23 Fla. 121 | Fla. | 1887
delivered the opinion of the court:
This court, in the exercise of its original jurisdiction, issued an alternative writ of mandamus to the respondents, the three inspectors at an election lately held in the city of Sanford for the office of Mayor and other municipal offices. The issue presented by the pleadings, including the returns of two of the inspectors and the traverse thereof, is whether or not the name of Henry L. Lilienthal, the relator, who was one of two candidates for Mayor, was, as it appeared upon one of the ballots voted at such election) “ scratched.” The respondents, Deane and Whiteman, say in their returns that it was scratched, and in the exercise of their judgment, as to whether it was or not, they decided that it was, and refused to count it as a vote for relator. The other inspector files a separate return, to the effect that he was in favor of counting the ballot. Two of the inspectors being introduced as witnesses identified the ballot in question, which was also put in evidence. There appear upon its face across the name of the relator several pencil marks, or lines, which though dim are plainly visible, and there are two small holes in the ballot, one through the first or given name, and the other in or just under the surname, and both seemingly made with the pencil in making the marks or lines referred to. Whether or not it was the purpose of the person who cast this ballot to vote for the relator is not necessary for us to decide. There is enough upon the face of the ballot to call for the exercise of judgment by the inspectors upon this point, and exercising, as under the circumstances they had the right to do, their judgment as to whether the ballot should or should not be counted by them for the relator, they have decided that it should not be, or in other words, thej7 have held it to be
The judgment will be that the respondents go without day, and that they recover their costs. High on Extraordinary Legal Remedies, §526 ; State ex rel. County Commissioners Sumter County, 21 Fla., 370.
It will be so ordered.
