Reynolds v. McDermottReynolds v. McDermott
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Pierce
This is a petition for mandamus commanding the respondent to cease interfering in any manner with the petitioner in the performance of the duties of the office of superintendent of waterworks of the city of Lowell, and to cease from attempting to perform the duties of that office. The case was submitted to a single justice of this court upon the petition, answer, and an agreement as to facts. The justice ordered the petition dismissed as matter of law and, at the request of the petitioner, reports the case for determination to the full court.
The petitioner, in 1924, was examined by the civil service commission and was certified as one eligible for appointment to the position of superintendent of waterworks of the city of Lowell. In December,-1924, he was appointed to the position by the board of public service in accordance with the provisions of St. 1921, c. 383, § 30, Parts 3, 4 and 5. Previous to this appointment the petitioner, since July 12, 1920, had been assistant superintendent of the waterworks of Lowell, which was classified under the civil service laws.
The city of Lowell is governed by Plan B charter and St. *1601921, c. 383, in so far as the latter chapter is not inconsistent with G. L. c. 43 and with such ordinances as have been passed by the city council of the city of Lowell pursuant to
St. 1921, c. 383, § 38, so far as material, provides that “Administrative heads of departments, boards and commissions shall have the power to appoint and employ and to suspend or discharge all subordinate officers and employees in their respective departments, subject to civil service regulations, and laws relating thereto, and shall cause to be kept in their respective departments a record subject to public inspection of all persons appointed or employed therein, and of all persons suspended or discharged, and in case of suspension or discharge the reason therefor.”
*161
The board of public service performed the duties of their office until the passage of an ordinance by the city of Lowell on November 9, 1926. The ordinance is entitled “Ordinance to abolish-the office of the board of public service and transfer the powers and duties heretofore vesting in said *162board,” and provides in part as follows: § 1. “The Board of Public Service heretofore established by the provisions of Section 30, Chapter 383, Acts of 1921, is hereby abolished. All the powers, rights, duties and liabilities heretofore vesting in and imposed upon said Board are transferred as hereinafter set forth”; § 3. “There is hereby created the following administrative offices . . . Department of Water Works .... The Superintendent of Water Works shall be the administrative officer who shall have charge and direction of the Department of Water Works”; § 4. “All the powers, rights, duties and liabilities Heretofore vesting in and imposed upon the Board of Public Service . . •. in relation to the Department of Water Works, all the powers, rights, duties and liabilities as vested in the Commissioner of Water Works and Fire Protection, on the 31st day of December, 1921 . . . are hereby transferred to and imposed upon the Superintendent of Water Works. . . . the present Superintendent of Water Works, shall . . . administer the duties of . . . the department of Water Works, as . . . [such] duties are herein defined until . . . [his successor is] appointed and qualified as provided herein”; § 5. “The mayor of the City of Lowell, shall upon this ordinance taking effect appoint a . . . Superintendent of Water Works, whose . . . [term] shall expire on the first Monday of January, 1927, or until . . . [his successor is] duly appointed and qualified. . . . [the appointment] shall be subject to confirmation by the City Council. The Mayor . . . shall on the first Monday of January, 1927, appoint a . . . Superintendent of Water Works. . . . [the] appointment shall be subject to confirmation by the City Council. . . . [He] too . . . hold office for a term of three years from the said first Monday in January, 1927, and upon each three years thereafter the Mayor shall appoint such . . . [officer] with such like confirmation”; § 6. “Any and all ordinances inconsistent herewith are hereby repealed.”
Upon the passage of this ordinance, the petitioner on November 12, 1926, sent the mayor and city council a letter, a copy of which reads: “I herewith notify you that under the provisions of chapter 31 of the General Laws, I claim the *163right of a hearing upon the attempted abolishment of my civil service position of superintendent of water works by reason of the passage of an ordinance entitled ‘Ordinance to abolish the Office of Board of Public Service and transfer the Powers and duties heretofore vesting in said Board’, passed by the City Council, November 9,1926: and I respectfully request such hearing. Without waiving or prejudicing any rights which I may have under the law, I will continue to carry on the duties of superintendent of water works as formerly, together with any added duties provided by said ordinance.” Thereafter, and up to the time of the taking over of the office of superintendent of waterworks of the city of Lowell by the respondent, the petitioner continued to perform all the duties of said office. On March 15,1927, the respondent was appointed by the mayor to the position of superintendent of waterworks “pursuant to the provisions of law made and provided”; he was duly confirmed by the city council and was sworn to the faithful performance of his duties by the city clerk. “It is agreed by the parties that neither prior to the passage of said ordinance as set forth in petition, nor at any other time was the plaintiff notified of the proposed action of the city council of the city of Lowell, nor was he furnished with any statement in writing of any reason for his removal from said office, nor was he given a public hearing, nor were any charges preferred against him. It was further agreed that within three days after the passage of the aforesaid ordinance the plaintiff notified the mayor and city council of the city of Lowell of his attitude as hereinbefore set forth.”
It was contended by the petitioner before the single justice, and it is now argued before this court, that the position of superintendent of waterworks in the city of Lowell was a civil service position under
It was and is the contention of the respondent that the petitioner was appointed by the board of public service in accordance with St. 1921, c. 383, § 30, Parts 3, 4 and 5, as an officer whose term of office was unlimited but who could be removed by the board for cause which they deemed sufficient; citing O’Dowd v. Boston, 149 Mass. 443, 445; Lacy v. Selectmen of Winchendon, 240 Mass. 118, 120; Bailen v. Assessors of Chelsea, 241 Mass. 411, 414; that the civil service commission was without authority to examine, classify or certify under the rules and regulations of the civil service commission a position as defined in St. 1921, c. 383, § 30, Parts 3,4 and 5; that the ordinance of November 9,1926, abolishing the board of public service and transferring its powers and duties was valid, and by the passage of the ordinance the positions of executive officers went with the board; that the respondent was appointed, confirmed and qualified in a legal manner and is the lawful holder of the office.
Under St. 1921, c. 383, § 20, the administrative officer in charge of the water department in 1926 was the board of public service. Under § 30, Part 3 of that chapter, the board of public service had power to appoint a superintendent of waterworks to have charge of the waterworks of the city under the direction of the board and of the city engineer. It is plain under this appointment the superintendent was not the head of a department, but was a subordinate officer exercising his duties under the supervision of superior officers. It is manifest the’ ‘ executive officers ” appointed by the board of public service under § 30 Part 4 for an unlimited term *165were but subordinate officers and that they could not be suspended or discharged by the administrative heads of the departments to which they were appointed except in accordance with the civil service rules. The petitioner, as against the public service board acting under St. 1921, c. 383, § 30, Part 3, and § 38, was entitled to the protection afforded an employee under
The city of Lowell, however, had the power, when exercised in good faith under
Order denying petition affirmed.