Spalding v. SpaldingSpalding v. Spalding
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Herrick
Lead Opinion
delivered the opinion of the court:
Maurice A. Spalding, complainant in the trial court and appellant here, in the superior court of Cook county filed his bill for divorce against Dora Spalding charging her with extreme and repeated cruelty, and also prayed for the return of a Lincoln automobile alleged to have been taken by her. Her answer denied the allegations of cruelty and the ownership of the automobile by.the complainant. She filed a cross-bill for separate maintenance, charging the complainant with cruelty and praying that a deed be set aside which she had signed conveying to her husband her interest in certain real estate, that the several interests of the parties in such real estate be determined, an accounting had, and alimony, together with solicitors’ fees, be awarded her. The husband answered the cross-bill, denied the charges of cruelty and that his wife was entitled to any part of the relief prayed.
On the question of divorce and separate maintenance the chancellor heard the issues in open court, announced on January 27, 1933, that while the husband would not be
Many alleged errors are argued. The husband claims that inasmuch as the wife’s cross-bill only asked for separate maintenance and not divorce the court was without power to order the cause referred. It is well to remember that only the issues made in the cross-bill other than for separate maintenance were referred to the master. Those matters were all germane to the original bill filed, in the sense
The record is very voluminous and a detailed statement of all the evidence would be impracticable. Attention will be given to such portions, only, as we deem to have a material bearing on the issues here reviewed. On some of the important controversial issues the testimony of the parties is in irreconcilable conflict. The evidence justified the chancellor entering the decree of divorce for the husband’s fault. The parties were married March 20, 1920, the day following the husband’s graduation from medical school. No children were born of the marriage. Immediately after his marriage the husband began serving as an interne in one of the local hospitals. At the time of the marriage the
The master in stating the account between the parties charged the husband with the $4000 loan. This sum was reached by debiting the husband with the $3000 securities loaned to him before the marriage, plus the $3000 which he withdrew from the bank account, and crediting him with the $2000 securities returned to his wife. He also charged the husband with the withdrawals by him from this account of the items of $2000, $332 and $800. It is apparent that the original $3000 of securities was obtained by the husband from his then fiance with the expectation on his part of re-paying her, as is evidenced by the fact that when the securities were redeemed by the discharge of the loan the husband promptly returned to her $2000 of such securities. The circumstances attendant upon opening the bank account clearly show that it was not contemplated that the $32,200 deposited therein, nor any part thereof, was intended as a gift on the part of the wife to the husband. The evidence amply supports a promise on the part of the husband to re-pay the sums withdrawn for his use, aggregating $7132, and the chancellor was warranted in overruling the husband’s exceptions to these several items and entering a decree requiring the husband to re-pay those sums.
The husband completed his internship about May of 1921. During that month, having access to his wife’s safety deposit box, he withdrew some of the securities which stood in her name, cashed a check against his account in the Scheubert & Ambry Bank and deserted his wife. She had a warrant sworn out for him. He was arrested in Vincennes, Indiana, and brought to Chicago. The securities he had taken were surrendered to his wife. After this affair she procured a new safety deposit box to which the doctor did not have access. On the husband’s return from Indiana the parties apparently composed their differences
In the wife’s cross-bill as amended she made no charge that the husband had ever requested her to pay the rent’ or living expenses, or that she had at any time asked him to re-pay her, or that he had promised to reimburse her for any payments so made. There is no evidence of any fraud committed nor of coercion on the part of the husband by reason of which the wife made such payments. In so far as the evidence discloses she made the same voluntarily. In her testimony she does not claim otherwise. In this State a wife may deal with her separate property as she sees fit. She may give it to her husband if she desires, and a gift from wife to husband may be valid, depending on the circumstances attending the transaction, except as against creditors, and while such transactions are carefully scrutinized by the court, yet where the gifts are fair and reasonable and not procured by the fraud or imposition of the husband they will be enforced. 1 Schouler on Marriage, Divorce, Separation and Domestic Relations, (6th ed.) sec. 553, p. 566.
The master charged the husband with the sum of $2700 representing the purchase price of a Paige automobile, and with $4000 the cost of a Lincoln roadster. The exceptions of the husband to this finding of the master were overruled and the finding sustained by the trial court. The evidence of the wife is, that in the fall of 1921 she purchased the Paige for $2700 with her own funds; that this automobile was bought for her husband’s use in the practice of his profession; that in 1922 she bought a Lincoln roadster, the Paige being traded in on the purchase price and the difference paid by her; that the Lincoln roadster was also bought for the doctor’s use professionally. It is not
There is a grave dispute between the parties respecting the doctor’s earnings from his profession. To attempt to reconcile their evidence on that subject would be a hopeless task, for it cannot be done. Such earnings are only incidental to the issues here. The doctor testified his income in 1921 was about $3000; in 1922, $10,000; in 1923, $25,000; in 1924, $40,000, and from 1925-1931 from $40,000 to $60,000, and that there was a marked decline after the latter years. There is other evidence showing that he had a large and flourishing practice. He testified that substantially all his earnings were turned over to his wife and that she had thriftily secreted enough funds therefrom to keep her the rest of her life. On the other hand, the wife claims that during the period of his greatest prosperity his earnings were about $9000 a year and that she has accounted for all that came to her charge. We believe the doctor’s opinion of his earnings is somewhat inflated. The evidence does tend to prove the wife came to the office at stated intervals and received money and checks which had come to the office in due course of the doctor’s practice. Considerable cash was kept in a safety deposit box, wherein there was placed also the wife’s income from securities held by her and the rent received from the second apartment of the Manor avenue house owned by them. The husband had access to the box. There is no dispute but that in the later years of the marriage the funds were commingled and kept either
On April 11, 1927, the property referred to as the Manor avenue property was bought for the sum of $45,000 and title thereto taken in the husband and wife as joint tenants. The parties separated on March 18, 1932. On February 1, 1932, the wife purported to convey her interest in such property to her husband. She claims she made this deed in reliance upon her husband’s promise that if she would transfer to him her interest in this property he would pay off certain notes at the Pioneer Bank bearing her signature and reimburse her for money which she had previously applied on the original indebtedness to that bank. The husband claims that in consideration of his wife’s agreement to deliver certain stocks in her possession standing in his name and the transfer to him of her interest in the Manor avenue property he paid her $20,000 one day during the last ten days of January, 1932. He testified that his brother, Harry, brought from Indianapolis, Indiana, the $20,000 in fifty-dollar and one-hundred-dollar bills, wrapped in a newspaper; that at the time of the payment to his wife, Harry Spalding, a cousin, and C. J. Harrison and himself, were present; that the transactionoccurred at the Manor avenue home about 6:00 o’clock in the evening; that Harry Spalding handed the package to Mrs. Spalding; that she opened it, counted the money and stated she was satisfied; that the husband then asked her, in the presence of the witnesses, if she agreed that for the $20,000 she would deed him the Manor avenue property and turn over the stocks to him; that she said yes, took the money and went to another part of the residence.
C. J. Harrison and Harry Spalding testified to substantially the same facts as to the occurrence at the residence. Harry Spalding stated that in 1924 he drew the $20,000 from
A further issue is presented with reference to the Manor avenue property. The evidence shows the wife had charge of the purchasing of the property, that the husband was not present at the time the deed was drawn or delivered, that the wife was, and she had the deed made to herself and husband as joint tenants. The evidence discloses that part of the purchase price was paid out of currency from the safety deposit box in which the funds of the wife and husband were commingled, a part was paid by the doctor’s own funds and a part by the wife’s funds. The master
We have carefully examined the record as to the disposition of the household furniture and chattel property. The court was justified in finding the ownership of such chattels in accordance with the decree, and the chancellor’s findings will not be disturbed on that issue.
There remains for disposition the finding of the court with reference to the indebtedness to the Pioneer Bank. In March, 1929, appellant commenced a course of speculation in the stock market. The wife, under his direction, handled these purchases and sales. The speculation’ apparently continued through several months and resulted in a.
Other errors which have been assigned and argued have been reviewed, but the court’s findings upon those controversial issues will not be disturbed.
The decree of the superior court is affirmed in part and reversed in part and the cause is remanded to that court, with directions to enter a decree in conformity with the views herein expressed.
Affirmed in part, reversed in part mid remanded, with directions.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting:
The majority of the court have overlooked and ignored the rule recognized in Gilbert v. Gilbert, 305 Ill. 216, and Termaat v. Termaat, 357 id. 472, with reference to the division of property between husband and wife in a divorce proceeding. The rule which permits an inquiry into the amounts contributed by joint tenants was also recognized in People v. Varel, 351 Ill. 96. Section 17 of the Divorce act (Smith’s Stat. 1935, chap. 40, par. 18,) is also totally disregarded and treated as non-existent. There is no reason given for binding the hands of the chancellor by the presumption of a gift in the case before us where the tenancy was joint that would not apply with equal force to a husband or wife who held the fee simple title absolute. The results of the rule laid down would be most disastrous if a “gold-digger” married, obtained title to her husband’s real estate and divorced him. If the presumption of gift’ applies in the instant case it would apply with equal force to the hypothetical case of the gold-digger.