Stahl v. StahlStahl v. Stahl
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Hand
delivered the opinion of the court:
The appellees averred in their answer that the deed bearing date August 18, 1900, executed by Fredericka L. Stahl to Frank A. Stahl, and the deed bearing date September 5, 1902, executed by Frank A. Stahl to John Stahl, were absolute
At the time Fredericka L. Stahl executed said deed to Frank A. Stahl she was seventy-two years of age and was sick in bed. The scrivener who prepared the deed was called by her grandson to her house at eleven o’clock at night. The deed was executed by her at about twelve o’clock of the same night. All her children, five in number, in the city of Chicago were assembled at her house. The premises conveyed were then of the value of about $25,000,-—-all the property she had. At that time Frank A. Stahl was a practicing physician in the city of Chicago and earning from $3000 to $4000 per year. The relations existing between Fredericka L. and all her children, including Frank A., were friendly and confidential. No- consideration was paid to her by Frank A. Stahl for the conveyance, and the premises were subsequently conveyed to John Stahl by Frank A. Stahl without consideration. Frank A. Stahl, after the death of his mother, and John, after the conveyance to him by Frank A., both admitted -that their brothers and sisters were equally interested with them in said premises. Such admissions were denied by them upon the trial. Louisa F., who was present on the night of the 18th of August, when the deed from Fredericka L. to Frank A. was executed, testified that her mother was sick in bed
The chancellor saw and heard the witnesses testify, and evidently, from the decree entered by him, did not adopt the view of the witnesses for appellees who testified to what took place and what was said at the time of the execution of the deed, but did adopt the view of Louisa F., as he found in the decree that at the time the deed was executed and delivered
The Statute of Frauds, requiring an express trust in regard to lands to be evidenced by writing, reads as follows: “All declarations or creations of trusts or confidences of any lands, tenements or hereditaments, shall be manifested and proved by some writing signed by the party, who is by. law enabled to declare such trust, or by his last will in writing; or else they shall be utterly void and of no effect: Provided, that resulting trust or trusts created by construction, implication or operation of law, need not be in writing, and the same may be proved by parol.” (Hurd’s Stat. 1903, chap. 59, sec. 9, p. 996.)
In Pope v. Dapray, 176 Ill. 478, on page 484, it was said: “A constructive trust is one that arises where a person clothed with1 some fiduciary character, by fraud or otherwise gains something for himself.—Perry on Trusts, sec. 27; Reed v. Reed, 135 Ill. 482.”
In Mayrand v. Mayrand, 194 Ill. 45, on page. 48, the following statement from Thomas v. Whitney, 186 Ill. 225, defining the meaning of the term “fiduciary and confidential relation,” as used in this connection, was quoted with approval. It was there said: “There is a well defined distinction between undue influence arising from acts which the law deems
In Dowie v. Driscoll, 203 Ill. 480, on page 496, it was said“The doctrine repeatedly announced by this court is, that courts of ‘equity ‘will scrutinize with the most jealous vigilance’ transactions between parties occupying fiduciary relations toward each other, (Casey v. Casey, 14 Ill. 112,) and that the burden of proof is on the beneficiary, in such cases, to establish the fairness of the transaction and that it did not proceed from undue influence.” In this case Frank A. Stahl failed to explain in a satisfactory manner why his mother conveyed to him all her property without consideration, why his brothers and sisters stood by and assented to such transfer, and why he, without consideration, transferred said property to his brother John, if he was the absolute owner thereof at the time he transferred the same to him.
In Pope v. Dapray, supra, on page 484, it was said: “Where ‘a person obtains the legal title to property by virtue of a confidential relation and influence, under such circumstances that he ought not, according to the rule of equity and good conscience as administered in chancery, to hold and enjoy the beneficial interests of the property, courts of equity, in order to administer complete justice between the parties, will raise a trust, by construction, out of such circumstances or relations, and this trust they will fasten upon the conscience of the offending party and will convert him into a trustee of the legal title, and order him to hold it, or execute the trust in such manner as to protect the rights of the defrauded party and promote the safety and interests of society.’ (Perry on Trusts, sec. 166.) This rule has been by this court quoted with approval in the cases of Beach v. Dyer, 93 Ill. 295, and Allen v. Jackson, 122 id. 567.”
In Larmon v. Knight, 140 Ill. 232, on page 236, it was held, whenever a person acquires the legal title to land or other property by means of an intentionally false and fraudulent verbal promise to hold the same for a certain specified
And in Ahrens v. Jones, 169 N. Y. 555, (62 N. E. Rep. 666,) where the wife obtained a deed from her husband by a promise to pay out of the property deeded,..$1000 to each of his two grandchildren, and afterwards refused to carry out the promise, the court said: “This is an attempt to perpetrate a fraud not only upon her husband, who was induced to make the gift to her by reason of her promise, but also upon the plaintiff, who, presumably, would have been otherwise provided for by her grandfather had it not been for the defendant’s promise.” It was also said: “Such a trust does not affect the deed, but acts upon the gift, as it reaches the possession of the grantee; and the foundation for the trust is, that equity will then interfere and raise a trust in favor of the persons intended to be benefited, in order to prevent a fraud.”
Mr. Pomeroy, in his work on Equity Jurisprudence, (vol. 2, sec. 1054,) says: “Whenever a person procures a devise or bequest to be made directly to himself,—and thereby preventing, perhaps, an intended testamentary gift to another, —through false and fraudulent representations, assurances or promises that he will carry out the original and true purpose of the testator, and will apply the devise or bequest to the benefit of a third person who is the real object and who would otherwise have been the actual recipient of the testator’s bounty, and
We are impressed, from a careful examination of this record, in view of the foregoing authorities, that the position assumed by Frank A; and John Stahl with reference to the property ^n question must be held to be constructively fraudulent, and by reason of that fact think this a case in which a court of equity may properly raise a constructive trust and fasten it upon the conscience of John Stahl, the present holder of the legal title,- and convert him, as the holder of such title, into a trustee for the benefit oj all the children of Fredericka L. Stahl, deceased, who in equity must be held to be the beneficial owners of said property. White v. Ross, 160 Ill. 56.
The cases relied upon by appellees we are of the opinion are not in point. Those cases, it will be found upon examination, are cases in which no fraud, actual or constructive, or1 fiduciary relation between the parties, was found to exist.
The decree of the superior court will be reversed and the cause remanded to that court, with directions to’ enter a decree in accordance with the views herein expressed.
Reversed and remanded, with directions.