8 Ga. App. 654 | Ga. Ct. App. | 1911
The plaintiff, a woman who lived at Plainville, a small station on the defendant’s line of railroad, not a great distance from Rome, went to that city to do some shopping. She spent all her money except thirty cents, the fare from Rome to Plainville. Her train passed Rome late in the afternoon. About the middle of the afternoon she went to the station and asked the agent to sell her a ticket. He told her that he would not sell her a ticket until twenty minutes before the train arrived. She remained about the waiting-room during the afternoon and until after the train arrived, and by reason of the fact that the agent went off and failed to leave his keys with any one who could sell tickets, she was unable to purchase a ticket. She went back to the city and got accommodations at the home of a stranger. Next morning she bought a ticket and got to her home about 12 o’clock in the day. The jury awarded her $150 damages. She proved no special damages. The company, in addition to the contention that the verdict is excessive, makes the point that under the law of this State she would have had the right to board the train without a ticket and to be carried at the customary ticket fare, though the conductor’s fare is usually greater than the ticket fare, she having used reasonable diligence in attempting to procure a ticket. We do not think that the verdict is excessive. The plaintiff, not having shown special damages, was entitled to general damages for the defendant’s breach of duty in refusing to make a contract of carriage with the plaintiff, who offered herself as a passenger and tendered the fare. Under such circumstances, the general damages allowed need not be merely nominal in amount; besides, the majority of this court is of the view that $150 would not be excessive as nominal damages. See Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Glenn, ante, 168 (68 S. E. 881), in which the writer dissented. Rome being an agency station, with business hours covering the period within which the present al