Pogue v. GrubbsPogue v. Grubbs
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Holt
This appeal involves an election contest. Appellant, Pogue, and appellee, Grubbs, were candidates for the office of Constable in the Democratic Primary Election on August 12, 1958. The official election returns as properly certified showed that appellant received 257 votes and appellee 252. In apt time, appellee, Grubbs, filed a complaint in the Poinsett Circuit Court in which he alleged that he had received a majority of all legal votes cast and should be declared the nominee. Appellant answered denying appellee’s allegations and prayed that the official returns, as above indicated, be upheld. A trial resulted in a finding by the court that the correct result of the election showed that appellant, Pogue, had received 207 votes and appellee, Grubbs, 225 legal votes and declared appellee the nominee. From the judgment is this appeal. For reversal appellant says: (a) The burden of proof rested on appellee, the contestant, to show that he received a majority of the legal votes cast, (b) The integrity of the ballots was destroyed, and the court erred in considering the ballots to determine the result of the election, (c) Appellee failed to sustain the burden of proving that he received a majority of the legal votes cast.
Our rule is well established that in an election contest the official returns are prima facie correct and the burden is on the contestant (appellee here) to show to the contrary by affirmative proof. “The official returns of the election are quasi records, and are prima facie correct. The burden is upon the contestant to show by affirmative proof that they do not speak the truth. *
The record shows that after appellee had completed the introduction of all of his testimony, appellant filed a demurrer to appellee’s evidence which the court overruled. Whereupon appellant declined to plead further, or to offer any evidence, but elected to stand on his demurrer. The court then found from appellee’s evidence that appellee, Grubbs, had received 225 legal votes and the appellant, Pogue, 207, and declared Grubbs the nominee.
In a situation such as here presented, our long standing rule is settled that if we find any substantial evidence to support the judgment of the trial court, we must affirm it. We said in Werbe v. Holt, 217 Ark. 198, 229 S. W. 2d 225, “The question may arise either in equity cases, where the chancellor is the arbiter of the facts, or in’ cases tried at law without a jury, where also the trial judge decides all issues of fact. By the overwhelming weight of authority it is the trial court’s duty, in passing upon either a demurrer to the evidence or a motion for judgment in law cases tried without a jury, to give the evidence its strongest probative force in favor of the plaintiff and to rule against the plaintiff
“Appellant also says that the allegation in the complaint, the first quoted above, that many votes were cast and counted for appellee by persons who were not qualified
After examining all the evidence presented, which we do not attempt to analyze here, we have concluded that the trial court was warranted in refusing to hold that the integrity of all the ballots had been destroyed by alleged misconduct on the part of the election officials, and in proceeding to consider those legally cast in determining the result of the election. We hold that appellee has sustained the burden of proof that he received a majority of the legal votes cast.
Affirmed.