirmed its finding of guilt at the hearing on remand based on its review of Speener‘s documents along with the evidence before it at the original hearing.
*478 ¶ 22. Based on our review of the record before the committee on remand, we conclude that the committee‘s decision was not arbitrary, oppressive or unreasonable and that the evidence satisfies the substantial evidence test. The committee reviewed the computerized results of a urinalysis test indicating that Speener had tested “high” for “cannabinoids.” Speener submitted a different read-out indicating that he tested at 130.3, and a urinalysis report indicating that he had “tested positive for cannabinoid.” He also submitted the chain of evidence log for his urinalysis showing only one person as handling his urine specimen, indicating that Speener had taken some medicine in the seventy-two hours before the test, and indicating that a result of 130.3 amounted to a positive test for cannabinoids. Finally, he submitted a chain of evidence log for another inmate‘s urinalysis test showing entries for a number of people who handled the urine specimen, the Department of Corrections internal memo on urinalysis testing, a letter denying him access to the urinalysis machine manual, and the Department of Corrections’ mission statement. Based on the urinalysis results, reasonable people could conclude that Speener had used marijuana despite the fact that he had taken medicine in the seventy-two hours before the test and that his chain of evidence log contained only one entry.
¶ 23. Speener also contends that his due process rights, under the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution and article I, sections 1 and 8 of the Wisconsin Constitution, were violated because: (1) he was not provided sufficient notice of the hearing on remand; (2) he was not allowed to present witnesses; (3) he was denied a second urinalysis test to confirm *479 the results of the first; and (4) the prison did not follow proper procedure in processing his urine sample. However, Speener has appealed only from the order denying his motion for reconsideration. He did not raise any of these issues in that motion and, generally, we do not consider issues that were not raised before the trial court. See Greenlee v. Rainbow Auction/Realty Co., 202 Wis. 2d 653, 672, 553 N.W.2d 257 (Ct. App. 1996). We see no compelling reason to address these issues on appeal.
¶ 24. For the reasons discussed above, we order that Speener‘s petition for a fee waiver is granted and we affirm the circuit court‘s order denying Speener‘s motion for reconsideration.
By the Court. — Order affirmed.
Notes
All references to the Wisconsin Statutes are to the 1997-98 version unless otherwise noted.
After reviewing jurisdictional memos submitted by the parties, we ordered that we had jurisdiction over the appeal because Speener‘s motion for reconsideration raised issues different from those determined in the order sought to be reconsidered. See Silverton Enters. v. General Cas. Co. of Wis., 143 Wis. 2d 661, 665, 422 N.W.2d 154 (Ct. App. 1988).
“Prisoner” means any person who is incarcerated, imprisoned or otherwise detained in a correctional institution or who is arrested or otherwise detained by a law enforcement officer. “Prisoner” does not include any of the following:
a. A person committed under ch. 980.
b. A person bringing an action seeking relief from a judgment terminating parental rights.
c. A person bringing an action seeking relief from a judgment of conviction or a sentence of a court, including an action for an extraordinary writ or a supervisory writ seeking relief from a judgment of conviction or a sentence of a court or an action under s. 809.30, 809.40, 973.19 or 974.06.
d. A person bringing an action under s. 809.50 seeking relief from an order or judgment not appealable as of right that was *470 entered in a proceeding under ch. 980 or in a case specified under s. 809.30 or 809.40.
e. A person who is not serving a sentence for the conviction of a crime but who is detained, admitted or committed under ch. 51 or 55 or s. 971.14 (2) or (5).
“Type 1” and “Type 2” prisons are defined in WlS. STAT. § 301.01(5) and (6). In addition, several Wisconsin statutes use the terms “county jail” and “house of correction.”
See, e.g.,
Gudmanson points out that, prior to the PLRA, WlS. STAT.
Wisconsin Stat.
This is a waiver of the filing fee only in the Court of Appeals. It is not a determination of indigency for any other purpose.