Resolution Trust Corp. v. Shoreview Builders, Inc.Resolution Trust Corp. v. Shoreview Builders, Inc.
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Michels, Havey J.A.D., Conley
In November 1987, Shoreview executed and delivered to City Federal two notes in the principal amounts of $385,500 and $2,111,880. In January 1989, City Federal gave Shoreview a line of credit in the amount of $250,000 as evidenced by a third note executed by Shoreview. All three notes were guaranteed by Schreurs and Strzalka.
On December 8, 1989, the Office of Thrift Supervision (OTS) declared City Federal insolvent and appointed the RTC as receiver. The RTC then assigned its right to defendants’ notes to City Savings Bank, F.S.B., which was in conservatorship under the RTC. In September 1990, the OTS closed City Savings Bank and appointed the RTC as receiver, and on the same day the RTC assigned the notes to City Savings, F.S.B., a newly-created federal mutual association.
Because defendants had defaulted on the note payments, on November 9, 1990, the RTC, as conservator for City Savings, F.S.B., filed a complaint in the Law Division against defendants to recover the amounts advanced by City Federal to defendants.
The RTC moved to dismiss defendants’ counterclaim arguing that the Law Division lacked subject matter jurisdiction, see R. 4:6-2(a), because defendants had failed to comply with the comprehensive federal administrative claims procedure under FIRREA. The trial judge denied the motion, reasoning that defendants’ counterclaim was in reality an affirmative defense which was not a “claim” subject to the administrative procedure under FIRREA. In denying the RTC‘s motion for reconsideration, the judge found it significant that the RTC had in the first instance filed an action in the state court against defendants. As a consequence, the judge reasoned, defendants should not be precluded from raising what he deemed a “defense” in a “collection action” in the state court proceeding.
I
Congress‘s passage in 1989 of FIRREA was intended to address the recent savings and loan crisis. H.R.Rep. No. 54(I), 101st Cong., 1st Sess., 1, 302-12, reprinted in 1989 2 U.S.C.C.A.N. 86, 98-108. The act provides a detailed regulatory framework so as to “restore the financial integrity of the
FIRREA carefully circumscribes the scope and form of judicial review of the agency‘s disallowance of a claim asserted against the RTC in its capacity as receiver. The act creates a comprehensive administrative procedure for adjudicating claims asserted against a failed depository institution. As receiver, the RTC initiates the process by giving prompt notice to creditors of the failed institution by advising them they have (at least) 90 days from publication of notice to present their claims against the assets of the institution.
Section 1821(d)(13)(D) provides that:
Except as otherwise provided in this subsection, no court shall have jurisdiction over —
(i) any claim or action for payment from, or any action seeking a determination of rights with respect to, the assets of any depository institution for which the Corporation has been appointed receiver, including assets which the Corporation may acquire from itself as such receiver; or
(ii) any claim relating to any act or omission of such institution or the Corporation as receiver. [Emphasis added.]
Thus, “no court” shall have jurisdiction over “any claim” against the RTC or the failed institution except as provided by FIRREA. That the administrative remedy under the act is exclusive is also apparent from FIRREA‘s legislative history. The Report of the House Banking, Finance and Urban Affairs Committee reported on FIRREA that a judicial de novo review will be available only “[a]fter exhaustion of streamlined administrative procedures,” and the House Judiciary Committee reported that the act provides for judicial involvement in the resolution of claims only as the act “itself provides.” Circle Indus., 749 F. Supp. at 453-54.
Further, the federal decisions under the act have uniformly held that Congress intended to vest the RTC with primary jurisdiction to determine a “claim” against a failed institution before judicial intervention. Praxis Properties, Inc. v. Colonial Sav. Bank, S.L.A., 947 F.2d 49 (3rd Cir.1991). Once the RTC has been appointed receiver, a claimant must comply with FIRREA‘s statutory procedures as a prerequisite to federal jurisdiction. Id.; Rosa v. RTC, 938 F.2d 383, 392-93 (3rd Cir.1991), cert. denied, ___ U.S. ___, 112 S.Ct. 582, 116 L.Ed.2d 608 (1991); Circle Indus., 749 F. Supp. at 454. By enacting FIRREA, “Congress expressly withdrew jurisdiction from all courts over any claim to a failed bank‘s assets that are made outside the procedure set forth in section 1821.” Federal Deposit Ins. Corp. v. Shain, Schaffer & Rafanello, 944 F.2d 129, 131 (3rd Cir.1991) (emphasis added); see also Rosa, 938 F.2d at 391. In short, the administrative claims procedure under the act is exclusive. Resolution Trust Corp. v. Elman, 761 F. Supp. 245, 247 (S.D.N.Y. 1991), aff‘d, 949 F.2d 624 (2nd Cir.1991).
II
In view of FIRREA‘s pervasive regulatory scheme, we are satisfied that if defendants’ counterclaim is deemed a “claim” under the act, the Law Division had no subject matter jurisdiction to hear and decide it. It is undisputed before us that the RTC published notice pursuant to
III
The question then becomes whether defendants’ counterclaim is a “claim” under FIRREA. We do not agree with the trial judge‘s observation that the counterclaim was nothing more than a “defense” to the RTC‘s “collection action.” The gravamen of the counterclaim is that as a result of City
Indeed, it has been held that a “lender‘s liability” action similar to defendants’ counterclaim, bottomed on a failed bank‘s refusal to advance promised funds, constituted a “claim” under FIRREA. In Circle Indus., 749 F. Supp. at 447-455, City Federal and a consortium of banks had provided $158,000,000 in financing for the construction of “Port Liberte,” a 1,690 luxury apartment complex in Jersey City. The owner defaulted on the loan. Circle Industries, a subcontractor, alleged that City Federal had promised to provide sufficient funding to complete Phase I of the project and, in reliance on the promise, Circle Industries and other subcontractors completed Phase I. Id. at 450. When the RTC was named receiver for City Federal, Circle Industries filed suit against City Federal and the other banks seeking compensatory and punitive damages, alleging that the defendant banks had breached their covenant to deal
In enacting FIRREA, Congress intended litigants like Circle Industries to first submit their claims against failed savings and loan institutions to the RTC or FDIC before commencing an action in the district court.... “Therefore, this court has no jurisdiction over the claims [for breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty and fraudulent misrepresentation] raised in plaintiff‘s complaint.” [Id., (quoting Frawley Assocs. v. City Federal Sav. Bank, No. CIV. A. 90-2060, 1990 WL 63546, at *7 (E.D.Pa. May 9, 1990).]
IV
In denying the RTC‘s motion to dismiss, the trial judge distinguished a direct claim asserted against a failed institution from a claim asserted in response to an action commenced in the state court by the RTC on behalf of the institution. The judge suggested that when a claim is asserted as part of a counterclaim in response to the RTC‘s suit in a state court, the counterclaim does not fall within FIRREA‘s reach. However,
V
Defendants’ counterclaim not only seeks money damages, but may fairly be read to include a claim of equitable recoupment. Recoupment is the “right of the defendant, in the same action, to cut down ... plaintiff‘s demand[.]” Superior Air Products Int‘l, Inc. v. Director, Div. of Tax., 9 N.J. Tax 463, 470 (Tax Ct.), (quoting 20 Am.Jur.2d Counterclaim, Recoupment, and Setoff, § 1 at 228 (1965)), aff‘d o.b., 10 N.J. Tax 238 (App.Div. 1988). Recoupment is in the nature of a counterclaim against plaintiff‘s demand for a money judgment and is an efficient procedure for settling all the demands of all of the parties in one suit. Superior Air Products Int‘l, Inc., 9 N.J. Tax at 470. Recoupment is distinguishable from setoff in that:
the latter involves an affirmative recovery on a claim that may be independent of the transaction upon which the plaintiff‘s claim is based. While recoupment may be utilized only to reduce or extinguish the plaintiff‘s recovery, setoff may be awarded for any amount to which the defendant is entitled. [Beneficial Fin. Co. of Atlantic City v. Swaggerty, 86 N.J. 602, 609, 432 A.2d 512 (1981).]
It may be argued that a claim for a setoff, being an affirmative claim, is barred by FIRREA, but a recoupment is not because it may be “utilized only to reduce or extinguish the plaintiff‘s recovery[.]” Id. However, the distinction between a setoff and recoupment becomes blurred and of little consequence when the provisions under FIRREA and its underlying purpose are considered. Recoupment clearly is a claim which
Reversed and remanded for the entry of an order dismissing defendants’ counterclaim.