Price v. HudsonPrice v. Hudson
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Shope
delivered the opinion of the Court:
This was an action of ejectment, by John N. Price, against Phoebe Hudson and William D. Hudson, to recover the northeast quarter of the north-west quarter of section 3, township 3 north, range 9, east, in Richland county. The general issue was filed, and a trial by jury resulted in a verdict of not guilty. A motion for new trial interposed by plaintiff was overruled, and judgment entered on the verdict, from which the plaintiff below prosecutes this appeal.
The first question presented is, did the title pass to Phoebe Hudson by the deed from her husband ? Waiving the question as to the right of the husband to thus convey the homestead, to render the deed operative as a conveyance an unconditional delivery was requisite; or if the delivery was conditional, or to take effect upon the happening of some event in the future, it must appear that the condition has been performed, or that the event has happened. (Skinner v. Baker, 79 Ill. 496; Hoig v. Adrian College, 83 id. 267; Stone v. Duvall, 77 id. 475.) It is not essential, however, to a delivery, that the deed should pass from the hand of the grantor to the grantee. Any disposition made of the deed by the grantor, with the intention thereby to make delivery of it, so that it shall become presently effective as a conveyance of a title, will, if accepted by the grantee, constitute a sufficient delivery. (3 Washburn on Real
But is said that the defendant should be estopped to deny title in Phœbe Hudson at the time of the furnishing of material and of performing the labor for which the mechanic’s lien was declared by the decree in said mechanic’s lien proceedings. None of the facts or circumstances relied on by counsel as creating an estoppel are shown to exist by a preponderance of the evidence. Instead of William B. Hudson standing by and permitting the mechanic and material-man to improve the property, under a contract with his wife, without objection on his part, exactly the opposite state of facts is shown by the evidence. There is little or no conflict in the evidence in respect of the facts out of which the mechanic’s lien proceedings arose. Hudson and wife were residing in the dwelling house on these premises in the spring of 1883. The husband had $300 in money, and for that sum Lamport proposed to build them a new dwelling, the dimensions and plan of which were talked over and agreed upon. Lamport went to the neighboring town of Olney to price or purchase material, and on returning reported to Hudson that the house could not be built for the sum of $300. Hudson told her that $300 was all the money he had, and if the house could not be built for that sum, to let it alone. Mrs. Lamport replied that she would go on with the building; that if it cost any more she would arrange with Mrs. Hudson for the balance; that Mrs. Hudson could pay the excess over the $300 by boarding the hands engaged in its construction, etc. Hudson then told her if the house cost any more than the $300 his land should not stand good for it, but if she would consent to look to his wife for her pay over and above the $300, to go on. To this Lamport assented, and the building was erected accordingly upon that understanding and agreement. Hudson paid $300 in cash, and hands were boarded to the amount of $8. Mrs. Lamport presented a bill for $138 additional, which being disputed by Mrs. Hudson, the
Finding no error in this record, the judgment of the circuit court is affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.