Polk County v. CopePolk County v. Cope
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Weaver
From January 1, 1909, to January 1, 1911, the defendant Cope was a duly elected and acting justice of the peace in Des Moines Township, Polk County, Iowa. His eodefendants in this action are sureties upon his official bond. This action was brought by the county, August 28, 1912, alleg*21ing that, during Cope’s said term of office, he collected as fees of that office taxed in civil cases brought in his court, the aggregate sum of $2,834.75, no part of which had by him been paid over or accounted for to the county, though demand therefor had been made. It was further alleged that, before the suit was brought, the board of supervisors of Polk County, acting under the authority vested in them by the statute, duly passed a resolution allowing the said Cope $500 a year for the expenses of his office for the period of said term, and, after allowing him the credit of $1,000 to which he thus became entitled, there was left due and owing by him to the plaintiff for the fees so collected, the sum of $1,834.75 and interest, for which judgment was demanded. Later, and during the pendency of this action, the board of supervisors attempted to rescind the resolution making such allowance for expenses, and thereupon plaintiff amended its petition and withdrew the credit therein acknowledged and demanded judgment for recovery of the entire amount of defendant’s collections. The defendants answered the petition, admitting the election of Cope as justice of the peace, his giving of the bond sued upon, and his service in that office for the time mentioned. They also admitted the allowance to Cope of $500 per year for the expenses of his office, and denied all other allegations not admitted, and denied the validity of the action of the board of supervisors in attempting to revoke the allowance made for expenses. There was a further plea of the statute of limitations, which appears to have been abandoned, and we shall not further notice it.
The issues were submitted to the court without a jury upon an agreed statement of facts. The stipulation concedes substantially every allegation of the petition, except the validity of the attempt of the board to rescind the allowance of office expenses; and, as the trial court held with the defendants upon this proposition and gave them credit therefor in computing’ the amount of indebtedness, and as plaintiff has not appealed therefrom, we may also pass this issue without *22further consideration. It is further conceded that Cope made proper report of the fees of his office in criminal cases and paid the proper amount over to the county treasurer, but that he made no report of the fees of his office in civil cases until April 1, 1912, at which time he reported to the board that the actual and reasonable expenses of his office for the term of two years were $2,402.76. The amount of fees which he collected and still retains is admitted to be as stated in the petition. There is no plea or suggestion in the answer alleging the invalidity of the law fixing the compensation of justices of the peace, nor any affirmative allegation of fact on which Cope bases any legal right or authority to retain the fees which he admits that he has collected. The trial court entered judgment for plaintiff for the full amount of plaintiff’s claim, after giving credit thereon for the sum of $1,000, as provided by the original resolution of the board of supervisors. From this judgment, the defendants appeal.
The statute governing the compensation of justices of the peace, so far as applicable to this case, is as follows:
Sec. 4600-a, Cope Supp., 1913. “Justices of the peace and constables in townships having a population of twenty thousand shall pay into the county treasury all criminal feés collected in each year. Justices of the peace and constables in townships having a population of under twenty thousand shall pay into the county treasury all fees collected each year in excess of the following sums: ... In townships having a population of twenty thousand or more, justices of the peace and constables shall receive in full compensation for their services performed in criminal cases during the year, the following sums which shall be paid quarterly out of the county treasury: In townships having a population of twenty-eight thousand or more, justices, fifteen hundred dollars; constables, twelve hundred dollars; in townships having a population of twenty thousand and under twenty-eight thousand, justices,, twelve hundred dollars; constables, one thousand dollars. Jus*23tices and constables in all townships having a population of twenty thousand and over shall retain such civil fees as may be allowed by the board of supervisors, not to exceed five hundred dollars per annum, for expenses of their offices actually incurred, and shall pay in to the county treasurer all the balance of the civil fees collected by them. ’ ’
Beading the pleadings and the admitted facts in the light of the statute, they would appeal to the ordinary mind as merely a roundabout method of confessing judgment, but counsel rise to the emergency and solemnly argue that the law “is contrary to the Constitution of the United States and to the Constitution of the state of Iowa in that: (1) The law is arbitrary, unreasonable and not of uniform operation. Article 1, Section 6, Constitution; Article 3, Section 30, Constitution. (2) The law is contrary to public policy. Article 5, Section 4, Constitution. (3) The legislature has delegated to .the board of supervisors its power to make a law. Article’ 3, Section 1, Constitution.”
*25
It is unnecessary to further pursue this discussion. The defense and the appeal are equally without merit, and the judgment of the district court is — Affirmed.
Evans, C. J., Deemer and Preston, JJ., concur.