Richardson v. DonehooRichardson v. Donehoo
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Haymond
delivered the opinion of the Court:
The appellant has assigned in his petition for the appeal and supersedeas the following as errors, for which he claims that said decree should be reversed, viz :
“ Your petitioner is advised and represents to your Honors that the said decree is erroneous, and that he is aggrieved thereby in the following particulars:
“First — In that the said decree was made before your petitioner’s exceptions to the answers of A. R. McCown and Daniel Donehoo (which exceptions were well taken) were passed on.
“ Second — In that your petitioner’s exceptions to the depositions of A. R. McCown and Daniel Donehoo were overruled, and the said cause was heard upon such depositions.
“Third — In that the said cause was finally heard upon said depositions when there had been no replication or issue, and while there were exceptions to the answers of the only two parties really interested otherwise than formerly.
*703“Fourth—In that the said final decree recites and is based upon a decree in another suit, of which there was no evidence in this suit, and the sufficiency of which, as a release of the lien mentioned in the said decree, your petitioner had no oportunity of ascertaining or contesting.
“Fifth—In that the said circuit court, after having rightfully taken jurisdiction of the said cause, did not proceed to ascertain the amount due by your petitioner to the said McCown, and did not decree that your petitioner should not be compelled to pay interest thereon.
“Sixth—rln that the said circuit court dissolved the injunction which had been granted to your petitioner, and dismissed his bill without in any way securing his title from the cloud resting upon it, the decree in the suit of Jenkins v. Burke being inter alios and of no benefit to complainant, and of no binding force as to him.
“Seventh—And your petitioner represents’ that the said decree is in other respects uncertain, informal and erroneous.”
As to the appellant‘s first assignment of error:
,f Exceptions taken by the said complainant to the answer put in by the defendant, C. D., to the said complainant’s bill of complaint. First exception — For that the said defendant, C. D., hath not, to the best and utmost of his knowledge, remembrance, information and belief, answered and set forth whether (set forth the interrogatory in the bill which is not ansioered, in hcec verba.) Second exception — For that the said defendant, C. D., hath not, in manner aforesaid, answered and set forth whether» etc., (as supra.) In ail which particulars the answer of the said defendant, C. D., is, as the said complainant is advised, imperfect, insufficient and evasive; and the said complainant therefore excepts thereto, and prays that the said defendant, C. D., may put in a further and better answer to the said bill of complaint.
“ J. E., Solicitor and Counsel for Complainant.”
The plaintiff’s second exception to said answer I think is not well taken. The matter of this exception is more a matter of evidence, if its assumption be true, than an objection to the sufficiency of the answer as to the matter to which the exception relates.
The third exception to said answer, I think, is not well taken. It seems to me that the answer is sufficient upon the subject to which this exception relates. I am not aware of any rule that requires the particularity in an answer as to the matter referred to, which this exception would seem to indicate. According to my views, as above expressed, said exceptions are not well taken and should have been disallowed. The plaintiff’s exception to the answer of Daniel Donehoo is not strictly sufficient *706uPon its face, for the reason stated in relation to the plaintiff’s exception to the answer ofMcCown, butwaiv-hig this objection I think the answer is substantially and sufficiently responsive to the allegations of the bill to which I understand said exception to refer. The answer in this respect might have been broader and more specific, still I think it is .sufficiently responsive and that the exception is not well taken and should have been disallowed. Mr. Robinson in the second volume of his Old Practice at page two hundred and thirteen says: “ There are some cases in the Virginia reports, which countenance the idea that an allegation in the bill, not denied by the answer, is to be considered as admitted. But these are cases, in which the allegation was that some fact did not exist, or that something was not done. Thus in Page’s ex’r v. Winston’s adm’r, 2 Munf. 298, a bill of injunction charged the plaintiff at law with having failed to do an act, on which the equity of his claim depended; and in his answer he took no notice of this allegation. The court at the hearing regarded this failure to answer the charge as a tacit acknowledgment of its truth, and decreed accordingly. See also Edgar v. Donally, &c., 2 Munf. 397; and Carr, Judge, in Coleman v. Lyne’s ex’r, 4 Rand. 457. “But, generally speaking, if the answer is deemed insufficient for omitting to notice any material allegation in the bill, the plaintiff should except to it, and call for a better answer. If, instead of excepting for insufficiency, the plaintiff enters a general replication to the answer, he cannot insist at the hearing that these allegations of the bill, which are not expressly denied by the answer, are admittéd to be true. Were he permitted to do this, he might surprise the defendant. By Chancellor Taylor in Dangerfield &c., v. Claiborne &c., 2 H. & M. 17; Coleman v. Lyne’s ex’r, 4 Rand. 454.”
*708This section of the Code was taken from the fourth section of the Code of Virginia of Í 849, and, so far as I have been able to ascertain after search, it was enacted in Virginia for the first time on the 27th day of February, 1S28. See acts of the Legislature of Virginia of 1827-8, page 20. The decision in the case of Clarke v. Linsley, adm’r, 4 Rand. 250, was made in May, 1826, prior to this act. In that case it is manifest, I think, that the answer was insufficient, and the case in this respect, as well perhaps as in others, materially different from the ease at bar. The case was not cited by counsel.
As to the appellant’s second assignment of error:
The first and second exceptions to the depositions of defendant, Daniel Donehoo, involve the sufficiency of the notice and order of adjournment of the taking ofthé depositions. No particular defect is pointed out by the appellant’s counsel in his brief or argument in the notice touching its sufficiency. I have examined the notice and the service thereof and the plaintiff’s affidavit,, and it *710seems to me that- the notice of taking the depositions is sufficient. The adjournment of the taking of the depositions from the 23d of February, 1875, to the 24th day of February, 1875, I think, is good and sufficient. The depositions seem to have been taken on the 24th of February, pursuant to the adjournment on the 23d. Huster v. Fulcher, 5 Rand. 124, 128, 129.
As to the appellant’s third assignment of error:
This exception has been fully answered in considering the plaintiff’s first assignment of error; and for the reasons there stated it is overruled.
*711.As to the appellant’s fourth assignment of error:
*712
In the last named case it was held by this Court, “if an appeal is taken from a decree of a circuit court to this Court, and the case is within its jurisdiction, the matter in controversy must be enquired into and determined; and if the decree be found to be right in all other respects and erroneous as to costs, this Court will not reverse the decree because of such error as to costs; but may, in a proper case, correct the decree as to the error, and affirm it as corrected.” I am not aware that this course lias been departed from by this Court since the last named decision.
Tucker in volume two of h.is Commentaries book three, *715page four hundred and sixty-six, edition of 1831 says: “In those cases, however, in which there is a covenant of seizin that is broken, or when the party never has been put in possession under his contract, relief against the payment of purchase is freely allowed; for as on the one hand it is unjust that he should retain both the possession and the purchase-money, so on the other it would be equally unfair, that the seller should get the purchase-money, where he has never been able to put his vendee in possession. So where before a conveyance or outstanding encumbrance has been discovered, the purchaser may retain so much of the purchase-money as will indemnify him, until it is removed, though there be no covenants against encumbrances, Sug. 345. And the like principle prevails, I conceive, even after a conveyance, where there is a covenant against encumbrances, even though the vendee knew of their existence, 3 Munf. 68; or even where there is no such covenant, provided the vendee did not know of them, and the vendor did; for the concealment brings the case within the principle of relief against fraud. 3 John. 375.”
Decree Corrected and Afpirmed.