State Ex Rel. Sloane v. ReidyState Ex Rel. Sloane v. Reidy
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Comley
In this proceeding in the nature of quo warranto, the plaintiffs, as residents and taxpayers of the city of Waterbury, challenge the validity of certain provisional promotions of policemen and firemen made by the boards of police commissioners and fire commissioners. The plaintiffs’ attack is based principally on the ground that pro
The finding, which is not subject to correction, recites the following facts: In September, 1961, a charter revision commission was appointed by the board of aldermen with instructions to consider an amendment to the charter establishing a merit system for city employees. Such an amendment was prepared and sent to the board of aldermen, which approved it and voted that it be submitted to the electors of the city in November, 1962. This action was vetoed by the mayor. This veto was subsequently held invalid by this court in Sloane v. Waterbury, 150 Conn. 24, 183 A.2d 839. The basis of our decision was that the only procedure now contemplated by our law for the local amendment of city charters is contained exclusively in the so-called Home Rule Act (General Statutes, c. 99), which contains no provision for such a veto. Following that decision, the civil service system amendment was approved by the electors on November 6, 1962.
The amendment states that the civil service commission shall adopt rules and regulations which shall provide for provisional and emergency appointments without examination. Such rules and regulations are subject to disapproval by a two-thirds vote of the board of aldermen. Provisional appointments may be made only with the concurrence of the director of personnel. On September 27, 1963, the commission adopted a regulation which
The case was initially tried on the theory that the amendment was authorized by a section of the Home Rule Act.
The Waterbury charter provides that the munic
In the construction of a statute, effect should be given to the purpose behind it.
Northeastern Gas Transmission Co.
v.
Collins,
138 Conn. 582, 592, 87 A.2d 139, and cases cited. A reading of
In the
Sloane
case the issue presented before the court was whether the procedure for charter amendment under the Home Rule Act superseded the procedure for charter amendment under the charter. We held that a reading of the Home Rule Act made it clear that the act set forth a complete self-contained method of charter amendment, irrespective of any existing charter provision. Therefore,
The Home Rule Act, however, does not have any effect on the grant of power in the charter of “Waterbury to amend its charter by providing for a civil service system. Legislation is construed to effectmate the expressed intention of the legislature.
Bridgeport
v.
Stratford,
142 Conn. 634, 641, 116 A.2d 508;
Landry
v.
Personnel Appeal Board,
138 Conn. 445, 447, 86 A.2d 70. That intent is determined from the language used when there is no ambiguity.
McAdams
v.
Barbieri,
143 Conn. 405, 415, 123 A.2d 182. Thus, in this case also, the clear language of the Home Rule Act exhibits a legislative intent to add a new power to those which municipalities already had without affecting existing powers. That language is found in
Other claims made by the appellant are also without merit. Chapter 113 of the General Statutes does not preempt the field of civil service legislation. There is a presumption that the legislature was aware of existing statutory provisions and that in framing a charter, it did not intend to enact conflicting provisions.
State ex rel. Pape
v.
Dunais,
120 Conn. 562, 566, 181 A. 721. If the expressions of legislative will are irreconcilable, the latest prevails, even though it is contained in a special act.
Moran
v.
Bens,
144 Conn. 27, 30, 127 A.2d 42. Application of the above principles leads to the result that the charter provision exists notwithstanding chapter 113. Chapter 113 was in substantially its present form in 1930. Rev. 1930, c. 105. The charter, with its provision giving it the right to adopt a civil service system by charter amendment, was enacted in 1931. The charter, being later in time, is not preempted by chapter 113. The fact that chapter 105 was reenacted as incident to the adoption of the Revisions of 1949 and 1958 (Rev. 1949, c. 47; General Statutes, c. 113) does not have the effect of repealing the charter provision. See Rev. 1949, § 8894;
The other claims of the defendants are without merit.
There is no error.
In this opinion the other judges concurred.
Notes
Chapter 113 contains two subdivisions, one pertaining to adoption of a merit system and the other pertaining to a retirement system. No argument has been made that the charter amendment could qualify as being adopted in accordance with this chapter.