Salazar v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueSalazar v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Goeke
Diana P. Hinton, for respondent.
MEMORANDUM FINDINGS OF FACT AND OPINION
GOEKE, Judge: These consolidated cases arise from petitions for judicial review of two notices of determination concerning
We have jurisdiction to review respondent‘s collection determination relating to the employment tax liabilities as well as the income tax liabilities under amended
FINDINGS OF FACT
Some of the facts have been stipulated and are so found. The stipulations of facts and related exhibits are incorporated herein by this reference. At the time the petitions were filed, petitioners, husband and wife, resided in New York.
Previously, petitioners were residents of Nevada, where they owned and operated a retail art gallery named Artistic Nature. While operated by both petitioners, the gallery was organized as a sole proprietorship in the name of Mr. Salazar. The operation, and ultimately the failure, of Artistic Nature has led to the current proceedings. Respondent seeks collection of petitioners’ outstanding Federal income taxes, penalties, and interest for taxable years 1997, 1998, and 1999. Respondent also seeks to collect the outstanding employment tax liabilities of Mr. Salazar related to Artistic Nature from 1998 through 2001.
On January 23, 2001, when Artistic Nature was failing, petitioners filed for chapter 13 bankruptcy protection in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Nevada. Petitioners captioned their bankruptcy petition as “Claude E. Salazar dba
On February 1, 2001, respondent filed a proof of claim with the bankruptcy court, which respondent later amended. On respondent‘s last amendment to the proof of claim, filed on September 27, 2003, respondent listed a secured claim of $19,915.40, an unsecured priority claim of $43,673.45, and an unsecured general claim of $8,850.74. The secured claim related to a lien respondent had previously filed with respect to petitioners’ 1997 and 1998 income tax liabilities, and it included penalties and interest. The unsecured priority claim also included interest. Petitioners, while represented by counsel, did not file an objection to respondent‘s claims. On July 25, 2002, petitioners received a discharge of debtor from all dischargeable debts. On August 22, 2005, the bankruptcy trustee disbursed $17,834.51 to respondent. The bankruptcy case was closed on March 30, 2006.
During the 2000, 2001, and 2002 tax years, petitioners allowed withholdings from income to exceed their income tax liabilities, which created overpayments totaling $15,814.91. On October 2, 2003, respondent applied these overpayments to petitioners’ 1997 income tax liabilities. On October 6, 2003, respondent assessed $3,192.34 in interest and an additional
After petitioners received the discharge of debtor, respondent initiated collection on petitioners’ liabilities. On October 27, 2003, respondent sent petitioners a separate letter for each of the outstanding liabilities stating that he intended to seek collection by levy. Respondent‘s notification of intent to levy indicated the following liabilities, including penalties and interest:
| Tax From Form | Period Ending | Unpaid Balance |
|---|---|---|
| 1040 | 12/31/1997 | $437.21 |
| 1040 | 12/31/1998 | 5,923.33 |
| 1040 | 12/31/1999 | 6,923.71 |
| 941 | 12/31/1998 | 3,970.30 |
| 941 | 3/31/1998 | 6,248.92 |
| 941 | 6/30/1999 | 5,658.56 |
| 941 | 9/30/1999 | 7,000.45 |
| 941 | 12/31/1999 | 6,122.27 |
| 941 | 3/31/2000 | 5,006.08 |
| 941 | 6/30/2000 | 5,626.37 |
| 941 | 9/30/2000 | 6,575.15 |
| 941 | 12/31/2000 | 5,855.57 |
| 941 | 3/31/2001 | 5,118.99 |
| 941 | 6/30/2001 | 2,210.01 |
Petitioners’ file was forwarded to Appeals Settlement Officer Bruce Conte. On May 14, 2004, Mr. Conte contacted petitioners to schedule a conference. At the same time, Mr. Conte contacted respondent‘s internal bankruptcy specialists. Mr. Conte received a fax from a specialist outlining petitioners’
On or about May 24, 2004, petitioners submitted a completed Form 656, Offer in Compromise, to respondent seeking to resolve their outstanding employment and income tax liabilities for $9,024.25, to be paid within 90 days from notice of acceptance of the offer. Upon receipt of the offer-in-compromise, Mr. Conte contacted petitioners to seek additional financial information. Over the course of several months, Mr. Conte and petitioners corresponded on multiple occasions with respect to additional documents Mr. Conte needed in evaluating petitioners’ offer-in-compromise. In one letter to Mr. Conte dated August 13, 2004, petitioners requested that “given that the Bankruptcy Court has failed to render a final accounting to date, the penalties attributable to the principal balance outstanding should be waived.”
While he was attempting to obtain additional information about petitioners’ economic situation, Mr. Conte was also attempting to determine what amount would be paid to respondent from petitioners’ bankruptcy estate. Mr. Conte contacted respondent‘s internal bankruptcy specialists on numerous
According to his case record, Mr. Conte was concerned that accepting an offer-in-compromise while awaiting a final distribution from the bankruptcy might jeopardize respondent‘s claims to that distribution. Mr. Conte performed research, including reviewing the Internal Revenue Manual (IRM), to assist with his consideration of petitioners’ offer-in-compromise. Mr. Conte noted the IRM‘s caution on accepting an offer-in-compromise while awaiting a distribution of assets from a bankruptcy. Mr. Conte also sought and received legal advice on the effect an offer-in-compromise would have on the pending bankruptcy distribution. Counsel from within the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) advised Mr. Conte that acceptance of the offer-in-compromise risked respondent‘s claim to the distribution and that the offer-in-compromise should be increased by the amount respondent expected to receive from the bankruptcy.
I have received guidance from our Counsel regarding the acceptance of an Offer in Compromise in an instance where the distribution of the assets of the bankruptcy has not been completed. This, as you may recall, was the primary issue surrounding your * * * request for an offer.
It is Counsel‘s opinion, as it is mine, that if the Service were to accept an offer in this instance, the Service would at that point no longer have a claim to any distribution of the bankruptcy proceeds.
It is also our opinion that the only way that an offer could be accepted under these circumstances, is for the Service to attempt to determine how much of the distribution we would be entitled to and add that to the amount of the offer.
Mr. Conte went on to reason that respondent would likely receive approximately $20,000 from the pending distribution. Accordingly, Mr. Conte informed petitioners that their offer-in-compromise would have to be increased by $20,000 before it could be accepted.
By letter dated November 22, 2004, petitioners responded that they could not pay the estimated $20,000 to respondent that was pending distribution without first receiving the distribution. As an alternative, petitioners offered to relinquish any rights they might have to the distribution for the benefit of respondent. Mr. Conte determined that this offer-in-compromise still risked respondent‘s forthcoming distribution and thus could not be accepted before receipt of the distribution
On January 4, 2005, respondent‘s Appeals Office issued a Notice of Determination Concerning Collection Action(s) Under
On February 3, 2005, petitioners filed a petition with this Court seeking review of respondent‘s determination under docket No. 2203-05L. Petitioners allege that respondent‘s rejection of their offer to compromise both their outstanding income tax liabilities and Mr. Salazar‘s employment tax liabilities was an abuse of discretion. Petitioners’ petition for docket No. 2203-
Respondent moved to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction as to Mr. Salazar‘s employment tax liabilities on the grounds that respondent had never issued a notice of determination concerning a collection action under
In the interim, on June 20, 2005, the bankruptcy trustee submitted to the bankruptcy court a Trustee‘s Final Report and Application for Compensation and Reimbursement (the final report). In the final report, payment on respondent‘s secured claim of $19,915.40 was not allowed. Instead, payment on respondent‘s priority claim of $43,673.45 was allowed. On August 22, 2005, the bankruptcy trustee disbursed $17,834.51 to respondent.
As of June 30, 2005, Mr. Salazar still had unpaid employment tax liabilities that included:
| Period Ending | Unpaid Balance |
|---|---|
| 12/31/98 | $2,636.81 |
| 3/31/99 | 5,281.02 |
| 6/30/99 | 4,067.44 |
| 9/30/99 | 5,904.60 |
| 12/31/99 | 5,158.55 |
| 3/31/00 | 4,219.10 |
| 6/30/00 | 4,729.82 |
| 9/30/00 | 5,522.11 |
| 12/31/00 | 4,670.33 |
| 3/31/01 | 4,097.97 |
| 6/30/01 | 1,752.20 |
On May 17, 2006, petitioners had an in-person hearing with Mr. Conley. On June 20, 2006, Mr. Salazar submitted a new offer-in-compromise. The basis of the new offer-in-compromise was again doubt as to collectibility, and the new offer included updated financial information. Mr. Salazar offered to compromise petitioners’ then-outstanding income and employment tax liabilities for $19,547.13. By this time, Mrs. Salazar was working as an attorney and Mr. Salazar as a manager of a
On October 18, 2006, respondent issued a Notice of Determination and Collection Action Under
OPINION
I. Introduction
While this matter has developed in a manner that has made it more complicated than necessary, in the end it is a collection review case in which petitioners principally sought to resolve their outstanding income and employment tax liabilities through an offer-in-compromise. Petitioners offered to settle all of their outstanding liabilities, including the income tax liabilities and the employment tax liabilities, for $9,024.25. Respondent rejected the offer-in-compromise because he was likely to receive more from the petitioners’ pending bankruptcy. Petitioners want the Court to determine that respondent‘s rejection was an abuse of discretion and that respondent be compelled to accept the offer-in-compromise with respect to both the income taxes and the employment taxes. We find that respondent did not abuse his discretion.
Following a hearing, the Appeals Office must make a determination whether the Secretary may proceed with the proposed collection action. We have jurisdiction to review the Appeals officer‘s determination.
II. Offers-in-Compromise
Petitioners first seek to compel respondent‘s acceptance of their offer-in-compromise. Petitioners suggest that the failure to accept their original offer-in-compromise was an abuse of discretion.
We do not conduct an independent review of what would be an acceptable offer-in-compromise. Murphy v. Commissioner, 125 T.C. 301, 320 (2005), affd., 469 F.3d 27 (1st Cir. 2006); Fowler v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2004-163. The extent of our review is
The
If an offer-in-compromise is submitted where a taxpayer has also filed a bankruptcy petition, the Commissioner cautions against acceptance of the offer-in-compromise in the window between a taxpayer‘s discharge in bankruptcy and the time the final distribution is made because “it is uncertain whether the Service would still have a valid claim in bankruptcy if an offer is accepted.” 1 Administration, IRM (CCH), pt. 5.8.10.2.3(2), at 16,368. Thus, the Internal Revenue Manual guidelines advise that “the amount acceptable for an offer should include the amount we reasonably expect to recover from the bankruptcy in addition to what can be collected from the taxpayer on non-discharged liabilities or from property outside the bankruptcy.” Id.
It is clear from the administrative record that Mr. Conte was concerned that accepting petitioners’ $9,024.25 offer-in-compromise would risk respondent‘s expected distribution from the bankruptcy. Mr. Conte had extended contact with respondent‘s bankruptcy specialists. He also performed his own research, including reviewing the IRM guidelines. Mr. Conte sought to determine the likely amount respondent would receive from the
Petitioners argue that respondent‘s rejection of the offer-in-compromise was based on an erroneous conclusion of law that the bankruptcy distribution was at risk. Petitioners argue that respondent‘s distribution from the bankruptcy was never at risk. If respondent‘s determination was based upon an erroneous conclusion of law, we must reject that view and find that respondent abused his discretion. See Swanson v. Commissioner, 121 T.C. 111, 119 (2003).
As respondent‘s counsel now explains, an offer-in-compromise must include all of the outstanding liabilities of the taxpayer. Further,
We believe, however, that respondent‘s risk, or at least his perceived risk, goes beyond simply the release of any secured claim he has to the bankruptcy distribution. If an offer-in-compromise must include all of the outstanding liabilities of the taxpayer, then acceptance and satisfaction of the offer would risk, if not extinguish, all claims the Commissioner had to the bankruptcy assets. The administrative record suggests it was this more generalized risk, to all of respondent‘s claims, that concerned Mr. Conte in evaluating petitioners’ offer-in-compromise. Nonetheless, petitioners fail to point to any authority to suggest that respondent‘s position that accepting an offer-in-compromise jeopardized the bankruptcy distribution was without legal basis, and the Court knows of none.
In furtherance of their argument that the bankruptcy distribution was not at risk, petitioners highlight their offer to relinquish any claim to the bankruptcy distribution for the
Petitioners make two additional arguments on why respondent’s determination was an abuse of discretion. First, petitioners suggest that respondent was announcing a bright-line rule and did not exercise discretion at all. Second, petitioners argue that respondent abused his discretion because he rejected the offer-in-compromise solely on the basis of the amount offered in contravention of
Petitioners first take issue with Mr. Conte’s requirement that their offer-in-compromise be increased by the amount of the expected distribution from the bankruptcy. The IRM guidelines instruct that an acceptable offer-in-compromise would have to include the amount that respondent expected to receive from the bankruptcy in addition to what respondent could collect from petitioners directly. Petitioners argue that by relying upon
Mr. Conte’s use of the IRM was not, however, a de facto enunciation of a bright-line rule that trumped the exercise of discretion. In evaluating an offer-in-compromise under doubt as to collectibility, the Commissioner must first determine the reasonable collection potential on the amount owed.
Thus, at first, the IRM instructs a settlement officer to consider the Commissioner’s standing as a creditor in the bankruptcy and advises that an acceptable offer-in-compromise include the amount the Commissioner reasonably expects to recover from the bankruptcy. 1 Administration, IRM (CCH), pt. 5.8.10.2.3(2). In other words, the Appeals officer should not accept an offer of $5 when doing so will risk the likely receipt of $10 down the road. Second, the IRM instructs that an acceptable offer-in-compromise should also include the amount that “can be collected from the taxpayer on non-discharged liabilities or from property outside the bankruptcy.”
Mr. Conte did not have to reach the second part of this analysis––the amount respondent could collect from petitioners outside of the bankruptcy. The $9,024.25 offer-in-compromise from petitioners was less than the $20,000 Mr. Conte expected respondent would receive from the bankruptcy, and he determined
Finally, petitioners argue that respondent abused his discretion by rejecting petitioners’ offer-in-compromise solely on the basis of the amount offered.
The administrative record makes clear that Mr. Conte did not reject petitioners’ offer-in-compromise solely on the basis of the amount offered, $9,024.25. Mr. Conte used respondent’s policies and procedures––the guidelines of the IRM as well as advice received from counsel––to evaluate the specifics of petitioners’ offer in the light of what respondent could
We are not unsympathetic to petitioners’ situation as they ultimately had no control over when any distribution from the bankruptcy would be made. Since then, petitioners’ financial outlook has improved dramatically. Mr. Salazar is now employed as a manager of a restaurant and has begun receiving Social Security benefits. Mrs. Salazar completed law school and now works as an attorney. Thus, while the $9,024.25 offer-in-compromise may have been the limit of what petitioners could pay in 2004, when Mr. Salazar submitted a second offer-in-compromise during the second collection review hearing with respect to his employment tax liabilities, respondent determined that Mr. Salazar was then in a position to pay the entirety of his outstanding employment tax liabilities. Petitioners have not presented any argument or evidence to the Court to suggest that respondent’s rejection of this second offer-in-compromise was an abuse of discretion.
III. Underlying Liability
To the extent the Court does not compel respondent to accept their original offer-in-compromise, petitioners argue in the alternative that respondent’s assessment of penalties and interest while their bankruptcy petition was pending was erroneous. Petitioners also argue that respondent erroneously applied the bankruptcy proceeds to the individual employment tax liabilities of Claude Salazar instead of their joint income tax liabilities.
In a collection review proceeding, a taxpayer may raise challenges to the existence or amount of the underlying liability for any tax period if the person did not receive any statutory notice of deficiency for such tax liability or did not otherwise have an opportunity to dispute the underlying liability.
In petitioners’ bankruptcy proceeding, respondent submitted a proof of claim for petitioners’ unpaid income tax and employment tax liabilities, including penalties and interest. Petitioners, while represented by counsel, did not file an objection to these tax liabilities. Accordingly, petitioners are precluded from challenging their underlying liabilities, including the penalties and interest. However, even if petitioners had raised the issue of whether respondent’s assessment of penalties and interest during their bankruptcy proceeding was erroneous, to the extent that respondent has not conceded this issue, we would sustain his assessment of penalties and interest.
Respondent admits having erroneously assessed a failure to pay penalty with respect to petitioners’ 1997 income tax account on October 23, 2003, while petitioners’ bankruptcy was pending.
With respect to the employment tax liabilities for Mr. Salazar under docket No. 23547-06L, petitioners again argue that additions to tax were sought for the period their bankruptcy was pending. However,
Petitioners also argue for abatement of interest on both their income tax and employment tax liabilities. The
Petitioners do not argue that the interest is excessive or was erroneously assessed under
At the time of the bankruptcy trustee’s final report, respondent possessed: (1) A secured claim of $19,915.40 for petitioners’ 1997 and 1998 tax liabilities; (2) an unsecured priority claim of $43,673.45 for petitioners’ 1999 income tax liabilities and Mr. Salazar’s 1998, 1999, 2000, and 2001 employment tax liabilities; and (3) an unsecured general claim of $8,850.74. However, only payment on respondent’s $43,673.45 priority claim was allowed by the bankruptcy trustee.
Respondent applied the $17,834.51 that was ultimately disbursed by the bankruptcy trustee on August 22, 2005, to the employment tax liabilities of Mr. Salazar that made up part of respondent’s priority claim. At first respondent applied the disbursement to the employment tax periods ending December 31, 1998, March 31, 1999, and June 30, 1999, in amounts that exceeded respondent’s priority claims for those periods. Eventually, respondent corrected this application of the proceeds to also
Petitioners claim that respondent should have applied the disbursement to petitioners’ joint income tax liabilities first instead of just Mr. Salazar’s employment tax liabilities. Where a taxpayer makes voluntary payments to the IRS, he does have the right to direct the application of payments to whatever type of liability he chooses. See, e.g., Estate of Wilson v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1999-221. However, where a taxpayer makes an involuntary payment, the IRS may allocate or reallocate the payment as it sees fit, regardless of a taxpayer’s designation. As we have stated: “An involuntary payment of Federal taxes means any payment received by agents of the United States as a result of distraint or levy or from a legal proceeding in which the Government is seeking to collect its delinquent taxes or file a claim therefor.” Amos v. Commissioner, 47 T.C. 65, 69 (1966); see also United States v. Pepperman, 976 F.2d 123, 127 (3d Cir. 1992) (noting that most courts to have considered the issue have concluded that payments made in the bankruptcy context are involuntary). In the light of the involuntary nature of the bankruptcy distribution, we find no error in respondent’s application of the proceeds to the employment tax liabilities of Mr. Salazar before the joint income tax liabilities of both petitioners. In any event, there is no
On the basis of the record before the Court, and with the exception of the failure to pay penalty for income tax year 1997 which respondent concedes, petitioners are liable for the taxes, additions to tax, and interest as determined by respondent. We further find that respondent did not abuse his discretion in rejecting petitioners’ offers-in-compromise. Thus, respondent‘s determination that the Federal tax levies were appropriate in these cases is sustained.
To reflect the foregoing,
Decision in docket No. 2203-05L will be entered under Rule 155.
Decision in docket No. 23547-06L will be entered for respondent.