State Ex Rel. Erhardt v. MacGillivrayState Ex Rel. Erhardt v. MacGillivray
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Hill
The plaintiffs in a civil action pending in Spokane county (hereinafter referred to as the appellants) seek, in this proceeding, to have one of the attorneys for the defendants in that civil action (hereinafter referred to as the alleged contemnor) punished for contempt under the provisions of
We have, in
Keller v. Keller
(1958),
ante
p. 84, 323 P. (2d) 231, very recently had occasion to discuss and clarify our contempt statutes and procedures. As there indicated,
This statute dates back to 1869, and is found in the Code of 1881 as chapter 62, §§ 725-738. As presently found in
We are concerned with “Any other unlawful interference with the process or proceedings of a court.”
The issue presented to the court in the present case is the sufficiency of the affidavit filed in this proceeding; and that, in turn, depends upon whether it is necessary that the af-fiant, or affiants, have testimonial knowledge of the acts or omissions constituting the claimed contempt.
Some of the other provisions of this statute should be briefly outlined before we proceed to a consideration of this issue.
“When the defendant has been brought up or appeared, the court or judicial officer shall proceed to investigate the charge by examining such defendant and witnesses for or against him, for which an adjournment may be had from time to time, if necessary. [Code 1881 § 732; 1877 p 149 § 737; 1869 p 169 § 674; RRS § 1056.]”
“Upon the evidence so taken, the court or judicial officer shall determine whether or not the defendant is guilty of the contempt charged; and, if it be determined that he is so guilty, shall sentence him to be punished as provided in this chapter. [Code 1881 § 733; 1877 p 149 § 738; 1869 p 170 § 675; RRS § 1057.]”
In the present proceeding the appellants filed an affidavit, made by one of their attorneys to comply with the requirement of
The affiant further stated that the statements contained in the article were made for the sole and only purpose of prejudicing and biasing readers of that newspaper against any award or recovery for the appellants in their civil action; and that the alleged contemnor knew that by the pub
The affiant concludes with the allegation that the alleged contemnor is guilty of contempt of court and misconduct in the following respects:
(1) That he had intentionally invaded the jurisdiction of the court by attempting to influence, prejudice, and bias jurors against the appellants, and prevent the appellants from having a fair and impartial trial.
(2) That he knowingly misrepresented facts to the prospective jurors to be selected in Spokane county as to who would have to pay any judgment the appellants might secure.
(3) That he was guilty of violating the canons of professional ethics by issuing a statement for newspaper publication, concerning pending litigation, which he knew would interfere with a fair trial in the litigation then pending.
Based on this affidavit, the appellants asked for an order to show cause why the alleged contemnor should not be punished for contempt.
The trial court directed a hearing on this application, and the alleged contemnor filed an affidavit that at no time during the months of March or April, 1957, did he make any solicitations, requests, or statements of or to the representatives of the newspaper referred to in the affidavit in the presence of or within the hearing of the affiant.
The purpose of this affidavit was to raise the issue that the affiant had no testimonial knowledge that the alleged contemnor solicited and requested the city editor of a Spokane newspaper to publish the specific article in question.
It was conceded by the affiant, at the hearing on whether the order to show cause should issue, that he did not personally hear any such solicitation or request; it is likewise conceded in appellants’ brief. It is pointed out in the brief that a person, such as the news editor referred to in the affidavit, cannot be compelled to make an affidavit, but that if a hearing is held, he can be compelled to testify.
“The affidavit, therefore, became the foundation of the action, and from its recitals the jurisdiction and powers of the court in the premises must be determined,”
and, confronted with a situation where, as here, the maker of the affidavit did not have testimonial knowledge of the facts constituting the contempt, the court said:
“We think a hearsay statement of this kind is not sufficient to invoke the jurisdiction of the court for the arrest and punishment of one under a grave and opprobrious charge. Before the court can assume jurisdiction of such a proceeding, it must receive its information through the affidavit of some one who is prepared to state the facts without referring to a third person as his informant.”
The trial court based its refusal to issue an order to show cause on the reasoning of
State v. Canutt, supra,
which supports the proposition that before the superior court will assume jurisdiction of a contempt proceeding under
At the hearing on the application for the order to show cause, there were charges and countercharges as to breaches of the canons of professional ethics. We are not concerned at this time with those charges; the machinery for their investigation and determination is available to the interested parties.
We affirm the refusal of the trial court to issue the order to show cause requested by the appellants.
Donworth, Weaver, Rosellini, and Foster, JJ., concur.