History
  • No items yet
midpage
Smith v. Auldridge.
3 N.C. 382
Sup. Ct. N.C.
1806
Check Treatment

Lead Opinion

charged that the creek was the boundary, and included within the bounds of Auldridge's deed the land in controversy.

Smith proved on the trial many admissions of Auldridge, after his purchase, that the said line, South 50 E., was his boundary; (383) and many offers on his part to purchase the land between that and the creek. Upon this evidence after a verdict for the defendant, Smith filed his bill, stating a mistake in drawing the deed, and that the *Page 335 said line was the line shown to him at the time of the purchase, and understood it to be the line purchased to. It prayed an injunction against the costs of the action in ejectment until the court of equity should make further order upon this bill.






Addendum

The plaintiff knew of Auldridge's claim, and has taken a wrong mode of obtaining redress. He should not have brought an ejectment. The costs have accrued in consequence of this wrong step, which is imputable to him. It is said the defendant was wrong in setting up a defense for the lands claimed by the plaintiff, as he knew he, the defendant, had not purchased them. Plaintiff, however, had every reason to believe he would set it up, because he had taken possession and kept it. The first departure from correctness was on the part of the plaintiff in this bill, and therefore I will not screen him, by an injunction, from the costs incurred thereby.

Injunction refused.

NOTE. — On the first point, see the references in the note toPerson v. Roundtree, 1 N.C. 69; S. c., 2 N.C. 378.

Cited: Rogers v. Mabe, 15 N.C. 194; Power v. Savage, 170 N.C. 629.

Case Details

Case Name: Smith v. Auldridge.
Court Name: Superior Court of North Carolina
Date Published: Jul 5, 1806
Citation: 3 N.C. 382
Court Abbreviation: Sup. Ct. N.C.
AI-generated responses must be verified and are not legal advice.
Your Notebook is empty. To add cases, bookmark them from your search, or select Add Cases to extract citations from a PDF or a block of text.