Rhodes v. MeredithRhodes v. Meredith
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Vickers
delivered the opinion of the court:
The circuit court of Kane county dismissed appellant’s bill for partition for want of equity, and the record has been brought to this court by an appeal.
The real estate involved formerly belonged to Joshua Rhodes, and all parties in interest claim, in one way or another, from him. Rhodes died in Kane county, Illinois, December 19, 1910, leaving Addie M. Rhodes as his widow, and Martha Sheldon Rhodes, who claims to be his daughter by adoption. He also left John F. Rhodes, a brother, and a number of sisters and descendants of deceased sisters, as his collateral heirs. On April 25, 18S5, Rhodes and his wife, Addie M., conveyed a portion of the premises in controversy to Maria H. Severance, and within a few days thereafter- Maria Severance re-conveyed the same premises to Addie M. Rhodes. Neither of these deeds was recorded until the 10th day of January, 1911. No change was made in the possession of the premises in pursuance of these deeds. These conveyances were manifestly only resorted to as a means of transferring the title from Rhodes to his wife. On the nth of August, 1910, Rhodes executed a contract of bargain and sale of the farm in controversy to A. D. Hanna for the sum of $25,725. The contract was in writing, and provided for the payment of $5725 in cash March 1, 1911, and the execution of notes and a mortgage for the remainder. Rhodes- covenanted to convey the premises by a good merchantable title and surrender possession to the purchaser on that date. The contract of sale included that portion of the
There is nothing in the record to support the contention that the deed from Joshua Rhodes and wife to Mrs. Severance, and the deed from her to Mrs. Rhodes, were void for want of delivery. Mrs. Severance testifies that she paid nothing for her deed and received nothing when she re-conveyed to Mrs. Rhodes; that she held the deed- from the time it was made until she re-conveyed to Mrs. Rhodes. It is a fair and reasonable inference from the evidence that Joshua Rhodes intended to make a settlement upon his wife by giving her the north eighty acres of his farm and that the conveyance to Mrs. Severance was merely a convenient means adopted to accomplish his purpose. That he had a legal right to make a suitable provision for his wife where there are
Whatever of controversy may remain to be settled among the heirs of Joshua Rhodes, it must be held that Hanna is entitled to hold the land under his deed, un-’ molested by any of the conflicting claims to the purchase money. If, as we have sought to show, Hanna must at all
Again, the situation presented ‘by this record requires the application of the doctrine of equitable conversion. That doctrine rests on the maxim that equity regards that as done which ought to be done, and the situation presented by this record is a fitting illustration of the maxim. Under that rule real estate may, under proper circumstances, be regarded, in equity, as personal property and personal estate may be regarded as real, and transmissible and descendible as such. (Eaton on Equity, sec. 96; Howard v. Peavey, 128 Ill. 430.) When a valid, enforcible contract has been entered into for the sale of real estate, as between the vendor and vendee equity regards the vendee as the owner of the land and the vendor as the owner of the purchase money, which is personalty. The vendor is regarded as the trustee of the naked legal title for the benefit of the vendee, and the vendee as the trustee of the purchase money for the benefit of the vendor. (Lombard v. Chicago Sinai Congregation, 64 Ill. 477; Wright v. Troutman, 81 id. 374; Lewis v. Shearer, 189 id. 184.) Where th£ owner of real estate thus enters into a valid contract for its sale, the nature of his estate under the doctrine of equitable conversion is’changed and the real estate will be regarded as converted into personal property, and, in case of the death of the vendor before the contract is performed, it will be treated ’ as assets in the hands of his personal representative. 9 Cyc. 826; Keep v. Miller, 42 N. J. Eq. 100; 6 Atl. Rep. 495; Williams v. Haddock, 145 N. Y. 144; 39 N. E. Rep. 825; Bender v. Luckenbach, 162 Pa. St. 18; 29 Atl. Rep. 295.
The circuit court of Kane county did not err in dismissing appellant’s bill, and its decree will accordingly be affirmed.
Decree affirmed.