Price v. PeoplePrice v. People
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Mulkey
Lead Opinion
delivered the opinion of the Court:
On the 28th of June, 1883, Freeman Price, impleaded with James Moran and Abel Lindohl, was tried and convicted in the Henry county circuit court for the crime of burglary, the
The transaction upon which the indictment is based occurred about half-past six o’clock in the evening of the 9th of March, 1883, at the dwelling house of John Milroy, on his farm near the county line between Knox and Henry counties. Milroy testifies that at about the time indicated some one rapped at his door and inquired the road to Woodhull, a village some two or three miles distant; that about half an hour afterwards there was another rap at the door, and his wife, Mrs. Milroy, asked who was there, to which the party rapping replied, “It is me;” that she then inquired if it was Pete, meaning one of the neighbors, and receiving an affirmative answer, she thereupon opened the door, when three men, with cloths tied over the lower part of their faces, walked in, and one or all of them presented pistols, and said, “Your money or your life; ” that witness stepped into the kitchen to get a spade to defend himself with, where he was followed by the largest one, who subsequently proved to be Moran; that upon witness drawing a spade on Moran, the latter presented a pistol, but did not shoot, nor did witness strike with the spade; that Mrs. Milroy remained in the first room with the other two; that upon their ordering her to get a light she did so, and handed it to one of them, and then passed through the pantry down into the cellar, and from thence out of doors, when she screamed for help; that the parties thereupon left, without having got any money or other valuables. The three persons who thus entered the house were the accused and his co-defendants, and it is conceded that the latter entered the house of Milroy, as stated, for the purpose of robbing him;
The gist of the offence charged is the intent with which the plaintiff in error entered Milroy’s house. The indictment charges it was with the intent to steal, and it is conceded the facts, as testified to by Milroy and his wife, are amply sufficient to make out a case against the accused, if there was no evidence explanatory of the criminating facts occurring at the house, and testified to by them, and it is therefore unnecessary to detail more particularly what transpired there. Judging the case by what occurred at Milroy’s house alone, the plaintiff in error does not stand in any better position than his co-defendants, who are confessedly guilty, and have not therefore joined in the writ of error. The defence set up by the former is in the nature of a plea of confession and avoidance. If he was really, as he claims, acting the part of a mere detective in accompanying the other two on their criminal mission, it is a matter of no significance that no difference could be seen in his conduct and the other two at Milroy’s house, for to have acted his part well that would reasonably be expected. To have merely stood by as though he were a silent spectator, would doubtless have excited the suspicions of his comrades,’ imperiled his own safety, and possibly have defeated the very object he claims to have had in becoming one of the party. The turning point in the case then is, is the evidence tending to show plaintiff in error was acting in the affair merely as a detective, sufficiently strong to raise a clearly well founded doubt of his guüt ? If so, he ought not to be convicted.
The accused testifies the first intimation he had of an intention to rob Milroy he obtained from Moran, who came
But the error in excluding this evidence was, perhaps, cured by the subsequent testimony of the witness. Further on in his testimony, in answer to the question, “Did you take any steps, after you were informed of the intended robbery, to prevent it?” the witness states that he did, by informing Van-Riper, the constable, and Mr. Byers; that on the day of the robbery he called VanRiper out of Frederick’s store, into the back room, and told him two young men were going to rob an old man, and also told him what Byers had said. The witness then proceeds in these words: “I said, you (meaning Van Riper) had better telegraph to Woodhull and have the officers ready for them. He said, ‘It won’t do. ” Let them go on, and if they steal anything they will be caught. If they see the officers, they’ll skip.’ I told him these two, and another from Oneida, were going to rob Milroy; that they were going at
While Byers denies that Price told him of the intended robbery before it occurred, yet he admits he called at his office next morning and told him all about what had happened, and through the information thus given the parties were arrested that day. Moreover, Col. Buswell, ex-sheriff of the county, testifies to a conversation with Byers, the next morning after the attempted robbery, in which the latter told him all about the affair, and witness states as his best recollection that Byers said Price had told him of the intended robbery before the attempt was made. Mrs. Adams, the mother of Price, also testifies that in a conversation she had with Byers, after the attempted robbery occurred, the latter said, referring to her son, “He did not do as he (Byers) told him ; that he went into the house, when he told him to stay out. ” She further states that her son told her all about the affair next morning, after it occurred. The details of this witness’ conversation with Byers, as given by her, notwithstanding she is the mother of the accused, are so natural and free from anything indicating they might have been manufactured for the occasion,
Waiving all controverted questions, the undisputed facts, as appears from the foregoing, are, that the accused, on the day of the attempted robbery, went deliberately to a constable of the town in which he lived and told him all about the contemplated crime, giving the true names of the parties, and telling him when and where it was to take place, and the name of the intended victim; that the attempt was made at the very time and place, and by the parties, stated by him, and that on the following morning he, in like manner, went to a justice of the peace and told him all about what had been done, and furnished him with the true names of the parties implicated, by means of which, on the same day, they were brought to trial, and were subsequently convicted of the crime. That a sane person, really guilty of committing so grave a
The judgment of the circuit court” is therefore reversed, and the cause remanded for further proceedings not inconsistent with what is here said.
Judgment reversed.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting:
Dissenting, as I do, from the conclusion reached by the majority of the court, I deem the questions involved of sufficient importance to justify the expression of my views at length, of the whole ease.
At the June term, A. D. 1883, of the circuit court of Henry county, Freeman Price, James Moran and Abel Lindohl were jointly indicted for the crime of burglary. On being arraigned defendants pleaded not guilty. At the trial they were all found guilty in manner and form as charged in the indictment, and the jury, by their verdict, fixed the term each should serve in the penitentiary. Price entered his motion for a new trial. It was overruled, and sentence pronounced on the verdict. To reverse that judgment Price brings the case to this court on a writ of error.
It is not denied that Moran and Lindohl entered the house of John Milroy with the burglarious intent to rob him of his money, which they supposed he had in his house at the time,
There is some evidence tending to establish the defence insisted upon, but of course the weight to be given to it was within the province of the jury to determine. It was for them to determine, from all the evidence before them, with what intent he acted. Under the statute of this State, as is well known, the jury in criminal cases are the judges of the law and the fact, and unless some error in the rulings of the court occurs on questions of law, calculated to mislead the jury as to questions of fact involved, or as to the admission or rejection of evidence, their verdict is seldom disturbed.
On considering the instructions given for the prosecution in this case, no serious objection is perceived to any of them. The law applicable to the facts is stated with sufficient accuracy. The fifth instruction of the series given for defendant certainly states the law as favorably for the defence he was making as he could expect to have it given. There is no just ground for complaint in the action of the court in giving and refusing instructions at the trial.
The defence is placed mainly on the broad ground defendant is guilty of no crime. At the trial he offered to prove, by his own testimony, that before going to the house where the burglary was to be committed, he told a justice of the peace, and perhaps a constable, what the parties contemplated doing, and asked the advice of the justice as to the propriety of his going with them, and that he was advised to do so that he might detect the parties in the commission of crime. To the giving of the proposed testimony an objection was interposed by the State’s attorney, which was sustained by the court. If it shall be conceded the testimony tendered was competent, the accused
Passing, then, to the consideration of the merits of the defence, there remains only to be considered the question of fact raised on the evidence, and that has relation to the guilt or innocence of the accused. As we have seen, that is ordinarily a question of fact for the jury, but still it is the duty of the court to see that no injustice is done, either from the passion or prejudice of the jury, or from any other cause.. On looking into the testimony contained in the record, it can not be said the verdict is so much against the weight of the evidence as to warrant a reversal of the judgment. It may be, and is, doubtless,, true, the accused had some talk with the constable or the justice of the peace, or with both of them, as to his purpose in going to the house of the prosecuting witness, prior to his going there, and it is certain that after he returned he communicated what had been done, to the officers of the law and others. These facts the jury were told they must consider in making up their verdict. Giving to these and all other extenuating facts all the force they are justly entitled to, it may be the jury rightly judged the accused did more than it would be lawful for a detective to do. It is admitted the accused went to the house of the prosecuting witness with others whose avowed purpose was to rob him of his money. That he might have done with no criminal intent. But he went much farther. It is proven he entered the house where the burglary was to be committed with one who carried a drawn pistol, that he knew was loaded with a deadly charge, that he presented in the face of the prosecuting witness, and “demanded his life or his money, ” and that accused
The judgment of the circuit court, in my opinion, ought to be affirmed.
Mr. Justice Craig, also dissenting.
Mr. Justice Walker : I do not concur in this decision.