Seaver v. BigelowsSeaver v. Bigelows
- Reporters:
- , , , ,
- Before:
- Nelson
The judgment creditors who have joined in this bill have separate and distinct interests, depending upon separate and
It is true, the litigation involves a common fund, which exceeds the sum of $2000, but neither of the judgment creditors has any interest in it exceeding the amount of his judgment. Hence, to sustain an appeal in this class of cases, where separate and distinct interests are in dispute, of an amount less than the statute requires, and where the joinder of parties is permitted by the mere indulgence of the court, for its convenience, and to save expense, would be giving a privilege to the parties not common to other litigants, and which is forbidden by law.
The case is analogous to proceedings in admiralty in behalf of seamen for wages, and salvors for salvage, where the practice of the court is well settled.
In the case of the seaman, though the contract is separate and not joint, all may join in the libel and carry on the proceedings, in form, jointly, to the decree, which assigns to each severally the amount due. If the sum thus assigned is under $2000, neither party can appeal.* So in respect to the case of salvage, where the amount charged upon the goods of each of the several claimants is less than this sum.†
The case of Rich v. Lambert‡ furnishes another illustration. There, several owners of cargo, having separate and distinct interests, filed a libel against the vessel for damage done to the goods on the voyage. The court decreed damages in their favor, but with the exception of two of the cases the amount was under $2000. The court dismissed the appeals for want of jurisdiction.
DISMISSED FOR WANT OF JURISDICTION.
NOTE. — Similar decree made for the same reason in the case of Field v. Bigelow, and in one branch of Myers v. Fenn.