State ex rel. Linthicum v. Board of CommissionersState ex rel. Linthicum v. Board of Commissioners
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Morris
This was a mandamus proceeding by appellants, against the Board of Commissioners of the County of Vanderburgh and others. It involves the right of the county to vote aid to a bridge company, for the construction of a bridge over the Ohio river, under § 4405 Burns 1908, Acts 1889 p. 266. So much of the section as applies here, reads as follows: “That counties wherein any bridge over any river or stream forming the boundary of the State of Indiana, or any part thereof, may be located, or any of the townships of such counties, are hereby authorized to take stock in or make donations to such bridge company in aid of the construction of such bridge by complying with the provisions, so far as the same are applicable, of an act approved May 12, 1869, being §§ 4045 to 4063, inclusive, of Revised Statutes [of 1881], giving to counties and townships authority to take stock in and make donations in aid of the construction of railroads.”
*402The act of May 12, 1869, as originally enacted (Acts 1869 [s. s.] p. 92) authffized counties, or townships thereof, to aid in the construction of railroads, either by making donations or taking stock This act was so amended in 1875 as to authorize townships only so to aid (Acts 1875 [s. s.] p. 70). Sections 4045-4063 R. S. 1881, designated in the act of 1889, swpra, embrace said act ‘of 1869, as amended by said act of 1875, and other amendments passed before 1881. These nineteen sections (§§ 4045-4063, supra) contain no authority to counties to give aid, except by the provision made in § 4059, supra, which authorizes the board of commissioners, under certain conditions, to pay out of the county-treasury an amount equal to the special tax voted by a township, pending its collection from the taxables of the township. The sum so advanced was to be refunded when collected. Section 4058, supra, authorized the board of commissioners to take stock in the company in the name of the township voting the aid, and to make proper contracts with the company relative to freight rates, location of depots, etc., pursuant to the terms of the petition for voting the aid by the township. Section 4056, supra, required the county board to make the levy of the special tax voted on the township taxables.
Appellees claim that the act of 1881 (Acts 1881 p. 5), as amended in 1889, does not authorize aid by counties to bridge companies. If this interpretation of the law is correct, the judgment of the trial court should be affirmed, because this appeal grows out of the refusal by the Board of Commissioners of the County of Vanderburgh to submit to the voters of said county the question of aid by the entire county for the construction of a bridge over the Ohio river.
While it is the duty of the courts, in construing a legislative enactment, so to hold as to give full effect to each *404word found therein, if possible, we are here confronted with a statute which, in general terms, provides that “ counties * * * or * * * townships * * * are hereby authorized- to take stock,” etc., “ by complying with the provisions, so far as the same are applicable, of * * * §§ 4045 to 4063, inclusive,” but, specifically, does not authorize the taking of stock, except in the name, and for the use of, a single township. § 4405 Bums 1908, Acts 1889 p. 266; § 5478 Burns 1908, § 4058 R. S. 1881.
In the case of Miles v. Bay (1885), 100 Ind. 166, 169, this court said: “The power to subject property to taxation in aid of railroad companies can be exercised only in strict conformity to, and by a rigid compliance with, the letter and spirit of the act conferring the authority. The act should be strictly construed in favor of the rights of property.” See, also, State, ex rel., v. Board, etc. (1906), 166 Ind. 162; Garrigus v. Board, etc. (1872), 39 Ind. 66; Demarree v. Johnson (1898), 150 Ind. 419; Voss v. Waterloo Water Co. (1904), 163 Ind. 69, 66 L. R. A. 95, 106 Am. St. 201, and cases cited; United States v. Oregon, etc., R. Co. (1896), 164 U. S. 526, 17 Sup. Ct. 165, 41 L. Ed. 541; Sioux City, etc., R. Co. v. United States (1895), 159 U. S. 349, 16 Sup. Ct. 17, 40 L. Ed. 177. Where a statute of this character is defective, courts have no power to supply omissions. Kunkalman v. Gibson (1909), 171 Ind. 503; 36 Cyc. 1113; State, ex rel., v. Reneau (1905), 75 Neb. 1, 104 N. W. 1151, 106 N. W. 451.
Appellants are seeking, by means of a special tax to be levied on all the taxables of the county, the appropriation of $436,000 to aid a gwasi-public corporation in constructing a bridge, if a majority of the voters of the county approve of the proposition. The statute in question omits any provision for a petition for such submission to the voters of the county. If it were held that such provision should be implied, the statute omits to designate the jurisdictional number of petitioners required to sign the petition; if this omission *405were supplied, it still fails to provide any method for the canvass of the votes, and, finally, it confers no authority on the board to levy a special tax of this nature on the taxables of the county. These defects cannot be supplied by the courts without legislating. Such power is vested in the General Assembly. Const. Art. 4, § 1. The statute in controversy does not authorize the Board of Commissioners of the County of Vanderburgh to aid a corporation in constructing a bridge over the Ohio river by taking stock in such corporation.
Several other questions are presented in this appeal, but in view of the conclusions reached, as before set forth, no useful purpose would be subserved by their consideration.
Judgment affirmed.