Slocum v. PeopleSlocum v. People
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Bakes
delivered the opinion of the Court:
■ We are called upon to give a construction to the first section of the Criminal Code, Revised Statutes 1874, p. 352, which reads as follows:
“ Whoever entices or takes away any unmarried female of a chaste life and conversation from the parents’ house, or wherever she may be found, for the purpose of prostitution or concubinage, and whoever aids and assists in such abduction for such purpose, shall be imprisoned in the penitentiary not less than one nor more than ten years.”
The first question that arises upon this record is, as to what constitutes an enticing or taking away from the parents’ house, within the purview of this statute. Is it sufficient that a girl living with her parents is induced, by persuasion or enticements, to go to some convenient place, away from her father’s house but in the immediate neighborhood, for the purposes of prostitution, where she is gone only for an hour or two at a time, she continuing all the while to dwell with the parents, as usual? We think it plain, both upon reason and authority, that the taking or enticing is not necessarily to a place distant from the family residence, or that any particular length of distance is required in order to bring the case within this requirement of the statute. If any fixed distance is a prerequisite to the commission of the offense charged, then it is difficult to perceive how or by what means we are to ascertain what this required distance is, and to distinguish cases without the statute from those within, and determine where the dividing line is. So, also, it would appear it is not essential that the girl should be kept permanently away from the parental home, or that there should be any intention so to keep her. Bishop’s Stat. Crimes, 637.
Under English enactments of a somewhat similar character, it was held to be a sufficient taking where the girl was taken for an hour or two from her father’s house and married, but not defiled. Regina v. Baillie, 8 Cox C. C. 238. And in
In Regina v. Miller, 14 English Beports, by Moalc, 633, the girl was in the lawful charge of her master, and not of her father, at the time of the alleged offense, and she had permission from her master to be away, and the prisoner had no connection with the transaction until after she had left his house under such permission. The prosecution was based on 24 and 25 Viet. C. 100, sec. 55, which imposes punishment on any one who shall unlawfully take an unmarried girl under the age of sixteen years “out of the possession and against the will of her father or mother or any other person having the lawful
Enticing or taking aAvay a female from the parents’ home, for the purpose of prostitution, is clearly Avithin the language of our statute, be that taking or enticing to a place distant or near, or be it for a long or short space of time. The crime charged is abduction, and it is so styled in the body of the statute. The taking or enticing aAvay from the parents’ house is the gist of the offense. Under the English statutes against abducting an heiress, the offense might Avell be committed although the detention Avas but temporary and the transaction confined to but an exceedingly limited territory. Such enticing or taking away is also Avithin the intention of our statute. The legislature, in passing the statute under consideration, had undoubtedly in view the punishment of pimps and procurers Avho entice and carry off young girls and induce them to abandon, for once and all, their homes and the control of their parents for the purpose of becoming permanent inmates of houses of ill-fame or living as concubines; but it also had in AÚeAV such persons, more especially in large towns and cities, as entice girls from the parents’ house to a den of infamy in the immediate neighborhood, for the purpose of prostituting them for pay to whomsoever may come, even though the absences from the parental roof are of but a temporary character. The latter evil is not only as much Avithin the terms of the statute as the former, but is equally Avithin the evils intended to be remedied. We are not inclined to explain aAvay the meaning of a Avholesome and remedial statute in order to make an exception of that Avhich is plainly within the mischief intended to be cured.-
At the same time Ave do not Avish to be understood as holding
The second ‘point raised is as to whether the prosecuting witness, in leaving her parents’ house, was enticed by defendants, and left in consequence of such enticements. It admits of no doubt, if the evidence of the prosecution is reliable, that the plaintiffs in error were acting in concert in all that was done by either to accomplish the ruin of this young girl. We .find from that evidence that almost from their very first acquaintance with the girl, Mrs. Slocum held out inducements to her to come to her house and have intercourse with the co-defendant, but the enticements and allurements suggested were of such character that we do not care to repeat them. Before any act of illicit intercourse, she frequently went to the girl’s home to get her to come, frequently sent a boy for her, and called her in from the street as she was passing the house in going down town. The allurements held out were such as would perhaps most usually and naturally repel and disgust a virtuous woman, but then they were such as were calculated to awaken the desires and inflame the imagination and passions, and weaken the moral and prudential restraints that surrounded her. The kind and extent of seductive arts, which will satisfy the law, do not depend upon any absolute rule.
If the inducements held out did, as a matter of fact, entice her from her parents’ house, then both the letter and spirit of the statute are met, at least so far as this point is involved.
Tested by this rule there is evidence to show that the purpose was prostitution. Both the plaintiffs in error, as the girl testifies, tried to induce her to enter upon a life of prostitution,— to have intercourse with other men whom they would get and bring to the house, and who would pay her therefor, telling her that she could make money that way. They also attempted to persuade her to stay with them rather than at home, promising her that she could go to dances and have money when she wanted it, and that they would furnish her with clothes. These inducements were first held out to her shortly after her seduction was accomplished. Again, it is impossible to account for the conduct of the wife, as detailed by the girl, in aiding in and insisting upon this seduction by, and subsequent illicit intercourse with, her own husband and in her own house, upon any reasonable hypothesis other thau that she expected to gain pecuniary reward by the prostitution of the girl.
The fact that she was not reduced to a life of public prostitution
It is argued that Miss Templeton was not a female of chaste life and conversation, and therefore the statutory crime was not committed. We admit that this clause requires that she shall possess actual personal virtue as distinguished from a good reputation. The presumption of law is, that her previous life and conversation were chaste, and the onus was upon the defendants to show otherwise. This presumption is fortified by the undisputed facts, which appear in the evidence, that at the time she first met plaintiffs in error she was under eighteen years of age, that she had always lived with her parents, and for nine years had lived at Woodhull, and went to school and church and mingled with other girls, and moved in respectable society. Then, she herself testifies that she never had intercourse with any man but Slocum. The only facts urged to rebut this presumption and proof of chastity are her lewd life and conversation after she had been subjected to the enticements and corruptions of plaintiffs in error. They are estopped from thus taking advantage of their own wrong. These persuasions, that poisoned her mind and corrupted her morals, form the very enticements that enter as a necessary ingredient into the crime charged against them.
The relations that existed between Jay Slocum and the prosecuting witness for a period of nearly nine months, would seem to support the second,count of the indictment, -which charges that she was enticed away for the purpose of concubinage. He had connection with her three or four times a week in his own house, frequently in the presence of the wife. As we have
It is urged, that the story told by Miss Templeton is incredible,—that it is unnatural, unreasonable, and contrary to the experience of mankind. This argument is well answered by saying, Avives sometimes lead lives of prostitution Avith the consent and by the solicitation of their husbands; that daughters too often lead lives of shame in houses of ill-fame kept by their parents; and that Ave learn from the books that offenses of an even more incredible nature than these are sometimes perpetrated. Besides, her testimony is corroborated in some of its material details by that of William Templeton, Mrs. Boot and BritAvall Taylor. No motive is perceived that would lead her to make the charge, if false. The evidence shoAvs that Jay Slocum was poor and a married man. A false charge of bastardy Avould naturally be made against one who either had property or was single. If her charge Avas false she lessened the probability of its being believed by including the Avife as a ’partic.eps criminis, and it is improbable that she Avould falsely bring such accusation against a married Avoman Avith whom she had been on terms of intimacy and friendship, and Avith Avhom she had no difficulty other than such as greAV out of the charge itself. There is only the uncorroborated testimony of the defendants themselves to contradict the tale she tells, and a number of witnesses impeached the character of one of them for truth and veracity. The jury heard the witnesses upon the stand and saw them face to face, and they believed the story
ISTo objections are pointed out to the rulings of the court upon the instructions, and such rulings seem to be in substantial conformity with the views herein expressed.
We find no error in the record, and the judgment of the circuit court is affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.