Quick Response Commercial Division, LLC v. Cincinnati Insurance Co.Quick Response Commercial Division, LLC v. Cincinnati Insurance Co.
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Gary L. Sharpe
MEMORANDUM-DECISION AND ORDER
I. Introduction
Plaintiff Quick Response Commercial Division, LLC, as assignee of
II. Background
A. Facts1
Cincinnati issued a commercial property insurance policy to Charbonneau Properties, LLC which was effective from February 28, 2012 to February 28, 2013. (Dkt. No. 18, Attach 5 at 25-72; Def.’s Statement of Material Facts (SMF) ¶ 1, Dkt. No. 18, Attach. 1 at 2-6.) On August 9, 2012, Charbonneau sustained fire, smoke, and other damage to its property located at 2831 Route 9, Malta, Saratoga County, New York. (Def.’s SMF ¶¶ 2-3.) Shortly thereafter, Charbonneau entered into a contract with Quick Response for Quick Response “to proceed with its recommended procedures to preserve, protect and secure the property.”
After meeting on September 13, 2012 with Charbonneau and Quick Response to discuss the loss suffered by Charbonneau, Cincinnati made several requests to Quick Response for estimates of the damage. (Def.’s SMF ¶¶ 6-7; Pl.’s SMF ¶ 6.) In March 2013, seven months after Charbonneau sustained the loss at its property, Quick Response provided an invoice to Cincinnati for $1,761,857.87. (Def.’s SMF ¶ 7.) According to Cincinnati, because this estimate included work outside of the scope of damage that the parties agreed to at their September 13, 2012 meeting, as well as work done for another tenant at the building, it retained a restoration remediation company to review and audit the claim. (Id. ¶ 8.) Subsequently, this restoration remediation company provided an audited invoice of $860,036.81, and Cincinnati paid at least $859,036.81 to Quick
When the parties failed to reach agreement on an amount to settle the claim, Cincinnati issued a “demand for appraisal” pursuant to the policy. (Def.’s SMF ¶¶ 11-13, Pl.’s SMF ¶ 12.) Under the policy, if Cincinnati and the insured disagree on the value of the property, the amount of net income and operating expense, or the amount of the loss,
either may make written demand for an appraisal of the “loss“. In this event, each party will select a competent and impartial appraiser and notify the other of the appraiser selected within [twenty] days of such demand. . . . The two appraisers will select an umpire. . . . The appraisers will state separately the value of the property, the amount of [n]et [i]ncome and operating expense, and the amount of “loss“. If they fail to agree, they will submit their differences to the umpire. A decision agreed to by any two will be binding.
(Def.’s SMF ¶ 17; Dkt. No. 18, Attach. 6 at 18-19.) Quick Response rejected Cincinnati’s demand for appraisal on several occasions, despite Cincinnati’s follow-up letter denoting May 30, 2014 as the deadline, under the terms of the policy, for Quick Response to name its appraiser. (Id. ¶¶ 14-15; Pl.’s SMF ¶ 14.)
B. Procedural History
On June 12, 2014, Quick Response commenced this action in New York State Supreme Court, Saratoga County, alleging (1) breach of contract for failure to cover the cost of repairs, and (2) breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing for failure to “fairly, timely and accurately adjust the claim.” (Compl. ¶¶ 49-79.) Quick Response seeks recovery of the amount owed on the invoice, the 18% interest accruing on that amount under the Charbonneau-Quick Response contract, and any attorney’s fees and costs associated with litigating the matter. (Id. at 13-14.) Cincinnati removed the action to this court, (Dkt. No. 1), and filed an answer with a counterclaim seeking an order compelling appraisal pursuant to the terms of the policy, (Dkt. No. 7). Despite a February 2015 discovery deadline, Cincinnati filed its now pending motion for summary judgment in September 2014.3 (Dkt. No. 18.)
III. Standard of Review
The standard of review pursuant to
IV. Discussion
A. Demand for Appraisal
First, Cincinnati argues that, because Quick Response failed to comply with the policy provisions with respect to the demand for appraisal, its claims must be dismissed. (Dkt. No. 18, Attach. 1 at 7-9.) Further, Cincinnati contends that, under
“‘New York public policy favors an appraisal proceeding over a trial on damages.‘” Amerex Grp., Inc. v. Lexington Ins. Co., 678 F.3d 193, 199 (2d Cir. 2012) (quoting SR Int‘l Bus. Ins. Co. v. World Trade Ctr. Props., LLC, No. 01 Civ. 9291, 2004 WL 2979790, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 1, 2004)). “This pro-appraisal policy is reflected in the November 2014 amendment to
[a]n appraisal shall determine the actual cash value, the replacement cost, the extent of the loss or damage and the amount of the loss or damage which shall be determined as specified in the policy and shall proceed pursuant to the terms of the applicable appraisal clause of the insurance policy.
Here, the dispute between the parties concerns Quick Response’s performance of work which exceeded the original scope of damage that the parties agreed to at their September 13, 2012 meeting. (Def.’s SMF ¶ 8; Dkt. No. 18, Attach. 6 at 60-61.) According to Quick Response, the agreed scope of damage was incomplete because it was determined only upon
Ultimately, there is no contention that Cincinnati has denied its liability for damages related to the August 9, 2012 fire, and Quick
Accordingly, because the parties dispute the extent and dollar value of the loss, and not the scope of coverage provided by the policy, Quick Response was required to comply with the policy’s appraisal provisions. See
B. Consequential Damages
Cincinnati next argues that Quick Response cannot maintain its claim for consequential damages because such damages were not contemplated
Under New York law, consequential damages resulting from a breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing may be asserted in an insurance contract context. See Zarour, 2015 WL 4385758, at *5; Gauthier v. Countryway Ins. Co., 100 A.D.3d 1062, 1063 (3d Dep’t 2012). Consequential damages “are in addition to the losses caused by a
Cincinnati contends that, because it was not a party to the Quick Response-Charbonneau contract, and the claim for consequential damages is not supported by any of the provisions of the policy, it did not contemplate such damages as the probable result of a breach at the time it issued Charbonneau the policy. (Dkt. No. 18, Attach. 1 at 10-15.) In response, Quick Response submits the affidavit of Robert Serafini, a current employee of Quick Response, and a former claims adjuster with Fort Orange Claims Service. (Dkt. No. 25, Attach. 2.) According to Serafini, “[t]he majority of times when a . . . property owner suffers a covered loss under an insurance policy they will hire adjusters or contractors to assist with the claim and to remediate and repair damage to the property they own.” (Id. ¶ 6.) Further, in his experience as a claims adjuster, Serafini was aware that “[these c]ontractors and vendors will require the insured to sign contracts[, which] include provisions for the payment of attorney fees and interest on unpaid balances for the work . . . performed,” typically in the range of 12-18% per year. (Id. ¶¶ 7, 9.) Moreover, Quick Response contends that depositions of Cincinnati’s claims adjusters, including Christine Snyder, Cincinnati’s claims adjuster
Ultimately, it cannot be said as a matter of law that Cincinnati did not foresee and contemplate the consequential damages sought by Quick Response. See Whiteface Real Estate Dev. & Constr., LLC v. Selective Ins. Co. of Am., No. 08-cv-24, 2010 WL 2521794, at *5 (N.D.N.Y. June 16, 2010) (holding that a reasonable factfinder could conclude that the interest paid on a loan an insured took out to cover reconstruction costs, as well as attorney’s fees and costs, were reasonably contemplated by the parties and necessary to return the insured to where it would have been had coverage been provided). Thus, the court denies Cincinnati’s motion for summary judgment on this ground, and the court will stay the action pending completion of the appraisal process.
V. Conclusion
WHEREFORE, for the foregoing reasons, it is hereby
ORDERED that Cincinnati’s motion for summary judgment (Dkt. No. 18) is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART as follows:
ORDERED that this action is STAYED pending completion of the appraisal process; and it is further
ORDERED that the Clerk provide a copy of this Memorandum-Decision and Order to the parties.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
September 10, 2015
Albany, New York
Gary L. Sharpe
U.S. District Judge