Smith v. United StatesSmith v. United States
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Wellford
ORDER ALLOWING REMOVAL OF CAUSE AND GRANTING PLAINTIFF ADDITIONAL TIME IN WHICH TO PLEAD
WELLFORD, District Judge.
Plaintiff, John Fitzgerald Smith, a minor, brought an action in state court on January 13, 1971, by his mother and next friend, Frankie Smith, against defendant, William B. Hall, for damages for personal injuries received in an automobile accident allegedly caused by the negligence of defendant, in the Circuit Court of Lauderdale County, Tennessee. William B. Hall was an employee of the Agricultural Stabilization and Conservation Service, Department of Agriculture, at the time of the accident. The United States of America, by the United States Attorney, certified that Hall was acting within the scope of his employment at the time of the accident and sought removal to this Court pursuant to
Defendant, United States of America, has also filed a motion to dismiss this tort action on the grounds that the plaintiff did not file his claim with the appropriate federal agency prior to the institution of this suit as required by
This Court, after oral argument, indicated its inclination against removal of this cause and expressed an intention to remand it back to the state court as filed originally without the United States of America as a party. An examination of the authorities compels the Court, however, to abandon its intent.
The plaintiff asserts that it was not his desire to bring an action against the United States in Federal Court. To the contrary, he originated this action against a private individual in state court and opposes its removal to this Court and does not desire to present any claim against the United States of America.
As the legislative history of this section indicates, and as many courts have recognized, the purpose of this provision was to protect Government drivers from personal liability on claims resulting from accidents occurring within the scope of their employment. 107 Cong.Rec. 18, 499-500, 87th Cong., 1st Sess., U.S.Code Cong. & Admin.News, 1961, p. 2784; Carr v. United States, 422 F.2d 1007 (4th Cir., 1970); Noga v. United States, 411 F.2d 943 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 396 U.S. 841, 90 S.Ct. 104, 24 L.Ed.2d 92 (1969); Vantrease v. United States, 400 F.2d 853 (6th Cir., 1968); Van Houten v. Ralls, 411 F.2d 940 (9th Cir.) cert. denied, 396 U.S. 962, 90 S.Ct. 436, 24 L.Ed.2d 426 (1969), reh. den. 397 U.S. 930, 90 S.Ct. 900, 25 L.Ed.2d 110.
As stated by the Court in Meeker v. United States, supra, 435 F.2d at p. 1222:
“Where an action is initially commenced in a state court against the individual driver * * * effectuation of the exclusive remedy provision of § 2679(b) is accomplished under subsection (d) of that statute. * * * In view of [the statutory] language, appellant’s claim, which concededly had its origin in the negligence of a Government employee who was acting within the scope of his employment, could not be removed from the ambit of28 U.S.C. § 2671 et seq. (Federal Tort Claims Act) * * * by the filing of a suit against the employee in a state court.”
In other words, after an action has been brought against a government employee in state court, and the Attorney General certifies or it is otherwise conceded that said employee was acting within the scope of his employment at the time of the accident, the plaintiff no longer has a right to sue the employee individually in state court; on the contrary, the plaintiff’s sole and exclusive remedy is against the United States. Hoch v. Carter, 242 F.Supp. 863 (D.C.N.Y., 1965); Perez v. United States, 218 F.Supp. 571 (S.D.N.Y., 1963); Gustafson v. Peck, 216 F.Supp. 370 (N.D.Iowa, 1963); Whealton v. United States, 271 F.Supp. 770 (D.C.Va., 1970); Noga v. United States, supra; Vantrease v. United States, supra; Meeker v. United States, supra.
Since it appears, regardless of the desires of plaintiff, that removal to federal court is appropriate in this cause, the Court must reluctantly still refrain from exercising jurisdiction unless it can be established that prior to the institution of this suit a claim was filed with the appropriate administrative agency pursuant to the requirements of
An affidavit has been filed by defendant United States of America asserting that there has not been, in fact, a claim filed with the appropriate administrative agency, which in this case would be either the Agricultural Stabilization and Conservation Board or the Department of Agriculture. Nothing has been filed by the plaintiff to refute such an assertion. Therefore, the Court shall allow plaintiff a period of. ten (10) days in which to present some evidence of his having filed an administrative
*1227
claim. In the event plaintiff fails to present, or cannot present, such evidence, the Court must regretfully hold that it does not have jurisdiction in this action and defendant’s motion to dismiss will have to be granted.
The Court feels that the law should permit plaintiff his option, under the circumstances present, to pursue his case in state court. Still, the court will have to adhere to what seems settled law under the authorities cited and grant the removal.