Port v. PortPort v. Port
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Scholfield
delivered the opinion of the Court:
This record presents only the single question, is the complainant the widow of Silas Port, deceased ?
It was proved, by a number of witnesses, that Silas Port and the complainant lived together, in rooms which he had rented at 457 South Clark street, Chicago, from May, 1870, until his death, in March, 1872. During this time, they ate and slept together, and, in other respects, deported themselves towards each other, apparently, as husband and wife. On a few occasions, they attended places of public amusement, where he introduced her as his wife. He frequently spoke of her, in the presence of others, as his wife, and introduced her to some of his acquaintances and friends by that designation.
It is, no doubt, true, that the mere cohabitation of two persons of different sexes, or their behavior, in other respects, as husband and wife, always affords an inference, of greater or less strength, that a marriage has been solemnized between them. Their conduct being susceptible of two opposite explanations, we
We are inclined to the opinion, supported as it is by the statements of many of the most eminent text writers, as well as by the decisions of courts of the highest respectability, that, inasmuch as our statute does not prohibit or declare void a marriage not solemnized in accordance with its provisions, a marriage without observing the statutory regulations, if made according to the common law, will still be a valid marriage, and that, by the common law, if the contract be made per verba de presentí, it is sufficient evidence of a marriage; or, if it be made per verba de futuro cum copula, the copula is presumed to have been allowed on the faith of the marriage promise, and that so the parties, at the time of the copula, accepted of each other as man and wife. Bishop on Marriage and Divorce, secs. 253, 254.
This is, however, merely a rule of evidence, and it is always competent, in such cases, to show by proof that the fact was otherwise. 1 Bishop on Marriage and Divorce, sec. 259; Myatt v. Myatt, 44 Ill. 473 ; Conant v. Griffin, Admr. 48 id. 410. The rule is well illustrated by the language of Lord Campbell, in The King v. Millis, 10 Clark & Fin. 534, 782, quoted by Bishop in the paragraph last referred to : “ If the woman, in surrendering her person, is conscious that she is committing an act of fornication, instead of consummating her marriage, the copula can not be connected with any previous promise that has been made, and marriage is not thereby constituted.” Upon this principle, it was held in Becking’s Appeal, 2 Brewst. (Pa.)
There is no pretense that there Avas a contract betAveen these parties to many, per verba de presentí, and we strongly incline to the belief, from the evidence, that Port always refused to agree to marry, at any time. Appellant, it is true, swears that there Avas a contract to marry in the future, but Olter sAvears that, about three Aveeks before Port‘s death, appellant Avas crying, and he asked her Avhat was the matter. She replied that her uncle was going to have them arrested for living in a state of adultery; that she had been pleading Avith deceased to marry her, and he Avould not do it; that she, in the morning, asked him to marry her, and he ansAvered her in language of contempt, too obscene for’ repetition. The Avitness says, on another occasion he said to appellant, alluding to the Avay in which she and deceased were living together: “It is no way to live, this way.” She replied: “He never will talk marry to me at all, from the first time he ever Avent with me.”
From the reading of this record, we perceive nothing from which we can conclude that William Port and Olter are not entitled to quite as much respect and confidence, as witnesses, as is appellant. The preponderance, then, upon this point, is against her. She is successfully contradicted, and we can not say that the court below erred, even if its decision could only be sustained on this view of the case.
But, if we shall concede that the evidence sufficiently shows there was a contract between these parties to marry in the future, it is certain that neither of the parties, in the lifetime of Port, ever considered that the contract was consummated. Ho children were born to them, and, aside from the inferences to be drawn from their residing together, the only evidence of copula is in admissions of the criminal character of their cohabitation. The relatives of neither party ever regarded or treated them as married, and the uncle of appellant, and the mother of the deceased, at different times, threatened to prosecute them for living together in an open state of fornication. Appellant virtually admitted that she was guilty of this charge. She did not deny it, or pretend that she had supposed they were married, or that she had been deluded to act as she had, under representations that it would constitute them
The conduct of Port, in introducing appellant as, and calling her, his wife, when considered in connection with the other evidence, proves merely a desire to avoid the odium and danger to which they would have been exposed if the truth had been known, and hence does not impair the force of the other testimony, direct and conclusive as it is in its nature.
The decree of the court below must be affirmed.
Decree affirmed.